Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Tow-behind Generator Question

User: busman, Location: Northern Virginia

Asked on: Monday, November 4, 2024 at 4:52 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:49 am EST

Question: I need to connect a tow-behind leased generator to a temporary shelter for research purposes. It is 208/120Y. I could not get 5-conductor Type W cable quickly enough. I have 4-conductor. Any Code issues with the three hots and the neutral in the 4-conductor cable and a separate properly sized EGC run separately? I would strap the two together. It "feels" OK since these temporary installs are frequently done with a bunch of single conductor cables. I will post signage indicating that the EGC must be "first connect / last disconnect". Thoughts?As always, thanks. Got this one on a short fuse and don't have days to spend trolling the NEC for answers.Mark

Okay, Mark, let's break this down to address the legality and safety of your proposed temporary power setup. You're on the right track with considering safety and code, especially since you're dealing with a generator and a temporary installation.

The Short Answer: Code Concerns and Strong Recommendation Against

While your logic has a basis, using a 4-conductor cable for the phase conductors and neutral, then running a separate EGC and bonding them together is generally not compliant with the NEC and carries significant safety risks. Here's why: NEC 300.3(B) Conductors of the Same Circuit

This section is key. It requires that all conductors of the same circuit (including the neutral and, crucially, the grounding conductor) be run
together in the same raceway, cable, or enclosure. Your proposed setup violates this fundamental principle.

Impedance and Ground Fault Return Path

Running the EGC separately significantly increases impedance in the ground fault return path. When a fault occurs (e.g., a short circuit to ground), a high-impedance path will limit the fault current. This can prevent overcurrent protective devices (breakers or fuses) from tripping quickly enough, creating a shock hazard and potentially a fire hazard. The tightly bundled conductors in a multi-conductor cable minimize impedance because of inductive reactance.

Induced Currents (Eddy Currents)

Separating the EGC from the other circuit conductors can also lead to circulating currents and potential overheating, especially under high load conditions.


Mechanical Protection

A separate, exposed EGC run is more susceptible to physical damage, compromising its effectiveness.

"First Connect/Last Disconnect" Signage - Insufficient

While good practice, signage doesn't eliminate the fundamental electrical safety problems created by a high impedance EGC path. It's an administrative control; engineering controls are better.

Why Single Conductors
Sometimes Appear Similar, But Aren't the Same


You mention temporary setups with single conductors. This is where nuances and specific NEC articles come into play:
Temporary Wiring (Article 590)

The NEC does allow for some flexibility in temporary wiring situations. However, even under Article 590, there are still strict requirements for grounding and bonding. Simply using separate conductors for the neutral and ground isn't generally permitted. The "flexibility" is more about routing and physical protection methods, not abandoning basic circuit integrity.

"Suitably Grouped"

When single conductors are used in temporary wiring, they must be "suitably grouped." This doesn't just mean bundled together. It means installed in a way that minimizes impedance and ensures a reliable fault current path. Often, this is achieved by using raceways or cable trays.


Larger Systems/Feeders

In some very large installations, you might see separate grounding conductors in addition to a properly sized grounding conductor run with the circuit conductors. This is supplemental grounding, not a replacement for the primary EGC.

What You Can Do (Alternatives)


Given your time constraints, here are some safer and potentially code-compliant options to explore:1. Find Type W Cable (Even if Longer Lead Time)

This is the best option. Scour your local supply houses, even smaller ones. See if you can expedite shipping from a larger distributor. Explain the urgency.2.

Derate the Generator

If it is lightly loaded, could you possibly derive the required 120/240 single phase from the generator output? You may have to change the generator connections.3.

Rent a Different Generator

Can you rent a generator with the proper output voltage and cable already attached or readily available? This is a good option if you are under a time crunch.4.

Consult with a Qualified Electrical Engineer Immediately

An engineer can assess your specific situation, perform calculations, and possibly design a compliant temporary power system that addresses the impedance and safety concerns. They might be able to find an acceptable alternative wiring method within the NEC, but this is highly dependent on the specifics of your load, distance, and available equipment.

Important Considerations



Local AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)

Ultimately, the local electrical inspector has the final say. Contact them and explain your situation. They may be willing to work with you on a safe and code-compliant solution, or they might require a specific inspection.
Do this before you start wiring!



Safety First

Never compromise on safety. If you have any doubts, err on the side of caution.

In summary, your proposed setup is not recommended due to code violations and safety concerns. Explore the alternatives I've suggested, and prioritize finding the correct Type W cable or consulting with a qualified electrical professional. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question