User: samgillis, Location: California, USA
Asked on: Tuesday, November 5, 2024 at 11:48 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:51 am EST
Question: I was in Alberta a few months ago, northwest of Calgary and southwest of Edmonton, and noticed what seemed to be distribution lines that only had one conductor. I even saw some pole mounted transformers that were fed by this one wire. All I could think was that these were SWER because I couldn't seem to find a mainline neutral anywhere.Is this what I was seeing and, if so, do they still run these in rural parts of the country or are they just antiquated and haven't been upgraded?
You're almost certainly right - you were likely seeing Single-Wire Earth Return (SWER) lines.Here's why and some details: Common in Rural Alberta
SWER systems are, or were, very common in rural Alberta and other sparsely populated areas of Canada, Australia, New Zealand, and parts of the US. The area you describe, northwest of Calgary and southwest of Edmonton, fits the profile of rural farmland where SWER systems have traditionally been used.
How SWER Works
As you understand, SWER uses a single high-voltage conductor and relies on the earth as the return path for the current, instead of a second wire. Pole-mounted transformers are connected to this single wire and a local earth ground.
Cost Savings
The primary reason for using SWER is cost. It's significantly cheaper to build a single-wire line than a traditional two- or three-wire distribution system, especially across long distances with few customers.
Identification Points
Single Conductor
The most obvious clue is the presence of only one high-voltage conductor on the poles.
Earth Stakes/Grounding
You'll often see prominent earth stakes or grounding conductors at the transformers and at regular intervals along the line.
Warning Signs
In some areas, there may be warning signs about the grounding system.
Are they still running/being upgraded? Yes, they are still in use
SWER systems are still in use in rural parts of Canada, including Alberta. It's not necessarily an "antiquated" system in the sense of being inherently unsafe or unusable, it's simply a design choice based on economic considerations for low-density areas.
Upgrades Happen, but Slowly
Utilities are gradually upgrading some SWER lines to more conventional two- or three-wire systems as load demands increase and as funding becomes available. However, the sheer scale of the rural grid means that SWER lines will likely remain in use for many years to come, especially in the most remote areas.
Driver For Upgrades
Upgrades are typically driven by:
Increased Load Demand
As farms and rural businesses expand, they require more power, which SWER systems may struggle to reliably deliver.
Power Quality Issues
SWER can be more susceptible to voltage fluctuations and outages due to earth resistance variations.
Modernization
Some utilities are proactively replacing SWER lines as part of grid modernization efforts.
In Summary:
It's highly probable you saw SWER lines. They're a practical and cost-effective solution for providing electricity to remote areas with low population density. While upgrades are happening, the economics often favor keeping SWER in place for the foreseeable future in many regions. Flag for review