User: TwoBlocked, Location: Bradford County, PA
Asked on: Thursday, October 31, 2024 at 6:47 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:42 am EST
Question: Got a call out to a frack truck filling facility. Only one of 6 fairly new mag meters were working properly. One had a burnt card, two had RS-485 failure, and two were reading only half the flow. The two reading half flow is what I am wondering about. This is reused fracking water after going through weir tanks. It was suggested to me that the electrodes in the meters might be sludged up, giving a false reading. I'll try to contact the manufacturer tomorrow for recommendations.Anybody seen this sort of problem with mag meters? These are Isoil brand.
You're on the right track. Mag meter issues with "dirty" or "sludged" fluids are common, especially in the oil and gas industry where dealing with produced water, frack water, and process fluids is the norm. Here's a breakdown of potential causes for the half-flow reading and things to consider
Likely Causes for Half-Flow Reading (Assuming Wiring, Power Supply, and Initial Configuration are Correct):
1. Electrode Coating/Fouling (Most Likely)
Mechanism
Frack water (even after settling) can contain solids (sand, silt, scale, organic matter, precipitated salts, bacteria) that can deposit on the electrodes. This coating interferes with the sensor's ability to accurately measure the induced voltage, which is directly proportional to flow velocity. A reduced induced voltage will appear as reduced flow.
Why Half Flow? While it's hard to say exactly why half flow, the coating may be causing a consistent voltage drop that the meter interprets as half the actual velocity. It could be a complex interaction between the coating's resistance and the meter's signal processing. A complete short is going to cause a zero reading, a bad signal is going to cause a fluctuating reading, but a consistent, equal resistance between the electrodes and the fluid might cause the meter to think that half the current is flowing. Diagnosis
Visually inspect the electrodes (if possible without disrupting the process or compromising safety). If you have access, carefully remove one of the meters (if possible) and thoroughly inspect the electrodes for any visible buildup. Use a multimeter to measure the resistance between the electrodes. If the fluid is more conductive than the deposit, it could be a small fraction of the "real" resistance. Compare this resistance with a known good meter.2.
Partial Obstruction/Flow Profile Distortion
Mechanism
Debris (rags, large particulate) can partially obstruct the flow in the meter's flow tube. This changes the velocity profile, impacting the magnetic field interaction.
Why Half Flow? A partial blockage could reduce the average velocity seen by the meter by roughly half, although the actual flow rate might be higher. Also, the obstruction will distort the ideal flow profile, which mag meters rely on for accurate measurement. Diagnosis
While difficult without shutting down, consider the process: Are there any filters upstream that may have failed? Could something large have entered the line? Consider using ultrasonic flow measurement as a non-invasive diagnostic tool.3.
Meter Degradation
Mechanism
While these are relatively new meters, components can fail prematurely. The magnetic field strength can weaken over time. The signal processing electronics can drift or become damaged.
Why Half Flow? Internal calibration drift can manifest as a consistent error in the flow reading. A weakened magnetic field would reduce the induced voltage, leading to an underestimation of flow. Diagnosis
Compare the flow with another flow meter (especially a different technology) somewhere else in the system.
Other Considerations & Troubleshooting Steps
Grounding
Ensure proper grounding. Mag meters are very sensitive to electrical noise. Confirm the grounding straps and connections are clean and secure. Poor grounding can introduce stray currents that interfere with the induced voltage measurement.
Air Entrainment
Air bubbles in the fluid can scatter the magnetic field and disrupt the conductivity, leading to inaccurate readings. Are there any points in the system where air could be introduced (e.g., pump suction, leaky seals)?
Fluid Conductivity
Mag meters require a minimum conductivity. If the conductivity of the frack water is too low or fluctuating, the meter may not function accurately. Use a conductivity meter to test the water.
Meter Size/Installation
Were the meters properly sized for the flow rate range? Is there sufficient straight run of pipe upstream and downstream of the meters (typically 5-10 pipe diameters upstream, 3-5 downstream)? Insufficient straight run leads to swirling or turbulent flow, degrading accuracy.
Calibration
When was the last calibration performed on these meters? Calibration drift is a common issue, especially in harsh environments. (This is usually a factory or third-party service.)
Process Changes
Has anything changed in the frack water composition or treatment process since the meters were installed? Changes in conductivity, solids content, or temperature can affect the meter's performance.
RS-485 Issues
Since you're having RS-485 issues on some meters, electrical interference might be a systemic problem. Consider using shielded cable and isolating the RS-485 network.
Burned Card
The burned card is concerning. It points to a possible electrical surge, overvoltage, or component failure. Investigate the power supply and grounding system for any issues.
Steps to Take (Beyond Calling the Manufacturer)
Document EVERYTHING
Record meter serial numbers, readings, dates, and any observations. Take pictures of the installation.2.
Isolate Variables
Swap Meters (Carefully)
If possible (and safe), swap the meters reading half-flow with the working meter (if they are identical models/sizes and readily removable). Does the problem follow the meter? This helps determine if the issue is with the meter itself or the installation.
Verify Installation
Double-check the meter installation against the manufacturer's recommendations (straight run, orientation, grounding).3.
Cleaning (If Feasible)
If you can isolate a meter, carefully try cleaning the electrodes. Use a soft cloth and a mild cleaning solution (avoid harsh chemicals that could damage the electrodes). Rinse thoroughly.4.
Consider a Different Flow Meter Technology
If the mag meters continue to be problematic, consider alternative flow measurement technologies that might be more resistant to the effects of solids and coatings (e.g., ultrasonic, Coriolis).
Safety Note: Frack water can contain hazardous materials. Wear appropriate PPE (gloves, eye protection, etc.) when working with the equipment and fluid. Consult the SDS for the specific chemicals present in the water.Good luck! Let me know if you have any more questions. Flag for review