User: MrMeAuggie, Location: Utah
Asked on: Friday, November 1, 2024 at 10:17 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:43 am EST
Question: Hey guys, I ran into an issue with an inspector where I was replacing the meter and relocating the distribution circuits to a new panel board. He “let it slide”, but said that LBs are subject to needing the pulling radius based on the conduit size, same as a junction/pull box would be. How does an LB have an UL listing if this is true. He took me to article 415 for pull boxes and said that in there it specifies LBs, but I can’t find anything on it, and 6 times the radius of the conduit would mean the LB would have to be massive, so I believe he’s wrong, but I’d like a Mike holt interpretation on the matter if we can because I do a lot of work in that inspectors area and used 2in conduit to get new SER’s into the house often.
Okay, this is a common point of confusion, and it's understandable why you're looking for clarification. Let's break down the code, the practical applications, and why the inspector's interpretation, while potentially well-intentioned, is likely incorrect for typical LB installations.
Key Code Sections & Interpretations Article 314 - Outlet, Device, Pull, and Junction Boxes; Conduit Bodies; Fittings; and Handhole Enclosures
This is the main article governing the installation of boxes and conduit bodies. Conduit bodies, in general, are covered in article 314.28 and 314.
29.
Article 314.28 - Pull and Junction Boxes and Conduit Bodies Containing Conductors of 4 AWG or Larger
This section deals with the minimum dimensions of pull boxes and conduit bodies where conductors of 4 AWG or larger are installed. This is where you'll find the famous "6 times the trade diameter" rule for straight pulls, and "8 times the trade diameter" rule for angle pulls. This rule applies for raceways such as conduit, which can be metallic such as EMT, IMC, RMC, or non-metallic such as PVC.
Article 314.28(A)(3): Conduit Bodies
In this section there is an exception for conduit bodies such as an LB. It states that when conductors are 4 AWG or larger enter in one side of the LB, and leave out the other, and the conductors containing splices, taps, or terminations. The minimum dimension must be no less than six times the trade diameter of the largest raceway.
Article 314.29 - Minimum Size
Conduit bodies, depending on use, must be large enough to meet the requirements of Chapter 3.
Article 314.16(A) - Standard Boxes
This is the standard box fill for boxes, conduit bodies and fittings, which means the volume of the box, conduit body or fitting must be large enough to accommodate the amount of conductors entering.
Article 314.17 - Conductors Entering Boxes, Conduit Bodies, or Fittings. This section basically says that conductors must have a wiring method, such as conduit, entering into the box, conduit body, or fitting, and be supported according to 314.17(C). Article 415 - This section is regarding Phase converters, it does not pertain to pull boxes, junction boxes, and conduit bodies. I believe he may have been mistaken on this article.Why the Inspector is Likely Incorrect (In Most Cases)
UL Listing
LBs are UL listed as conduit bodies. UL listing implies that they meet specific safety standards and are suitable for their intended use. The UL standard takes into account the bending radius requirements within the confines of the LB as designed. If an LB couldn't properly accommodate the bends required by the NEC within its intended use, it wouldn't be UL listed.2.
Intended Use
LBs are designed for short, directional changes in conduit runs, not for the same type of "pulling" that you'd do in a large junction box. The 6x or 8x diameter rule in 314.28 is intended for situations where you are pulling long lengths of wire through a box. With an LB, the wires are typically fished or manipulated into place, not subjected to the same pulling forces.3.
Practicality
Requiring a 2" LB to have a dimension equal to 12" (6 x 2") would make them impractically large for most applications. This is why the code recognizes the specific design and intended use of conduit bodies like LBs.
When the Inspector Might Have a Point (But Still Unlikely for Typical SER Installations)
Large Conductors and Difficult Pulls
If you were pulling very large conductors (e.g., 4/0 or larger) through a 2" LB, and you were experiencing extreme difficulty in making the pull, and you were damaging the conductor insulation in the process, then an inspector might argue that you're exceeding the LB's intended use and that the bend radius is too tight. However, even in these situations, the inspector would likely need to show that the LB is not suitable for the specific conductors being used according to the NEC.
Modifications or Damage
If the LB has been modified or damaged in a way that compromises its ability to provide a smooth bend, the inspector might have a legitimate concern.
Mike Holt Interpretation Summary
The 6x/8x diameter rule in 314.28 is primarily intended for pull boxes and junction boxes where pulling long lengths of wire is involved. LBs are UL listed and designed for short, directional changes, and their design takes into account the necessary bending radius for typical conductors. For typical installations using SER cable entering a house, the standard LB sizes are generally adequate, provided you're not forcing overly large conductors and damaging the insulation. The inspector's interpretation is likely incorrect unless you're dealing with unusually large conductors, difficult pulls, or a damaged LB.
Recommendations
Nicely but Firmly Ask for Clarification
Approach the inspector again and politely ask him to specifically point to the code section that requires LBs to meet the 6x/8x diameter rule in your specific installation*.2.
Document Everything
Keep records of the wire sizes you're using, the conduit sizes, and the LBs you're installing. Photos can also be helpful.3.
Consult with Another Inspector
If the inspector is adamant, consider getting a second opinion from another inspector or the head of the inspection department.4.
Manufacturer's Specifications: If you're still concerned, check the manufacturer's specifications for the LBs you're using. They may provide guidance on conductor size and bending radius.In most cases, you should be able to use standard-sized LBs for typical SER installations without running afoul of the NEC. The key is to avoid forcing conductors that are too large and to ensure that the LB is in good condition. Remember to always follow the manufacturer's installation instructions and local codes. Flag for review