User: Alwayslearningelec, Location: NJ
Asked on: Saturday, November 2, 2024 at 5:52 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:45 am EST
Question: Guys, if these fixtures( the 4' ones) were recessed in a drop ceiling but RGS had to be used on the job would it be possible or allowed to used fixtures whips( say under 6') out of the fixture to a box nearby and the RGS would enter there or would you probably/have to pipe right into the fixture? Fixtures are being fed with (2) line voltage wires and (2) 0-10v for most part? Yes there are two independent raceways, one for norm and one for EM. Thanks
Okay, let's break down the situation with RGS (Rigid Galvanized Steel conduit) and recessed fixtures in a drop ceiling, considering your requirements for normal and emergency circuits with 0-10V dimming.
Understanding the Challenges RGS Rigidity
RGS is, by its nature, rigid. It's not easily bent or manipulated in tight spaces, especially above a drop ceiling. This creates challenges in connecting directly to recessed fixtures, which often have limited space.
Limited Space Above Drop Ceiling
Drop ceilings rarely offer a ton of room above the grid. This makes maneuvering and connecting rigid conduit difficult.
Fixture Design
Recessed fixtures are designed for specific types of connections, often expecting flexible conduit or flexible wiring.
NEC Requirements
The National Electrical Code (NEC) dictates how electrical installations must be done safely and correctly. You need to meet these requirements.
Analysis of the Options1. Piping RGS Directly into the Fixture
Pros
Potentially more secure mechanical connection (if properly done).
Cons
Extremely Difficult
Physically getting the RGS aligned and connected to the fixture within the tight space of a drop ceiling is going to be very challenging. You'll likely need specialized fittings and a lot of patience.
Fixture Listing
Most recessed fixtures are not listed for direct RGS connection. Check the fixture's UL listing. If it's not listed for RGS, you're violating the NEC.
Vibration/Movement
RGS, being rigid, transmits vibrations easily. If there's any movement in the building, it could put stress on the fixture and the RGS connection.
Cost
More labor hours due to difficulty.2.
Using Fixture Whips (Flexible Conduit) to a Junction Box with RGS
Pros
Easier Installation
This approach allows for much easier connection to the fixture. The flex provides the necessary flexibility to work within the tight space.
Code Compliance
If done correctly, this can be NEC-compliant.
Reduced Stress on Fixture
The flexible conduit isolates the fixture from the rigidity and vibration of the RGS system.
Standard Practice
This is a very common and accepted method for connecting recessed fixtures.
Cons
Cost
Adds the cost of a JB box, fittings, and labor to wire box
Additional Connection Point
It adds an extra connection point (in the junction box), which needs to be properly made and maintained.
Conduit Fill Considerations
Make sure the flexible conduit has sufficient capacity for all the wires (normal, emergency, dimming).
Code Considerations (NEC - Consult the Latest Edition) 300.11(A) Securely Fastened
Raceways, cable assemblies, boxes, cabinets, and fittings shall be securely fastened in place. Support wires that do not provide secure support shall not be permitted as the sole support.
300.11(B) Fire-Rated Assemblies
(If applicable) Where electrical equipment is installed in fire-resistant-rated walls, floors, or ceilings, the fire resistance rating shall not be reduced.
300.22(C) Other Spaces Used for Environmental Air (Plenums)
This is critical! If the space above the drop ceiling is used for environmental air (a plenum), you must use plenum-rated flexible metal conduit (FMC) and wiring (CMP or other plenum-rated cables). Regular FMC and THHN/THWN wiring are not allowed in plenums.
314.16 Box Fill Calculations
Ensure your junction box is sized correctly to accommodate all the conductors, devices, and fittings.
348.30 Securing and Supporting
Flexible metal conduit (FMC) must be properly secured and supported according to NEC requirements, based on its size and application. (See the NEC for specific distances.)
410.64 Luminaires as Raceways
Luminaires (fixtures) cannot be used as a raceway for circuit conductors unless they are specifically listed and marked for that purpose.
725 (Class 2 and Class 3 Remote-Control, Signaling, and Power-Limited Circuits)
The 0-10V dimming circuits likely fall under this article. Ensure proper separation and wiring methods are followed. (Though not strictly Class 2, the principles apply.)
300.3(C) Conductors of Different Systems
"Conductors of alternating-current or direct-current circuits rated 1,000 volts or less...shall be permitted to occupy the same equipment wiring enclosure, cable, or raceway." This generally allows your normal and emergency circuits to share a junction box, but they MUST be properly insulated for the highest voltage present. Your 0-10V dimming wires are low voltage, but they're still part of the overall system.
Emergency Lighting Circuits. Emergency circuits must be kept entirely independent of all other wiring and equipment.
Recommended Approach1. Confirm Plenum Rating (Crucial!) Before you do anything, determine if the space above the drop ceiling is a plenum. This will dictate the type of flexible conduit and wiring you can use.2. Install Junction Box
Mount an appropriately sized metal junction box securely to the building structure near each fixture location. Use appropriate RGS connectors to connect the RGS conduit to the junction box.3.
Use Flexible Conduit (Fixture Whip)
Run a length of flexible metal conduit (FMC) or liquidtight flexible metal conduit (LFMC), properly sized, from the junction box to the fixture. If it's a plenum, use plenum-rated FMC (Greenfield) and plenum-rated wiring. Keep the flex length as short as possible, but long enough to allow for fixture maintenance.4.
Wiring
Pull the appropriate conductors (THHN/THWN or plenum-rated if required) through the RGS and the flexible conduit to the junction box and fixture. Connect the line voltage wires (normal and emergency) and the 0-10V dimming wires within the junction box and to the fixture, following all NEC requirements.
Segregation
If running separate emergency circuits, the emergency circuit must be kept independent of the other circuits.
Grounding. Ensure proper grounding to the fixtures and junction boxes.5. Secure and Support
Securely fasten the flexible conduit to both the junction box and the fixture using appropriate connectors. Support the flexible conduit per NEC guidelines (typically within 12 inches of the box and every 4.5 feet).
6.
Inspection
Call for inspection to ensure your installation meets all applicable codes.
Important Considerations Local Codes
Always check with your local electrical inspector for any local amendments or interpretations of the NEC.
Fixture Instructions
Always follow the fixture manufacturer's instructions.*
Qualified Electrician
This type of work should be performed by a licensed and qualified electrician who understands the NEC and local codes.
In summary, using fixture whips with RGS entering a junction box is generally the best approach for recessed fixtures in a drop ceiling when RGS is required. It provides a balance of code compliance, ease of installation, and protection for the fixture. Make sure to follow all applicable codes and use appropriate materials. Flag for review