User: Jpflex, Location: Victorville
Asked on: Saturday, November 2, 2024 at 6:51 pm EDT
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:46 am EST
Question: Many years ago when I was a mobile mechanic working in automotive electrical systems, I wandered how I could make lighting on a house dim when jumping a 2000 Ford f450 7.4l turbo diesel with my 12 volt dc 200 ampere jump box for the trucks dc starter motor but yet not trip the household breaker for the receptacle circuit rated for only 20 amperes AC?Hypothetically, what in the conversion process from AC to DC allows this to work?If comparing power in both circuits (ignoring power factor, impedance, reactive qualities) you haveAC120 volts x 20 amperes = 2400 VA on AC side of circuitAndDC12 volts x 200 amperes = 2400 VA on dc sideAlthough power whether in VA apparent or watts with power factor, I understand power is consistent in both but are not the AC household breakers rated to trip from excessive amperes current rather than power VA and WATTS?I also understand that breakers have an inverse trip setting which would make me think the dc jumper would cause the breaker to trip thermallyI guess the equal power is the reason but I thought this was an interesting subject
You've hit on a really interesting and complex question that touches on several key concepts in electrical engineering. Let's break it down
Why the Lights Dim (Potentially) but the Breaker Doesn't Trip (Usually):
The primary reason for the dimming, and the reason the breaker doesn't trip, revolves around the specific characteristics of the AC to DC conversion within the jump box, and the typical tolerances and characteristics of household breakers. Here's a more detailed breakdown:1. Inefficiency in the Jump Box's Charging Circuit and Draw
The jump box's AC to DC charging circuitry isn't perfectly efficient. This means that for every 2400 VA of DC power you're pulling out of the jump box to start the truck, the jump box is drawing more than 2400 VA from the AC outlet during the charging phase. In order to recharge and supply the DC power to the truck starter motor, more power has to be pulled from the household breaker to compensate for energy lost during the AC to DC conversion which causes the lights to dim.2.
Voltage Drop in the House Wiring
Anytime you draw current, you get a voltage drop due to the resistance of the wires. Drawing extra current from the receptacle during the charging phase will cause a voltage drop, albeit a small one, that causes the lights to dim.3.
Breaker Trip Curves
Household circuit breakers don't trip instantly at 20 amps. They have a time-current characteristic curve. This curve specifies how long it takes for the breaker to trip at different levels of overcurrent. You can temporarily exceed the rated current (20 amps) for a short duration without immediately tripping the breaker. This is essential for appliances like motors that have an inrush current when they start.4.
Typical Tolerances
Circuit breakers have tolerances in their trip points. A "20 amp" breaker might actually trip somewhere between 20 and 25 amps.5.
The Nature of the Load
A purely resistive load would heat up the breaker quickly. The AC to DC converter in the jump box may present a more complex load (capacitive, inductive) that doesn't heat the breaker as quickly as a purely resistive load drawing the same apparent power (VA).
Why the AC to DC Conversion Matters
The AC to DC conversion process is crucial:
It's not a direct, instantaneous transfer of energy. Think of the jump box as a reservoir. It slowly fills up with DC energy from the AC outlet. When you jump the truck, you're drawing from the "reservoir," and the charging circuit then needs to replenish it. The AC to DC converter is the key component. If you simply plugged a 12V 200A DC load directly into a 120V AC outlet, you'd have a direct short and the breaker would trip immediately. The AC to DC converter does several things: Voltage Transformation
It steps down the voltage from 120V AC to a lower DC voltage (often around 14-15 volts to charge a 12V battery).
Rectification
It converts the AC waveform into a pulsating DC waveform.
Filtering
It smooths out the pulsating DC to provide a relatively stable DC voltage.
Current Draw Over Time
The charging circuit doesn't instantly draw a massive current from the outlet the moment you connect the jump box to the truck. It draws power gradually to replenish the charge used during the jump-start. This is what prevents the instantaneous trip of the breaker.
Addressing Your Points
"Although power whether in VA apparent or watts with power factor, I understand power is consistent in both but are not the AC household breakers rated to trip from excessive amperes current rather than power VA and WATTS?" You are correct. Breakers are rated to trip based on current (amperes). However, the power (VA or Watts) is what ultimately causes the current to flow. High power demand leads to high current draw, which can trip the breaker. "I also understand that breakers have an inverse trip setting which would make me think the dc jumper would cause the breaker to trip thermally" Absolutely. The inverse trip setting (or time-current curve) is what allows you to draw a current higher than the breaker rating for a short period. The higher the current, the faster it trips.
In Summary
The dimming lights are due to a combination of the charging circuit's ineffciency, the extra power draw required to jump-start the truck, and voltage drop in the house wiring. The breaker doesn't always trip because: The charging circuit draws current more gradually to replenish the jump box. Breakers have inverse trip settings that allow short overloads. Breakers have tolerances.
Important Considerations
Never overload circuits deliberately. Repeatedly exceeding the breaker rating, even if it doesn't trip, can damage the breaker over time and create a fire hazard. Older wiring
In older homes with older wiring, you might experience a more significant voltage drop and be more likely to trip a breaker.
Extension cords
Using long, thin extension cords can add resistance and worsen voltage drop.*
The size of the jump box: A jump box with a more efficient AC to DC converter would likely cause less dimming.You're right; it's a very interesting subject that highlights the intricacies of AC and DC power and how they interact in real-world scenarios! Flag for review