Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Unventilated concrete trough

User: Jc.Sea, Location: USA/CAN

Asked on: Friday, November 1, 2024 at 8:00 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:44 am EST

Question: My client is interested in removing ventilation and reducing the wire size within a concrete trench or trough.Could it be confirmed whether the NEC (or California CEC) permits the installation of6 sets of 4 parallel 3c-2/0+G XHHW conductors (480V, 3-phase, 140A FLA continuous load) in a triangular configuration, with 2.15 OD spacing, placed on racks within an unventilated concrete trough(50ft length, 5 feet in width and 4 feet interior depth)?I felt the heat in this trough already, but can I go even with a smaller wire?Or NEC does not allow it to be non-ventilated.NEC 392.80(2)— is this the correct section to reference? since this is rack mounted, or should another part of the code be considered?Thank you all.

Okay, let's break down this problem and see what the NEC (and CEC) says about your client's proposal. This is a complex situation with multiple factors to consider.

Core Concerns and Potential Problems



Ampacity Derating

The primary concern is heat buildup due to the large number of conductors in a confined, unventilated space. This will significantly reduce the ampacity of the conductors, potentially leading to overheating and failure.


Conductor Size

Reducing wire size to save costs, while pushing the ampacity limits, is almost always a bad idea in this scenario. The current proposal is already likely problematic.

Continuous Load

The 140A continuous load
severely limits your options. NEC requires conductors to be rated for 125% of the continuous load (140A 1.25 = 175A).

Accessibility and Maintenance

While not a code violation in itself, a densely packed, hot trough makes future maintenance and troubleshooting very difficult.

NEC and CEC Considerations


NEC Article 310: Conductors for General Wiring
This is the starting point. You MUST determine the allowable ampacity of a 2/0 XHHW conductor in free air (typically around 175A-195A depending on the temperature rating and NEC table). This is your baseline before any derating. NEC 310.15(B)(3)(a) Adjustment factors. - Number of Current-Carrying Conductors in a Raceway or Cable or Earth (Direct Burial). This is your BIGGEST challenge. You have 6 sets of 3-phase conductors, which is 18 current-carrying conductors. This requires significant ampacity derating. NEC 310.15(B)(2) Ambient Temperature Correction Factors. - Concrete trenches can get HOT, especially in California. You need to account for the maximum expected ambient temperature in the trough. The table gives correction factors to reduce the ampacity.2. NEC Article 392: Cable Trays NEC 392.80(A): Ampacity of Cables and Conductors in Cable Trays. This section does apply even if you're using racks within a concrete trough. The trough is effectively acting as a large, enclosed cable tray. NEC 392.80(A)(2): Multiconductor Cables. This section is relevant if the XHHW conductors are bundled together and treated as a multiconductor cable assembly. NEC 392.22(B): Ampacity of Cables and Conductors. You will be applying the adjustment factors from NEC 310.15.
3. NEC Article 314: Junction Boxes, Pull Boxes, and Handhole Enclosures
NEC 314.28(C): Conductor Bending Radius. Ensure you have adequate space for the conductor bending radius within the trough, especially at entry and exit points.4. California Electrical Code (CEC)

The CEC generally follows the NEC, but California can have amendments or additions. Always check the latest CEC for any specific California requirements that might be more stringent. Pay close attention to any sections related to conductor ampacity and derating in enclosed spaces.

Analysis and Recommendation


Derating is Critical

With 18 current-carrying conductors, the ampacity derating factors will be SEVERE. Expect a significant reduction (possibly 50% or more) in the allowable ampacity of the 2/0 conductors.2.

Calculate Ampacity

Start with the free-air ampacity of 2/0 XHHW (based on temperature rating). Apply the ambient temperature correction factor (based on estimated trough temperature). Apply the adjustment factor from NEC 310.15(B)(3)(a) (based on 18 current-carrying conductors). The resulting ampacity MUST be greater than 175A (125% of the 140A continuous load).3.

Likely Unacceptable

I highly doubt that a 2/0 conductor, even with XHHW insulation, will be able to carry 175A in this configuration after all the derating factors are applied.4.

Larger Conductors Required

You will almost certainly need to use larger conductors, possibly even larger than what's currently being used.5.

Ventilation is Strongly Recommended

While the NEC doesn't
explicitly mandate ventilation in a concrete trough (like it might in some other enclosures), providing ventilation is a VERY good idea. It will: Reduce the ambient temperature, improving conductor ampacity. Increase the long-term reliability of the system. Make future maintenance easier.6.

Alternative Solutions



Increase Trough Size

A larger trough will provide more space for heat dissipation.


Forced-Air Cooling

Install fans to force air circulation through the trough.

Separate Conduits

Instead of racks, consider running each set of conductors in its own conduit. This can help with heat dissipation and may reduce the need for as much derating.


Fiber Optic Solutions
: For data transfer, consider fiber.7. Documentation is Essential

Regardless of the chosen solution, you MUST: Document all calculations, including ampacity derating factors, ambient temperature assumptions, and conductor sizes. Provide this documentation to the client and the local electrical inspector.* Include a clear warning label on the trough indicating the conductor ampacity limitations and any ventilation requirements.

In Conclusion

Your client's proposal to reduce wire size and eliminate ventilation in the concrete trough is HIGHLY problematic and likely violates the NEC and CEC. You need to perform thorough ampacity calculations, considering all derating factors, and demonstrate that the chosen conductor size can safely carry the continuous load. Strongly recommend increasing wire size, providing ventilation, or exploring alternative wiring methods.

Consult with a qualified electrical engineer and the local electrical inspector to ensure code compliance and a safe, reliable installation.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question