User: samgillis, Location: California, USA
Asked on: Tuesday, November 5, 2024 at 11:33 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:51 am EST
Question: So I have a Go Power 50a ATS that is fed by my inverter as the primary and grid as the backup.The grid feed is already protected by a Siemens whole home surge protector in the main panel. Does this adequately protect the circuit board of the ATS?I also just purchased a Midnite Solar SPD and was going to place it in the ATS, just trying to figure out where is best.I already have surge protection on the DC side into the inverter from the panels and batteries. Would placing the new SPD on the inverter AC out and before the input to the ATS be best? Would this also provide some protection to the inverter even though it’s on the output side? Or would it be best to place it on the output side of the ATS?
Okay, let's break down your situation and how best to utilize your surge protection devices (SPDs) for optimal protection of your ATS and other equipment.
Understanding the Problem ATS Vulnerability
Automatic Transfer Switches, while robust, have sensitive electronic components that can be damaged by voltage surges.
Inverter Vulnerability
Inverters, especially those with complex grid-tie capabilities, are also susceptible to surge damage.
Surge Path
Surges can come from various sources (lightning, grid events, inductive loads turning on/off) and can travel through AC wiring.
Layered Protection
Best practice involves layered surge protection, intercepting surges at multiple points.
Analyzing Your Existing Surge Protection Siemens Whole Home SPD
This provides good protection against surges entering your home from the grid. It should effectively protect most standard appliances connected to your main panel.
Limitation
A whole-home SPD doesn't necessarily protect against surges originating within your home (e.g., from a faulty appliance or from your inverter).
DC Side Protection
This is crucial for protecting your inverter from surges coming from your solar panels or batteries.
Evaluating SPD Placement Options
Here's a detailed analysis of the options you're considering for your Midnite Solar SPD
Option 1: SPD on Inverter AC Output, Before ATS Input
Rationale
Inverter Protection
This is the best option for protecting the inverter from surges originating from its own output and potentially from the grid side through the ATS. Although it is on the output side, surges on the grid input side can make their way to the inverter circuit.
ATS Protection
It provides a degree of protection to the ATS from surges coming from the inverter.
Internal Surge Protection: Some inverters have an internal surge protection, but adding an external SPD will most likely be more robust. Considerations
Wiring
You'll need to ensure adequate wire gauge and a short, direct ground connection for the SPD to be effective.
Coordination
The SPD voltage and surge current ratings should be compatible with your system's voltage and potential surge levels.
Recommendation
This is the
most effective location for your Midnite Solar SPD.
Option 2: SPD Inside the ATS Rationale
Direct ATS Protection
Provides direct protection of the ATS components.
Considerations
Space Constraints
May be difficult to physically fit the SPD and wiring within the ATS enclosure. Ensure it doesn't obstruct wiring or ventilation.
Wiring
Still requires short, low-impedance wiring to ground for optimal performance. Using the manufacturer provided leads is suggested.
Access
It may be more difficult to replace the SPD if it does its job and absorbs a large surge.
Recommendation
This is a good choice only if the SPD can be safely wired inside the ATS enclosure.
Option 3: SPD on ATS Output Side Rationale
This will protect the loads on the output, it will not protect the ATS, which is your main concern.
Recommendation
Not recommended in this situation.
Practical Considerations and Implementation1. Grounding is Critical
Ensure proper grounding for all your surge protection devices. A robust, low-impedance ground connection is essential for diverting surge currents. Follow the SPD manufacturer's grounding recommendations precisely.2.
Wire Gauge
Use appropriate wire gauge for connecting the SPD. Heavier gauge wire provides a lower impedance path for surge currents.3.
Short Wire Runs
Keep the wiring between the SPD and the equipment it's protecting as short as possible. Longer wires increase inductance, which can impede surge diversion.4.
Follow Manufacturer's Instructions
Adhere to the installation instructions provided by the manufacturers of both the ATS and the SPD.5.
Regular Inspection
Periodically inspect your SPDs to ensure they are functioning correctly. Some SPDs have indicator lights or other mechanisms to show their status.
Answer to Your Specific Questions Does the Siemens Whole Home SPD Adequately Protect the ATS Circuit Board? It provides some protection against surges from the grid, but it doesn't protect against surges originating from your inverter or other internal sources. Adding the Midnite Solar SPD is a worthwhile investment for improved protection. Where to Place the Midnite Solar SPD? The best location is on the inverter AC output, before the ATS input. This will provide good protection to the inverter and some protection for the ATS from the inverter side. Does Placing the SPD on the Inverter Output Protect the Inverter? Yes, it provides protection to the inverter. Placing it on the Output side of the ATS is not as beneficial as other options.
Final Recommendation
Install the Midnite Solar SPD on the AC output of your inverter, before the ATS input. This will give you the best overall protection for your inverter and a good level of protection for your ATS. Make sure that the SPD voltage and surge current ratings are appropriate for your system. Ensure proper grounding, short wire runs, and follow all manufacturer's instructions. If you can also place an SPD inside the ATS, that is fine too. Flag for review