Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Maximum circuit length

User: M.ABDULLATIEF, Location: Egypt

Asked on: Saturday, November 2, 2024 at 7:00 am EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:45 am EST

Question: I have a project which has all branch circuit fed from MCCB, how to calculate the maximum length for the circuits to be protected with the circuit breaker

Calculating the maximum length for a branch circuit protected by a Molded Case Circuit Breaker (MCCB) involves considering voltage drop, conductor ampacity, and overcurrent protection characteristics. Here's a breakdown of the process

1. Identify Key Factors:
Voltage Drop (VD)

The permissible voltage drop is usually the limiting factor. Typical recommended values are:


Power Circuits

3% VD (from the source to the furthest point)

Lighting Circuits

3% VD (from the source to the furthest point)


Combined Power and Lighting

5% VD total (split appropriately, often 3% for power and 2% for lighting)

Conductor Ampacity

The conductor must be able to safely carry the maximum anticipated load current, considering derating factors.


Overcurrent Protection

The MCCB must be able to protect the conductor from overloads and short circuits. This involves both the instantaneous trip (magnetic trip) and the thermal overload trip characteristics.

Source Voltage

The nominal voltage of the power system (e.g., 480V, 208V, 120V).


Load Current (I)

The maximum expected current that the circuit will draw. This must include any motor starting currents or other intermittent loads.

Conductor Material and Type

Copper or aluminum? Insulation type (THHN, THW, etc.) affects ampacity.


Conduit Material

Steel or aluminum conduit can affect the conductor impedance at higher frequencies.

Installation Method

Conduit, cable tray, direct burial, etc., affects ampacity derating.


Ambient Temperature

Higher temperatures derate conductor ampacity.

Frequency

System frequency (50 Hz or 60 Hz) affects impedance calculations, but is usually a minor factor.


MCCB Trip Curve

The instantaneous trip setting of the MCCB is important for short-circuit protection and can influence the maximum permissible length.

2. Calculate Voltage Drop



Voltage Drop Formulas

There are several formulas for calculating voltage drop. Here are two common ones, and some considerations:


Simplified Single-Phase/DC Formula

VD = (2  K  I  L) / CM
Where: VD = Voltage drop (in volts) K = Conductor constant (resistance per foot per circular mil. Use appropriate values depending on conductor temperature. Copper is approx. 12.9 ohms-CM/ft at 75°C, Aluminum is approx. 21.2 ohms-CM/ft at 75°C.) I = Load current (in amps) L = One-way length of the conductor (in feet) CM = Circular mils of the conductor (from wire size tables, e.g. AWG chart)Solve for L:
L = (VD  CM) / (2  K  I)


Three-Phase Formula

VD = (√3  K  I  L) / CM  (for line-to-line voltage)VD = (2  K  I  L) / CM  (for line-to-neutral voltage)
Solve for L (Line to Line):
L = (VD  CM) / (√3  K  I)
Solve for L (Line to Neutral):
L = (VD  CM) / (2  K  I)


Impedance Method (More Accurate, Especially for Longer Runs)

This method considers both resistance (R) and reactance (X) of the conductor. This is particularly important for longer runs where reactance becomes significant.


Single Phase

`VD = 2 I Z L/1000`

Three Phase

`VD = √3 I Z L/1000`Where: `VD` = Voltage drop (line-to-neutral) `I` = Load current (amps) `Z` = Impedance (ohms/1000 ft) (Z = √(R² + X²), where R is resistance and X is reactance. Obtain R and X values from conductor manufacturers or tables such as those in the IEEE Red Book or other resources. Reactance becomes more significant with larger conductors and longer runs.) `L` = One-way length (feet)Solve for L (single phase):
L = (VD  1000) / (2  I  Z)
Solve for L (three phase):
L = (VD  1000) / (√3  I  Z)


Choosing the right impedance tables

Be sure to choose values that match the conductor material, insulation type, temperature rating, and installation method (e.g., in steel conduit).

Iterative Approach

Since you're trying to find the
maximum length, you'll likely need to iterate:1.

Assume a conductor size.
Start with a size based on the load current and applicable ampacity tables (NEC Table 310.16 or similar). Remember to apply derating factors.
2. Calculate VD. Use the appropriate voltage drop formula, based on your system.3. Compare VD to the allowable VD. If the calculated VD exceeds the allowable limit, you'll need to
increase the conductor size and recalculate. If the VD is much lower than the allowable limit, you might decrease the conductor size and recalculate, to optimize costs.4. Repeat steps 2 and 3 until the calculated voltage drop is close to, but does not exceed, the allowable voltage drop.3. Conductor Ampacity and Derating



Ampacity Tables

Use appropriate ampacity tables (NEC Table 310.16 is a common reference). These tables provide the allowable ampacity for conductors based on insulation type and temperature rating.

Derating Factors

Apply derating factors for the following:


Ambient Temperature

If the ambient temperature is higher than the table's reference temperature (typically 30°C or 86°F), you must derate the ampacity.

Number of Conductors in a Raceway

If multiple current-carrying conductors are bundled together in a raceway or cable, their heat can affect each other, requiring derating. (NEC Table 310.15(C)(1)).


Conduit Fill

Excessive conduit fill can also lead to heat buildup.

Final Conductor Selection

Ensure that the conductor's derated ampacity is greater than or equal to the maximum load current
plus any applicable safety factors.

4. Overcurrent Protection (MCCB)



Conductor Protection

The MCCB must protect the conductor from both overloads and short circuits.

Overload Protection

The MCCB's thermal trip characteristic must be coordinated with the conductor ampacity. The MCCB's continuous current rating should not exceed the conductor's ampacity after derating. (NEC 240.4(B) provides rules about "next higher standard overcurrent device" in some situations, but it's best to avoid relying on this as much as possible and size the breaker appropriately)


Short-Circuit Protection

The MCCB's instantaneous trip (magnetic trip) setting is critical for short-circuit protection. The MCCB must trip quickly enough to prevent damage to the conductor during a short circuit. This requires checking that the available short circuit current at the end of the circuit is sufficient to activate the instantaneous trip of the breaker.

Available Short-Circuit Current (Isc)

The Isc at the
load (end of the circuit) must be high enough to activate the MCCB's instantaneous trip. The longer the circuit, the lower the Isc will be due to impedance.

Determining Available Fault Current

This requires a short-circuit study, which can be done manually (using point-to-point calculations) or with specialized software (SKM PowerTools, ETAP, EasyPower, etc.). The study will determine the available fault current at the load end, taking into account the impedance of the conductors, transformers, and source impedance.

MCCB Trip Curve Verification

Compare the calculated available fault current at the load end to the MCCB's trip curve. The available fault current must be high enough to ensure that the MCCB will trip instantaneously. If the fault current is too low, you will need to reduce the circuit length or increase the conductor size to lower the impedance and increase the available fault current.

5. Putting It All Together (Example)

Let's say you have a 480V, 3-phase circuit feeding a motor with a full-load current of 30 amps. The permissible voltage drop is 3%. You're using copper THHN conductors in steel conduit, operating at an ambient temperature of 30°C, and have 3 current carrying conductors in the conduit.1.

Allowable Voltage Drop

3% of 480V = 14.4V.
2.


Assume Conductor Size

Start with #10 AWG THHN (Ampacity = 30 amps at 75C, per NEC 310.16). Since the load current is 30 amps, we must apply a breaker sized at 30A. The #10 AWG conductor is sufficient in terms of ampacity.
3.


Calculate Voltage Drop (Simplified)

CM for #10 AWG = 10380 VD = (√3 12.9 30 L) / 10380 L = (14.4 10380) / (√3 12.9 30) = 217 feet (approximately).4.

Calculate Voltage Drop (Impedance Method)

Let's assume a run of 217 feet of #10AWG in steel conduit. Using online tables, the impedance of #10AWG in steel conduit at 60Hz is 2.09 ohms per 1000 ft. VD = √3 30 2.09 (217/1000) = 23.67 V.Since 23.67V is much greater than the allowable 14.4V, we need to increase the conductor size. This is not uncommon, as the simplified method is just an approximation.
5.


Increase Conductor Size

Increase conductor size to #6 AWG (Ampacity = 55 amps). Using online tables, the impedance of #6AWG in steel conduit at 60Hz is 0.785 ohms per 1000 ft. VD = √3 30 0.785 (217/1000) = 8.87 V.Since 8.87 is less than 14.4V, we can further increase length. L = (14.4 1000) / (√3 30 0.785) = 354 feet.
6.


Check MCCB Trip Curve

Now we need to check if the MCCB will trip instantaneously, given the available fault current at 354 feet. This requires a full fault study, or calculating the impedance. If a point to point calculation results in an available fault current of 1500A, and the MCCB has a trip curve with an instantaneous setting of 10x, that gives a trip current of 300A. Since 1500A is greater than 300A, then the MCCB will trip quickly enough to prevent damage to the conductor during a short circuit. If a point to point calculation results in an available fault current of 200A, and the MCCB has a trip curve with an instantaneous setting of 10x, that gives a trip current of 300A. Since 200A is less than 300A, then the MCCB will not trip instantaneously. That means we need to reduce the length, to reduce the total impedance of the conductor.As you can see, the available fault current is highly dependent on the source impedance, conductor size, and length. It is important to ensure that the MCCB has the appropriate setting to protect the equipment and conductors, in order to prevent a fire.7.

Conclusion

Iterate conductor size, voltage drop calculations, and fault current, until all requirements are met. This typically requires specialized design experience.

Important Considerations



Safety Factors

It's generally good practice to include a small safety factor when selecting conductors and calculating voltage drop.


Motor Starting Current

For motor circuits, consider the inrush current during motor starting. This can cause a significant voltage dip and must be factored into the voltage drop calculations. You might need to use larger conductors or voltage regulators if the voltage dip is excessive.

Harmonics

Non-linear loads (such as electronic ballasts, variable frequency drives, etc.) can introduce harmonic currents, which can increase voltage drop and heating in conductors. Consider using appropriately rated conductors and equipment if harmonics are present.


Coordination Study

A full coordination study is recommended, especially for larger or more complex systems, to ensure that the MCCBs and other protective devices are properly coordinated to minimize downtime and maximize safety. This is best done by a qualified electrical engineer.

Local Codes and Regulations

Always consult local electrical codes and regulations (such as the NEC in the US) for specific requirements and limitations.


Software Tools

Using specialized electrical design software (ETAP, SKM PowerTools, EasyPower) can greatly simplify these calculations and provide more accurate results, especially for complex systems.

In Summary:


Calculating the maximum circuit length requires a thorough understanding of voltage drop, conductor ampacity, overcurrent protection, and short-circuit characteristics. It's an iterative process that may require adjusting conductor sizes and MCCB settings to meet all requirements. For complex or critical applications, consult with a qualified electrical engineer. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question