User: Charlie R, Location: New York
Asked on: Tuesday, November 5, 2024 at 12:20 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:50 am EST
Question: First 400a residential service out on my own, 315 ft from the new pole the utility set. We are required to install a meter pedestal for services farther than 200 ft.Installing 2 200 amp panels1. Based on NEC 2017 section 225.32 would you consider that meter pedestal a structure. If so it would require a disconnecting means? I have figured 2 emergency disconnects at the building already but the inspector did not give me a straight answer whether he considered that a structure.2. Grounding - 250.66 gives me #4 GEC based on ungrounded conductors of 4/0 AL (parallel 4/0 from the pole to the meter). The only GEC I have is a UFER at the structure, so I would need to run 315 ft of #4 back to the first disconnecting means if I were required to have disconnects on the meter pedestal.If the 1st pair of disconnects are not required then my largest ungrounded conductor would be a 300kcmil AL and I would need #2 based on that table. However, 250.66(B) states when connected to a single or multiple concrete-encased electrodes, the grounding electrode conductor can be as small as 4 AWG copper if it doesn't extend to other types of electrodes that require a larger conductor.My interpretation is that #4 is the answer regardless of conductor size.Looking for some feedback on this and If I may be missing something
Okay, let's break down this 400A residential service with the meter pedestal issue. This is a common scenario that often causes confusion.1. Meter Pedestal as a Structure and Disconnecting Means (NEC 2017 225.32)
This is where it gets tricky and heavily relies on the inspector's interpretation, which is frustrating, but ultimately their call. Here's the problem:
Definition of "Structure": The NEC doesn't give a super concrete definition of "structure" in this context. Typically, it refers to something that stands on its own, is relatively permanent, and isn't just a piece of equipment. Argument FOR Pedestal as Structure
A meter pedestal could be argued to be a structure because it's a separate, permanent installation independent of the house. It houses equipment (meter, potentially disconnects), and has its own grounding system, and footings.
Argument AGAINST Pedestal as Structure
A meter pedestal could be argued not to be a structure because it solely serves the purpose of supporting the meter and associated service equipment. It's an accessory to the main service, not a separate building or detached garage etc.
Key Question for the Inspector
Instead of asking "Is this a structure?", try asking, "Does the AHJ require a disconnecting means at the meter pedestal for services over 200 feet given that you're already requiring emergency disconnects at the dwelling?" Phrasing it that way puts the ball back in their court and forces them to be clear on their specific expectation.
If a Disconnect is Required at the Pedestal
This adds significant cost and complexity due to the grounding requirements you've already identified. Consider alternatives like:
Moving the meter closer
Can you reposition the meter pedestal to be within 200 feet of the dwelling? This eliminates the entire issue. Even shaving off 115ft would solve the problem.
Discuss with the Utility
Sometimes the utility has specific rules or waivers regarding disconnects at meter pedestals. They may allow you to skip it if you have emergency disconnects at the house.
Appeal
If you strongly believe the pedestal shouldn't be considered a structure, you can appeal the inspector's decision through the proper channels (usually a review board). However, this is time-consuming and often doesn't work in your favor.
2. Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC) Sizing - 250.66 and 250.66(B)
You've pretty much nailed this down. Let's clarify:
Parallel 4/0 AL from Pole to Meter (Without Disconnects at Pedestal)
This is the crucial point. If you don't need disconnects at the pedestal, your main service conductors (pole to first disconnect) are parallel 4/0 AL. This is why you initially calculated the #4 GEC. However, the #4 GEC only runs from the meter pedestal to the ground rod at the meter pedestal.
Panel Conductors
At the building you have conductors protected by a 200 amp breaker which requires #2 AWG
250.66(B) and UFER
This is your saving grace! Because you have a single UFER electrode, and the GEC connects only to that UFER, you can use a #4 AWG copper GEC, even if the calculated size based on 250.66 would be larger.
Important
The UFER must be properly installed (at least 20 feet of 1/2" rebar or 20 feet of #4 copper embedded in concrete).
In summary, your interpretation is correct: You can use a #4 AWG copper GEC to connect your single UFER electrode.Important Considerations
Local Amendments
Check for any local amendments to the NEC that may affect these rules. Some jurisdictions have very specific requirements for meter pedestals.
Utility Requirements
The utility may have their own specific grounding and bonding requirements in addition to the NEC. Consult with them.
Communication
Maintain open communication with the inspector and the utility. Getting clarity before* you start the installation will save you a lot of headaches.
Recommendations
Clarify with the Inspector
Specifically ask if the AHJ requires a disconnecting means at the meter pedestal, given the distance and presence of emergency disconnects at the dwelling. Get it in writing if possible.2.
If Disconnects are Required
Explore relocating the meter closer, discuss with the utility, or consider an appeal if justified.3.
Grounding: If no disconnects are required at the pedestal, proceed with a #4 AWG copper GEC to your UFER, provided the UFER is properly installed. Ensure proper bonding throughout the system (meter pedestal, panels, etc.)Good luck! Let me know if you have more questions after talking with the inspector. Flag for review