Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Generator as a separately derived system

User: alixenos, Location: Florida

Asked on: Tuesday, November 5, 2024 at 9:45 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:51 am EST

Question: Hi,When I spec a generator, and in almost all the projects I worked on, my supervisor indicates that the generator is not considered as a separately derived system.My question is, what drives this decision? when do consider a generator as a separately derived system?Thanks for the help.

You've hit a common point of confusion! Whether a generator is a Separately Derived System (SDS) is a critical distinction that affects grounding, bonding, and overcurrent protection. Your supervisor's decision not to consider it an SDS is likely based on one or more of the following factors

What Defines a Separately Derived System (SDS) according to the NEC (National Electrical Code, usually Article 250):
No Direct Connection

An SDS has no direct electrical connection to the normal power source (utility). The only connection is through a transformer, generator windings, or other electrical isolation device.


Isolation

The key idea is electrical isolation from the normal power source. This prevents fault currents from the utility system from propagating to the generator system and vice versa.

Why Your Supervisor Might Not Consider the Generator an SDS (And the Code Implications)

Here's a breakdown of the most common reasons, with the NEC implications for not treating it as an SDS:1.

Transfer Switch Type (The MOST COMMON reason)



Non-Switched Neutral Transfer Switch

This is the MOST common reason for NOT treating a generator as an SDS. If the automatic transfer switch (ATS) does not switch the neutral conductor (the neutral from the utility and the generator are always connected together), then the generator is almost never considered an SDS.

NEC Rationale

With the neutral always connected, the generator is essentially an extension of the utility's grounded system. Fault currents can travel back to the utility transformer through the shared neutral.

Consequence

Grounding and bonding are greatly simplified. You maintain the single point of grounding at the service entrance (utility). The generator frame is bonded to the existing grounding electrode system. You
do not need a separate grounding electrode system for the generator. The generator neutral is also bonded to the generator frame.2.

Size of the Generator



Small Generators (Residential/Light Commercial)

Often, very small, portable generators (especially those without a separately accessible neutral) are implicitly not treated as SDSs, even if they use a transfer switch that appears to switch the neutral. This is more of a practical convention than a strict code interpretation, but it's based on the assumption that their fault current contribution is negligible.

NEC Rationale

The fault current contribution is so small, the existing grounding system can handle it.


Consequence

The same as above - treated as an extension of the existing system.3.

Existing Grounding Electrode System



If an adequate grounding electrode system is already present at the building service

The generator is connected to this same grounding electrode system.


NEC Rationale

No need to duplicate grounding; rely on the existing, adequate system.

Consequence

As above - treated as an extension of the existing system.

When You
DO Need to Treat a Generator as an SDS (And the Code Implications)


Switched Neutral Transfer Switch

This is the KEY reason to treat a generator as an SDS. If the transfer switch does switch the neutral conductor (the neutral from the utility and the generator are kept separate), then you must treat the generator as an SDS.

NEC Rationale

The generator is electrically isolated from the utility. You need to establish a new, independent grounding system for the generator to provide a low-impedance path for fault current to return to the source (the generator windings) to trip overcurrent protective devices.

Consequences (Significantly more complex and expensive)



Grounding Electrode System

You must install a grounding electrode system at the generator (ground rods, ground ring, etc.). NEC 250.30 is critical here.

Neutral-to-Case Bond

The generator neutral
must be bonded to the generator frame at the generator.

Overcurrent Protection

You need to ensure that overcurrent protection is properly coordinated for the generator's fault current contribution.2.

Specific Project Requirements



Consulting Engineer's Specifications

Sometimes, the project specifications will explicitly state that the generator
must be treated as an SDS, regardless of the transfer switch type. This is usually for reasons of redundancy or enhanced safety.

Why Does This Matter?
Safety

Proper grounding and bonding are critical for safety. They provide a low-impedance path for fault current, allowing overcurrent protective devices (circuit breakers, fuses) to trip quickly and clear the fault. Incorrect grounding can lead to voltage on normally non-current-carrying metal parts, creating shock hazards.

Code Compliance

Failure to comply with NEC Article 250 can result in rejection of the installation by inspectors.


Equipment Protection

Proper grounding and bonding also help protect sensitive electronic equipment from damage due to voltage surges and electrical noise.

How to Determine the Correct Approach


Transfer Switch Specifications

The type of transfer switch is the most important factor. Review the transfer switch specifications carefully. Does it switch the neutral conductor?2.

Project Specifications

Review the project specifications (if any) for specific grounding requirements.3.

Local Electrical Inspector

Consult with the local electrical inspector. They have the final say on whether the installation complies with the NEC.4.

Qualified Electrical Engineer

If you are unsure, consult with a qualified electrical engineer who is experienced in generator installations and grounding requirements.

In summary, ask these questions


Does the transfer switch switch the neutral?
If YES, it's almost certainly an SDS. If NO, it's likely not an SDS.2. Do the project specifications explicitly require it to be treated as an SDS?3. Is the generator very small (portable) and used in a simple setup? (If so, it might be implicitly treated as non-SDS, even with a seemingly switched neutral).

Important Notes



NEC is complex

Grounding and bonding requirements are complex and can vary depending on the specific installation.


Local Amendments

Local jurisdictions may have amendments to the NEC.*

Professional Judgment:
A qualified electrical engineer or experienced electrician should always make the final determination based on the specific circumstances of the installation.By understanding these factors, you can better understand your supervisor's decisions and ensure that the generator is properly grounded and bonded for safe and reliable operation. Always document your decisions and the reasoning behind them. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question