User: VirutalElectrician, Location: Mpls, MN
Asked on: Sunday, November 3, 2024 at 10:04 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:46 am EST
Question: Customer just installed new appliances and they are tripping the GFCI.I suggested they file a repair order with place of purchase and this is what they sent back:Hello,I received the service request below for the Frigidaire Refrigerator. For this issue we received new direction from the Department of Labor and Industry's Chief Electrical Inspector about appliances tripping the breaker.State’s protocol:GFCI breakers are installed and inspected for NEC compliance.If after the appliance is installed, the appliance is shown to not be compatible with the GFCI protection, the contractor or homeowner will submit a NEMA incident report, and the GFCI breaker can be removed.GFCI issues can be documented here: https://www.nema.org/membership/products/gfci-unwanted-tripping-reportAFCI issues can be documented here: https://www.afcisafety.org/The contractor or homeowner provides proof, which is uploaded to the permit, that shows a NEMA incident report was submitted for an appliance at a specific address. (This could be a screenshot of the report on their webpage)If the breaker or appliance manufacturers provide a solution - it is up to the contractor/homeowner to make the necessary repairs and provide GFCI protection.
This is interesting. It sounds like your customer is caught between the retailer/manufacturer warranty service and some relatively new guidelines from their state's Department of Labor and Industry. Let's break down what this means and what your customer should do.
Understanding the Situation GFCI Protection
GFCI (Ground Fault Circuit Interrupter) breakers are designed to protect people from electrical shock. They trip when they detect a difference in current between the hot and neutral wires, indicating current is leaking to ground.
Nuisance Tripping
Modern appliances, especially those with inverters or complex electronics, can sometimes cause GFCI breakers to trip even when there isn't a true ground fault. This is often called "nuisance tripping."
State's Protocol
The state's protocol, as described, is essentially saying: GFCI breakers are installed to meet code (NEC - National Electrical Code). If an appliance causes nuisance tripping, instead of immediately assuming the electrical system is faulty, they want to investigate why the appliance is tripping the GFCI. This is done by submitting a NEMA (National Electrical Manufacturers Association) report. The idea is to identify specific appliances and models that are frequently causing GFCI tripping and work towards solutions (possibly through appliance design changes or modified GFCI breaker technology). Removing the GFCI is a last resort and only after documentation is provided that a NEMA report has been submitted.
What the Customer Needs to Do (Based on the Provided Information)1. Submit a NEMA Incident Report
The most important step is for your customer to submit a report on the NEMA website (https://www.nema.org/membership/products/gfci-unwanted-tripping-report). They need to provide as much detail as possible about the appliance (make, model number, date of purchase, etc.), the electrical circuit, and the circumstances under which the GFCI trips.2.
Document the Submission
Take a screenshot or print a copy of the confirmation page after submitting the NEMA report. This will be the "proof" needed.3.
Upload Proof to Permit (If Applicable)
The information mentions "uploading to the permit." This implies there was an electrical permit issued for the installation of the new appliances (likely required). Your customer needs to find out how and where to upload this proof. This is likely done through the local building department or permitting agency. If no permit was pulled then there is likely nothing to upload to.4.
Consider Contacting Appliance Manufacturer/Retailer Again
Now that the customer understands the state's protocol, they can contact the retailer or appliance manufacturer again. They should explain they've followed the state's instructions and submitted the NEMA report. They can ask if the manufacturer has any known solutions or recommendations for that particular appliance model when used with GFCI protection.5.
Be Prepared for Limited Solutions
The manufacturer or retailer may not have a quick fix. Nuisance tripping can be difficult to diagnose and resolve.
Important Considerations for the Customer Safety First
If the GFCI continues to trip frequently, it's crucial to make sure the appliance is not creating a genuine safety hazard. The customer should stop using the appliance if they suspect a real electrical problem.
Consult with a Qualified Electrician
Even though the state is suggesting this NEMA reporting process, it's a good idea to have a qualified electrician evaluate the situation. They can: Verify that the wiring is correct and in good condition. Test the GFCI breaker to ensure it's functioning properly. Provide an independent assessment of whether the tripping is truly "nuisance" tripping or indicative of a potential electrical fault.
Understand the Potential Outcomes
The GFCI might need to be replaced with a standard breaker (after NEMA reporting)
This is the least desirable outcome from a safety perspective, but it might be the only way to use the appliance if all other solutions fail. This should only be done after submitting the NEMA report and documenting the process.
The appliance might be faulty
There could be a defect in the appliance causing a small current leakage that the GFCI is detecting.
There might be wiring issues
Less likely with a new installation, but possible.*
A combination of factors
It could be a combination of a sensitive GFCI and a slightly "leaky" appliance.
In Summary - What the Customer Needs to Do Now
SUBMIT THE NEMA REPORT.2. Document the submission.3. Upload documentation to the permit (if applicable)4. Contact the retailer/manufacturer again, armed with the information about the NEMA report and the state's protocol.5. Consider having a qualified electrician evaluate the situation.
Good luck to your customer! This can be a frustrating situation, but following these steps should help them work towards a solution. Remember to emphasize safety throughout the process. Flag for review