User: rojodo3030, Location: Virginia
Asked on: Sunday, November 3, 2024 at 4:53 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:47 am EST
Question: So something i am having trouble grasping...When sizing wire do I need to calculate for voltage drop, AND derating factors? Here is my thought process: derating is so the wire won't heat up beyond its insulation capabilities. Voltage drop is so the wire carries enough power without losing voltage. However, if you size a wire to compensate for voltage drop, it will still have the same resistance value than a smaller, but also shorter wire run of the same ampacity. This will cause the same heating effect no? In which case it seems logical to calculate your voltage drop, then calculate your derating factors for your final wire size.
You've hit on a crucial point of confusion in electrical wiring! Yes, you absolutely need to consider both voltage drop and derating when sizing wire. They address different, though related, aspects of conductor performance.Here's a breakdown of why you need both and how they interact
1. Derating (Ampacity Adjustment): Preventing Overheating
Purpose
The primary goal of derating is to ensure the wire insulation doesn't overheat and degrade, leading to insulation failure (melting, cracking, short circuits, fire hazard).
How it works
You start with the base ampacity of the wire (found in tables like NEC 310.16, based on the wire's insulation type and temperature rating). Then, you apply derating factors based on:
Ambient Temperature Correction
Higher ambient temperatures reduce a wire's ability to dissipate heat. If the ambient temperature is above the table value, you reduce the ampacity.
Conductors in a Raceway/Cable/Earth (Adjustment Factors)
When multiple current-carrying conductors are bundled together in a raceway, cable, or buried in earth, each conductor contributes to the overall heat. This reduces the ability of each individual conductor to dissipate heat. You reduce the ampacity based on the number of conductors.
Other factors
Some specialized installations have other derating considerations (e.g., underground ducts with specific thermal resistivity).
Result
Derating lowers the allowable ampacity of the wire. It tells you the maximum current the wire can safely carry under those specific installation conditions without overheating its insulation.
2. Voltage Drop: Ensuring Adequate Voltage at the Load Purpose
Voltage drop is the loss of voltage along the length of a wire due to its resistance. Excessive voltage drop can cause: Equipment malfunction: Motors run slower, lights dim, electronic devices malfunction. Inefficient operation: More energy is wasted as heat in the wires.
How it works
You calculate the voltage drop based on:
Wire length
Longer wires have more resistance.
Current
Higher current causes greater voltage drop.
Wire size (circular mils)
Larger wires have lower resistance and less voltage drop.
Conductor Material (Copper or Aluminum) Result
Voltage drop calculations tell you if the voltage at the end of the wire run will be sufficient for the equipment being powered. If the voltage drop is too high (typically more than 3% for branch circuits and 5% for feeders and other specialized installations), you need to increase the wire size.
Why You Need Both
Think of it this way:
Derating
Ensures the wire doesn't melt, even if the voltage is acceptable. It handles thermal safety.
Voltage Drop
Ensures the equipment works properly, even if the wire isn't melting. It handles performance.
Your Insight About Resistance and Heating
You're right to think about the relationship between resistance and heating. Here's the key distinction:
Increasing wire size for voltage drop REDUCES resistance per foot. You are right that you increase the cross sectional area of the wire (circular mils), reducing the Ohms/ft and subsequently lowering the overall voltage drop over the length of the wire. Derating does not change the resistance per foot of the wire.
In Summary
Determine the minimum ampacity required by the load
This is the starting point.2.
Apply derating factors to the base ampacity of different wire sizes
This gives you the adjusted ampacity for each wire size under your specific installation conditions.3.
Select a wire size whose adjusted ampacity is greater than or equal to the load current
This ensures the wire won't overheat.4.
Calculate the voltage drop for the selected wire size
Use the actual length of the wire run, the load current, and the wire's resistance per foot (or use a voltage drop calculator).5.
If the voltage drop is excessive, increase the wire size and repeat steps 4 and 5
You need to keep increasing the wire size until the voltage drop is within acceptable limits and the adjusted ampacity is still greater than or equal to the load current.
Example
Let's say you have a 20A load running 100 feet on THHN copper wire in a conduit with 5 other current-carrying conductors. Ambient temperature is normal (30°C).1.
Minimum Ampacity
20A2.
Derating
THHN 75°C ampacity (NEC 310.16): #12 is rated for 30A, #10 for 40A. Adjustment Factor (6 Current Carrying Conductors): 80% (from NEC 310.15(C)(1)) Adjusted Ampacity: #12: 30A 0.8 = 24A (Okay, barely) #10: 40A 0.8 = 32A (Okay)3.
Voltage Drop Calculation (using #12)
Let's say the voltage drop is 6V (3% of 200V).4.
Voltage Drop Calculation (using #10)
Let's say the voltage drop is 4V (2% of 200V).In this case, #12 might be acceptable from a derating standpoint (check your local codes!), but #10 would be better for voltage drop. The goal is to strike the right balance between cost (larger wire is more expensive), ampacity, and voltage drop.
Important Considerations
Local Codes and Regulations
Always follow your local electrical codes and regulations, as they may have specific requirements for wire sizing and voltage drop.
Continuous Loads
For continuous loads (loads that operate for 3 hours or more at a time), you typically need to increase the minimum required ampacity by 25% (multiply the load current by 1.25).*
Equipment Instructions: Some equipment may have specific voltage drop requirements that are more stringent than the general guidelines. Consult the equipment manufacturer's instructions.By understanding both derating and voltage drop, you can safely and effectively size wires to meet the needs of your electrical installations. Flag for review