User: philly, Location: New York, 40.7514,-73.9925
Asked on: Tuesday, November 5, 2024 at 8:41 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:50 am EST
Question: Can a concentric neutral that is part of an MV cable shield be used to satisfy the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) requirement per NEC 250.122?For example can a cable with a 1/3 rated concentric neutral be used as an EGC if the current carrying capacity meets the requirement of table 250.122? I believe in this case the upstream overcurrent device rating used for 250.122 would be the CT ratio or ground fault pickup setting of relay?Can the concentric neutrals of all (3) cables be added to account for EGC size or only one at a time can be considered?I know the NEC allows use of a tape shield as an EGC as long as it rated to carry fault current based on fault clearing time (typically not applicable on solidly grounded systems) so I was wondering if with a concentric neutral the current carrying capacity of concentric neutral gets applied directly against 250.122 based on CT ratio or GF pickup or if relay clearing time for faults must also be considered?
Let's break down the use of a concentric neutral as an Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC) in Medium Voltage (MV) systems, referencing relevant NEC sections and considerations.
Key Considerations1. NEC 250.122 - Size of Equipment Grounding Conductors
This section dictates the minimum size of the EGC based on the rating of the overcurrent protective device (OCPD) protecting the circuit. This is the core requirement you're trying to address.2.
Concentric Neutral as EGC - Potential Acceptability (But Difficult)
The NEC doesn't explicitly prohibit using a concentric neutral as an EGC. However, demonstrating compliance with 250.122 can be very challenging and requires careful engineering analysis. The devil is in the details of proving its adequacy.
3.
Fault Current Calculations and Coordination Study
This is crucial. You must perform a thorough fault current study to determine the magnitude and duration of fault currents that the concentric neutral will be subjected to. This study needs to consider:
Source Impedance
The utility source impedance (or generator impedance) is critical.
Cable Impedance
The impedance of the MV cables themselves.
Grounding Configuration
Solidly grounded, impedance grounded, etc. This dramatically affects fault current levels.
Overcurrent Protective Device (OCPD) Clearing Time
The time it takes for the OCPD to interrupt the fault current. This is essential for determining the thermal withstand capacity needed for the EGC.4.
Thermal Withstand Rating (Ampacity) of the Concentric Neutral
You must determine the short-circuit current withstand rating of the concentric neutral. This is based on the conductor material (usually copper), cross-sectional area, insulation (if any), and the allowable temperature rise for a short-circuit condition. Consult cable manufacturers' data for this. IEEE 837 is a relevant standard for testing grounding conductors for short-circuit withstand.5.
Impedance of the Concentric Neutral Path
The impedance of the neutral path is important, as it will affect the magnitude of ground fault current. Higher impedance lowers fault current.
Addressing Your Specific Questions 1/3 Rated Concentric Neutral
The "1/3 rated" designation typically refers to the ampacity of the concentric neutral relative to the phase conductors. It doesn't directly correlate with suitability as an EGC. You can't just assume a 1/3 rated neutral is sufficient; you must verify its ampacity through calculations and testing or manufacture data.
Upstream OCPD Rating
You are correct. With MV systems, the OCPD is usually a relay and current transformer (CT) combination, not a simple circuit breaker or fuse. The "rating" you use in 250.122 is functionally the CT ratio times the relay's ground fault pickup setting. However, the crucial factor is clearing time. A low pickup current might sound safe, but a long clearing time (intentional delay) can actually increase the thermal stress on the EGC.
Adding Concentric Neutrals
Generally, no. You cannot simply add the cross-sectional areas (or ampacities) of multiple concentric neutrals together to meet the EGC requirement for a single circuit. NEC 250.122 refers to a single equipment grounding conductor for the circuit. Each individual concentric neutral would be associated with its respective phase conductor. Think of it like paralleling conductors; paralleling EGCs requires very specific conditions to be met, and is typically not done in this type of application.
Tape Shield vs. Concentric Neutral
The NEC allows a metallic cable sheath (tape shield or other types of shield) to be used as an EGC if it's demonstrated to be capable of safely carrying the available fault current. This is the same principle that applies to concentric neutrals. The cable manufacturer or a qualified engineer must verify the shield's short-circuit current rating for the given fault clearing time. In solidly grounded systems, the tape shield typically cannot meet the fault current requirements due to the high fault current level and short clearing times and would be used only as part of a "low impedance ground plane".
Why It's Difficult and Often Avoided Complexity of Calculations
Determining the short-circuit current rating of the concentric neutral and its ability to withstand the fault current for the OCPD's clearing time requires complex calculations and detailed information from the cable manufacturer. The assumptions and modeling are critical.
Limited Data
Cable manufacturers may not always provide the necessary short-circuit withstand data for concentric neutrals, especially for the specific clearing times of your relay settings.
Coordination Challenges
Ensuring proper coordination between the relay settings and the concentric neutral's withstand rating can be difficult.
Alternative Grounding Methods
It's often easier and more reliable to install a separate, dedicated EGC (e.g., a copper conductor) sized according to 250.122 and run alongside the MV cables. This avoids the complexities of relying on the concentric neutral.
In Summary
While technically possible, using a concentric neutral as an EGC is a complex and potentially risky approach. You must:1. Perform a detailed fault current study.
2. Obtain short-circuit withstand data from the cable manufacturer for the concentric neutral.3. Verify that the concentric neutral's withstand rating exceeds the fault current for the OCPD's clearing time.
4. Document all calculations and assumptions.Consult with a qualified electrical engineer experienced in MV systems and grounding practices to ensure compliance with the NEC and best industry practices. In many cases, a dedicated EGC will be a more straightforward and reliable solution. Flag for review