User: Tulsa Electrician, Location: Tulsa
Asked on: Friday, November 1, 2024 at 10:03 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:43 am EST
Question: I recently did a walk through in a building with a emergency generator. I noticed in the electrical rooms on each floor it was wrapped with wire ways.The emergency feeders and branch circuits occupied the same wire ways as normal power.I see this as a violation since a wire way is considered a raceway.I was told since it's in an electrical room it's ok.My question is. Emergency feeders and branch circuits in same wire ways with normal power a violation.
Yes, it is generally a violation of the National Electrical Code (NEC) to run emergency feeders and branch circuits in the same raceway (which includes wireways) as normal power circuits unless certain specific conditions are met. The rationale behind this separation is to maintain the reliability of the emergency system in the event of a fault in the normal power system.Here's a breakdown of the relevant NEC sections and why it's a problem: NEC 700.9(B) (Emergency System Wiring)
This section is the core of the issue. It requires that emergency system wiring be kept entirely independent of all other wiring, equipment, and raceways. This aims to prevent a fault or failure in the normal system from affecting the emergency system. It states: "Wiring of an emergency system shall be kept entirely independent of all other wiring, equipment, and raceways...".
"Entirely Independent" Interpretation
The key phrase is "entirely independent." Sharing a raceway, even in an electrical room, is generally not considered "entirely independent." If a fault occurs in the normal power conductors within the wireway, it could potentially damage or compromise the emergency conductors.
Exceptions to Separation
There are limited exceptions to the independent wiring requirement. These often involve specific situations and require very specific conditions to be met, such as:
700.9(B)(1): Transfer Switches
Emergency wiring is permitted to be in the same raceway or enclosure as normal wiring when it is connected to a transfer switch. This is a common exception.
700.9(B)(2): Exit or Egress Lighting
Emergency wiring is permitted to be in the same raceway or enclosure as normal wiring when it is connected to exit or egress lighting that is normally powered by the regular lighting.
700.9(B)(5): Fire Alarm
Emergency wiring is permitted to be in the same raceway or enclosure as fire alarm systems if they are monitored by a fire alarm system.
Definition of Raceway
A wireway is considered a raceway. NEC Article 100 defines a raceway as "An enclosed channel of metal or nonmetallic materials designed expressly for holding wires, cables, or busbars, with additional functions as permitted in this Code." Wireways clearly fit this definition.
Why the "Electrical Room" Argument Fails (Usually)
The fact that it's in an electrical room does not automatically make it compliant. The NEC's requirement for separation is about preventing electrical faults in the normal power system from impacting the emergency system. The location of the raceway (inside an electrical room) doesn't change the risk of such a fault.
In Summary
Unless a specific exception applies (like wiring within a listed transfer switch or specifically permitted egress lighting wiring as mentioned above), running emergency feeders and branch circuits in the same wireway as normal power circuits violates NEC 700.9(B). The electrical room location is not a valid justification for ignoring this requirement.
What to Do
Review the NEC
Carefully examine Article 700 of the NEC to understand all the requirements for emergency systems.2.
Document the Violation
Clearly document the installation, including photographs and written descriptions of the shared wireways.3.
Consult with an Electrical Engineer
Seek the opinion of a qualified electrical engineer. They can perform a detailed code review and recommend corrective actions.4.
Contact the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ)
The AHJ (typically a local building or electrical inspector) has the final say on code compliance. Present your findings and the electrical engineer's recommendations to the AHJ for their determination. Be prepared to make corrections as required.
Possible Corrective Actions
Separate Raceways
The most common solution is to install separate raceways (wireways) for the emergency and normal power circuits.
Re-route Wiring
In some cases, it may be possible to re-route the wiring to avoid sharing raceways.*
Meet Exception Requirements: If an applicable exception exists, ensure the installation fully meets all conditions outlined in the NEC.It is vital to get this resolved, as it affects the life safety of building occupants. Flag for review