User: alixenos, Location: Florida
Asked on: Monday, November 4, 2024 at 10:53 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:48 am EST
Question: Hi,I have one service new service that provides is being tapped from a wireway that provides power to two electrical rooms. Picture attached.Should I provide a surge protection for one main or two mains? Why or why not?Thanks.
Okay, let's analyze your situation and determine the best approach for surge protection.
Understanding the Situation Single Source
You have a single wireway feeding two electrical rooms. This means any surge entering the wireway will likely propagate to both electrical rooms.
New Service Tap
You're adding a new service, which, depending on its nature, could introduce or be vulnerable to surges. More information of the purpose of this new service would be helpful.
Analysis and Recommendations1. Assess the Risk
Surge Prone Loads
Consider the types of equipment in each electrical room. Are there sensitive electronics like computers, PLCs, data servers, specialized medical equipment, or critical process controllers? These are very susceptible to damage from surges. Motor drives are also vulnerable. If the load is basic lighting, and general motor loads, surge protection is less critical, but still recommended, as a preventative measure.
External Sources
How exposed is your facility to external surges? Are you in an area prone to lightning strikes? Is your utility power supply known to be unreliable with frequent voltage spikes?2.
Single Main vs. Two Mains
Two Mains
This is the highly recommended and generally superior approach.
Reasoning
Zone of Protection
Installing surge protection at each main panel provides a localized zone of protection. It protects everything downstream of that panel.
Redundancy
If one SPD (Surge Protective Device) fails, the other still provides protection.
Reduced Let-Through Voltage
Multiple SPDs in a cascaded arrangement (as described below) can provide better overall surge protection.
Isolation
It limits surges from spreading between the two rooms. Imagine a surge originating within one room (e.g., from a motor starting). A surge protector in that room can help contain it from propagating to the other room.
Single Main (at the Wireway Tap)
While not ideal, you could consider this if your budget is severely limited, and you're willing to accept a higher risk profile.
Reasoning
It protects any downstream surges, but not from within the electrical rooms.
Cons
Single Point of Failure
If that single SPD fails, both electrical rooms are unprotected.
Limited Protection
A single SPD may not adequately suppress surges that originate within either of the electrical rooms.
Voltage Let-Through
A single SPD might have a higher "let-through voltage" than a cascaded system. Let-through voltage is the voltage level that the SPD allows to pass through to the protected equipment. Lower is better.3.
Cascaded Surge Protection (Best Practice)
The best practice is a cascaded approach:1.
Main SPD
Install a robust SPD at the point where the wireway taps to your new service. This is your first line of defense against external surges. This is typically installed a service entrance.2.
Sub-Panel SPDs
Install SPDs at the main panels in each electrical room. These provide localized protection and further reduce let-through voltage.3.
Point-of-Use SPDs
For particularly sensitive equipment, consider "point-of-use" SPDs (power strips with surge protection) right at the equipment.4.
Grounding
Make sure your grounding is very good as surge protection diverts surges to ground and a properly installed ground will make this process more effective and safer.
Specific Recommendations
Install SPDs at the Main Panels of BOTH Electrical Rooms. This is the minimum recommended approach. Consider a Cascaded System
If you have a medium to high risk profile, implement the full cascaded approach with an SPD at the wireway tap and SPDs in each electrical room.
Choose the Right SPDs
Select SPDs with appropriate Surge Current Capacity (measured in kA). The higher the kA rating, the better the SPD can handle large surges. Also, look for SPDs that are UL 1449 Listed.*
Professional Installation
Have a qualified electrician install the SPDs to ensure proper wiring and grounding.
In summary: Surge protection at both main panels is highly recommended. If possible, use cascaded surge protection. Flag for review