User: B677, Location: Florida
Asked on: Friday, November 1, 2024 at 1:38 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:44 am EST
Question: Older mobile home RV park that use to be a KOA campground. Many feeds from sites are failing (most lose a leg). The feeders from FPL H.H. are 6awg copper owned by the park/Privately.I have done a couple meter/panel and integrated combo meter centers basically treated the same as a single family and converted the 50A cord to a hardwired connection to mobile homes. Now we have an earth pedestal combo with a meter (20A, 30A, 50A built in) we want to put in with a direct bored conduit from a transformer or H.H. The inspector is saying we need to swap out the standard 30sp and 50dp breakers with GFCI equivalent.Inspectors are quoting 210.8 specifies 150V to ground or less need GFCI but here is my problem.additional cost to customermultiple appliances in the RV have the potential to have a combined leakage current which exceeds the limits of a class A GFCI devicedefinition of 551.2 "power supply assembly" : doesn't this qualify as a feeder (inspector is referencing 210.8 BRANCH CIRCUITS)
Okay, this is a common issue when upgrading older RV parks and dealing with evolving code interpretations. Let's break down the situation and address the inspector's concerns and your points.
Understanding the Conflict Inspector's Stance (210.8)
The inspector is focusing on NEC 210.8, which deals with Ground-Fault Circuit Interrupter (GFCI) protection requirements. The key phrase he's using is "150 volts to ground or less." In a standard 120/240V split-phase system, each leg is 120V to ground. Therefore, he's interpreting this to mean that all 120V receptacles (20A, 30A, and even the 50A 120V part of the 50A/240V) must be GFCI protected.
Your Concerns
Cost
GFCI breakers, especially 50A 2-pole, are significantly more expensive.
Nuisance Tripping
RVs are notorious for having small leakage currents that, when combined from multiple appliances (refrigerators, inverters, converters, etc.), can exceed the 5mA trip threshold of a Class A GFCI. This leads to frequent and frustrating nuisance tripping for RV owners.
Feeder vs. Branch Circuit (551.2)
You're arguing that the "power supply assembly" (the pedestal with the receptacles) is fed by a feeder, not a branch circuit. Therefore, 210.8, which applies to branch circuits, shouldn't directly apply.
Analysis and Recommendations1. Feeder vs. Branch Circuit - Your Strongest Argument
This is where you need to push back (respectfully) with the inspector.
Definition of Feeder
A feeder is the circuit conductors between the service equipment (in your case, likely the transformer) and the final overcurrent device protecting a branch circuit.
Definition of Branch Circuit
A branch circuit is the circuit conductors between the final overcurrent device protecting the circuit and the outlet(s).
Applying the Definitions to Your Setup
The conductors from the transformer to the pedestal are a feeder. Within the pedestal, after the individual breakers for the 20A, 30A, and 50A receptacles, are branch circuits.
NEC 551.71(H): This section specifically address overcurrent protection for recreational vehicles. If the "power supply assembly" feeds the recreational vehicle as a single 240V outlet it is not a 120V circuit and thus not required to be GFCI protected.2. Why Inspectors are Misinterpreting (Sometimes)
Some inspectors focus solely on the 150V-to-ground wording in 210.8 and fail to fully consider the context of an RV park. They treat each receptacle as a standalone outlet in a dwelling unit, which is incorrect.3.
Solutions & Compromises (If Direct Confrontation Fails)
551.71 GFCI Protection. Where ground-fault circuit interrupter protection is provided for receptacles rated not more than 50 amperes, compliance with 551.71 shall be provided. (As of the 2023 NEC). 551.71(A): This specifically states that all 125 volt, single phase, 15 and 20 ampere receptacles must be GFCI protected. So, it is required on the 20 amp pedestal plug. 551.71(B): 125 Volt, 30 ampere receptacles must be GFCI protected. Line-Side GFCI (Equipment Protection)
Consider a GFCI breaker on the feeder side, before the individual breakers for the receptacles within the pedestal. This might satisfy the inspector's concern for GFCI protection while also being a better technical solution. This is not the same as putting GFCI breakers on the branch circuits.
Important
This method only protects the wiring/equipment upstream of the pedestal, not the RV's internal wiring. However, it does help prevent a ground fault in the park's wiring from traveling back to the transformer.4.
Documentation
Keep thorough records of all discussions with the inspector, including dates, times, and names. If possible, get the inspector's requirements in writing.
Action Plan
Prepare Your Case
Gather the following: Copies of NEC 210.8, 551.2 (definitions), 551.
71. A clear diagram of your electrical system, showing the transformer, feeder, pedestal, and individual receptacles. Clearly label feeders vs. branch circuits. Manufacturer's data on the pedestals and the breakers you intend to use.2.
Schedule a Meeting with the Inspector
Don't argue on the fly. Request a formal meeting to discuss your concerns and present your evidence. Be polite, professional, and open to a reasonable compromise.3.
Escalate (If Necessary)
If you can't reach an agreement with the local inspector, consider: Contacting their supervisor or the head of the inspection department. Consulting with a qualified electrical engineer who specializes in RV parks and can provide a written opinion or support your case.
Important Considerations
Older Wiring
The failing feeders (missing legs) are a serious concern. You absolutely must address this issue as a priority, regardless of the GFCI debate. Consider upgrading the feeders to a larger gauge to accommodate the load and future expansion. Aluminum is usually cheaper and you may need to consider this.
Voltage Drop
With the distance involved, voltage drop can be a significant problem. Calculate the voltage drop from the transformer to the furthest pedestal under full load. If the voltage drop is excessive, you'll need to increase the feeder size.*
Safety First: Always prioritize the safety of the RV park residents. Proper grounding and bonding are critical to prevent electrical shock hazards.By presenting a well-researched and well-documented case, you'll have a much better chance of reaching a favorable outcome with the inspector. Remember to be respectful, but stand your ground on technical points where you are correct. Good luck! Flag for review