Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Separation Distance Between Intrinsically Safe Circuits and Non-IS

User: cowski, Location: New York

Asked on: Friday, November 1, 2024 at 3:37 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:44 am EST

Question: Is 2 inches all that's required for separation between intrinsically safe and non-intrinsically safe wiring and terminal blocks?As far as NEC, it seems to be 2" as described by 504.30(A)(1) and (2).The current version of UL698 seems to list 2". I have screenshots from the Sept 14th 2012 version of UL698A that shows 5" required. The revision notes on UL's website seem to have crossed out 8" and replaced it with 2". The panel builder I'm talking with thinks it's 4"...

You're on the right track, and this is a tricky area where codes and standards can sometimes conflict or update differently. Let's break it down: NEC (NFPA 70)

You are correct. NEC 504.30(A)(1) and (2) specify a
minimum separation of

2 inches
between intrinsically safe (IS) circuits and non-IS circuits. This is often measured "air gap" between the closest point of one circuit to the closest point of the other. NEC article 504 is the primary reference for IS installations in the US. UL698

This is where it gets complicated. UL698 is a product standard that applies to specific intrinsically safe equipment or systems (like control panels). It verifies that the product meets specific safety requirements related to intrinsic safety. While UL standards often align with the NEC, they can sometimes have more stringent requirements.

Historical Context (UL698A 2012)

You're also correct about your historical observations with UL698A. Earlier versions of UL698 and UL698A
did have significantly larger separation distances, including the 5" and even 8" distances you mention. These stricter requirements were often in place to provide a larger safety margin.

Current UL698

The current versions of UL698 and UL698A, in alignment with IEC 60079-11 and updates to the NEC, have generally reduced the required separation distances. The reference to crossing out 8" and replacing it with 2" is a valid observation.

Why the Confusion?
1. Outdated Information

Your panel builder might be relying on outdated information or experience with older versions of UL698. It is
critical to verify which edition of the standard they're using.2.

Manufacturer's Instructions

Some intrinsically safe equipment manufacturers might specify
larger separation distances in their installation instructions. These instructions always supersede general code requirements. Always prioritize the manufacturer's instructions for the specific equipment you are using.3.

Subjectivity and Interpretation

The interpretation of "intrinsically safe" and "non-intrinsically safe" can sometimes be subjective. A qualified expert might identify specific circuits as requiring greater separation.

Recommendations
1. Clarify the Relevant Standards

The most important step is to clearly identify which version of UL698 (or UL698A, if applicable) applies to your specific situation. Look for the date or revision number on the product's certification or documentation.2.

Consult the Latest UL Standard

Obtain the current version of UL698 (or UL698A) and carefully review the section on separation distances.3.

Manufacturer's Instructions are King



Always follow the manufacturer's instructions for the specific intrinsically safe equipment you're installing.
If the manufacturer requires a separation distance greater than what's specified in the NEC or UL, you
must adhere to the manufacturer's requirement.4. Consult with a Qualified Expert

It is strongly recommended that you consult with a qualified expert in intrinsically safe system design and installation. This expert can help you interpret the relevant codes, standards, and manufacturer's instructions, and ensure that your installation meets all applicable requirements. This person should be familiar with the application of NEC 504, and either UL698 or IEC 60079-14.5.

Documentation

Keep detailed records of all decisions made regarding separation distances, including references to the specific codes, standards, and manufacturer's instructions used to justify those decisions.

In summary:
While the NEC generally requires 2 inches of separation,
always* check the manufacturer's instructions for the specific IS equipment being used, and consult with a qualified expert to ensure compliance. Make sure you are working with the most current version of any applicable UL standards, as requirements can change. Your panel builder may need to update their information. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question