Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Charged to move a circuit breaker box?

User: JustAGuyNamedRob, Location: New York

Asked on: Friday, November 1, 2024 at 3:23 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:44 am EST

Question: Hello,I'm not sure if this should be posted here but I am looking for guidance. I recently had to have a fuse box changed to a breaker box in my co-op. The co-op secured a deal with an electric company to do the jobs. It was a set price for installation and a higher price if the box had to be moved to another location. The contract stated that if the box needed to be moved, the fuse box would remain as a splice box and the new panel would be relocated approximately 6 feet away. Instead, they ripped out the fuse box panel and put the breaker panel on the other side of the wall using the existing wiring they took out from the fuse box. They still want to charge me the extra for moving the box though. I obviously intend to pay the price for installation but I don't believe I should pay the extra for moving the box. There was no wiring added, they did not use a splice box and because they removed the fuse box I now have to also pay to repair the hole made from that. Charging the extra to move the box would have meant using the fuse box as a splice box. Would you guys normally charge extra for moving the box in a job like that? I tried to attach pictures for reference. One is where they ripped the fuse box out of the wall and the other is where they put the new breaker box on the other side. Thank you!https://imgur.com/a/YkOAuyv

Okay, this is definitely a situation where you need to stand your ground and advocate for yourself. Here's a breakdown of why you're right to question the additional charge, and how to approach the situation

Why the Additional Charge is Questionable:
Breach of Contract

The contract is the most important thing here. It explicitly states that if the box is moved, the
fuse box would remain as a splice box. This didn't happen. They completely removed the fuse box. They did not uphold the contract's terms.

No New Wiring

You specifically mention that no new wiring was added. Relocating a panel with new wiring is significantly more labor-intensive and justifies a higher cost. Simply running existing wires through a wall to a panel on the other side, without extending or adding wires, is not the same.

Definition of "Moving the Box"

The intent of "moving the box" in the contract likely referred to a situation where the new panel had to be located significantly further away, requiring more extensive wiring and labor. Simply placing it on the other side of the wall, using the existing wiring paths, is arguably
not what was envisioned by the term.

Unexpected Additional Cost

You now have to pay to repair the hole where the old fuse box was. The contract indicated it would remain there as a splice box.

How to Approach the Situation


Review the Contract

Review the contract again. Pay close attention to the exact wording regarding the "move" fee, what it includes, and any stipulations about the old fuse box.2.

Document Everything



Photos

You already have photos, which is great. Make sure they are date-stamped and clearly show the before (fuse box) and after (breaker box on the other side) situation.


Communications

Keep a record of all communication (emails, texts, phone call logs) with the electric company and the co-op.

Original Quote

Have the original quote on hand.3.

Communicate Your Concerns in Writing (Email or Letter)

This is crucial. A phone call leaves no paper trail. Clearly and politely explain:
You are happy to pay the base installation price as agreed upon. You are disputing the "move" fee because the work performed does not align with the contract's description of moving the box. The contract stated the existing fuse box would act as a splice box. The existing fuse box was not used as a splice box. The existing fuse box was removed, resulting in an unanticipated cost to repair the resulting hole. Clearly state that you believe the situation does not warrant the extra charge. You expect them to honor the original agreement for standard installation. Give them a reasonable deadline to respond (e.g., 5-7 business days).

Example Email Excerpt

"Dear [Contact Person],I am writing to express my concern regarding the invoice for the electrical panel upgrade performed on [Date]. While I am satisfied with the panel replacement itself, I am disputing the additional charge for "moving the box."As per the contract, if the panel was to be moved, the original fuse box was to remain as a splice box, which did not occur. No new wiring was installed.Given these circumstances, I do not believe the additional "move" fee is warranted. I am happy to pay the agreed-upon base installation price.I look forward to your prompt response and resolution to this matter.Sincerely,[Your Name]"4.

Involve the Co-op (if necessary)

If the electric company is unresponsive or unwilling to negotiate, escalate the issue to the co-op's management or board. Since they secured the deal, they have a vested interest in ensuring their residents are treated fairly. Remind the co-op that you are a shareholder/member and expect their support in resolving this issue.5.

Get a Second Opinion (Maybe)

If you're unsure about the technical aspects, consider getting a brief consultation with another licensed electrician. Ask them if what was done truly constitutes a "move" that would justify the extra charge, given the contract's terms. This will give you more ammunition in your argument.6.

Be Prepared to Negotiate

They may not completely back down, but be ready to negotiate a compromise. Perhaps you can agree on a price somewhere in between the base price and the full "move" price.7.

If All Else Fails, Consider These Options



Small Claims Court

This is a last resort, but if the amount in dispute is significant, it may be worth pursuing. Be sure to document everything meticulously.


File a Complaint with the Better Business Bureau (BBB)

While not legally binding, a BBB complaint can sometimes prompt a company to resolve an issue to maintain a good reputation.

Leave Online Reviews

Honest, factual reviews can influence other potential customers and may incentivize the company to address your concerns.

Key Points to Emphasize



Breach of Contract

They didn't follow the terms of the contract regarding the splice box.

Lack of Added Labor

The work involved was significantly less extensive than what would typically justify a "move" fee,
especially given that no new wiring was involved.

The Repair Cost

You now have an unforeseen expense for repairing the wall that wouldn't have existed had they followed the contract.

Important Considerations



Professionalism

Remain calm and professional in all your communications. Being angry or accusatory will likely be counterproductive.


Documentation is Key

You can't overemphasize the importance of having all the facts and documents to back up your claims.*

Know Your Rights:
Familiarize yourself with your rights as a consumer in your state.You are absolutely right to question this charge. The electric company's actions don't seem to align with the contract's intent or the actual work performed. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question