Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Bad to use only 2 legs of 208 wye 3 phase?

User: Moosifer, Location: Panama City Beach, FL

Asked on: Tuesday, November 5, 2024 at 4:15 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:52 am EST

Question: I hope this makes sense.I have a customer with a conex that has a 100a panel and needs a 100a panel but will pull less when the AC or heat isn't cranking hard.They want to be able to feed it with either 208 wye three phase or 240v single phase.I am wondering if wiring it up with a 208 to 240v transfer switch that will take 208 or 240 and feed a single phase panel will be a bad idea with that kind of load imbalance when it is only connected to 2 legs of three phase. This is an industrial type portable unit so a 50a load or whatever normal load it would pull on only two legs should not be a giant imbalance percentage wise, but I don't know how many different places they may plug it in to three phase.Not sure if I am being paranoid but I'd rather get some educated opinions.

Yes, your concerns about load imbalance on the 208V three-phase system are valid and it's good you're thinking this through. Here's a breakdown of the potential problems and some solutions to consider

Understanding the Issues
Load Imbalance

When you run a single-phase panel off only two legs of a three-phase system, you're creating a significant load imbalance. Even if the
total load is only 50A, all of that current is drawn from just two of the three phases. This can cause:

Overheating

The two loaded phases will carry significantly higher current than the unloaded phase, potentially leading to overheating of transformers, conductors, and other equipment upstream in the three-phase system.

Voltage Drop

The loaded phases will experience more voltage drop than the unloaded phase, which can negatively affect the performance of sensitive equipment connected to that system.


Harmonic Distortion

Unbalanced loads can introduce harmonic currents back into the three-phase system, which can damage equipment and reduce power quality.

Utility Issues

The utility company may not be happy if they see a consistently unbalanced load. In some areas, they may even penalize customers for excessive imbalance.


Transfer Switch

Using a 208V-to-240V step-up transformer followed by a transfer switch is a viable starting point, however, it will cause problems with the 208v power when there is more load.

Conex Wiring Considerations

Conex containers are often subject to vibration and movement. Properly securing the panel, transfer switch, and wiring is crucial to prevent damage and maintain safety.

Potential Solutions


Here are a few ways to tackle this problem, ranked in terms of best practice and complexity:1. Dedicated Panels for Each Voltage

This is the cleanest and safest solution. Install

two separate 100A panels
inside the conex:
One panel is wired for 240V single-phase. The other panel is wired for 208V three-phase. (This requires some internal three-phase wiring in the conex, which might need to be simple and only used for specific three-phase equipment). The customer plugs the appropriate power cord (240V single-phase or 208V three-phase) into the correct inlet on the conex. They cannot be plugged in simultaneously. Clearly label the inlets and panels. Benefits

Eliminates load imbalance, no transformers or transfer switches needed, safest and most reliable.


Drawbacks

Requires more internal wiring and careful labeling, and requires the customer to be diligent about using the correct input.2.

208 to 240 Step UP transformer and transfer switch
How it works

The utility will be wired to the transfer switch and the transformer will be wired to the transfer switch. The output of the transfer switch will wire directly to the panel.


Benefits

More flexible than a single voltage.

Drawbacks

The transformer will take up space. The power drop/ load balance will have a hard time when using 208v.3.

Phase Balancing Transformer
How it works

This uses a specialized transformer designed to mitigate phase imbalance. It takes the single-phase load and redistributes it across all three phases of the 208V supply.

Benefits

Reduces phase imbalance significantly. Can be automated.


Drawbacks

More expensive than a standard transformer. More complex installation. Requires careful sizing and selection.4.

Consider a Variac



How it works

Variacs are variable transformers. A properly sized variac (or a combination of variacs) could be used to adjust the voltage based on the input power source.

Important Considerations (Regardless of Solution)
Grounding

Proper grounding is essential in a conex container. Make sure the panel is securely bonded to the conex frame, and that the grounding system is adequate for the expected fault currents.

Overcurrent Protection

Use appropriately sized breakers or fuses to protect all circuits.


Conductor Sizing

Size conductors according to the anticipated load and the applicable electrical code. Consider the ambient temperature inside the conex container, which can get quite hot.

Cord and Plug Selection

Use heavy-duty, industrial-grade cords and plugs rated for the appropriate voltage and amperage.


Labeling

Clearly label all panels, inlets, outlets, and switches with the voltage, amperage, and phase configuration. Include warning labels about potential hazards.

Professional Installation

This type of electrical work should be performed by a licensed electrician who is familiar with the electrical code and best practices.


Inspection

Have the installation inspected by a qualified electrical inspector.

Recommendation


I strongly recommend the Dedicated Panels for Each Voltage (Option 1). It's the safest, most reliable, and simplest solution in the long run. While it requires the customer to be careful about selecting the correct input power, it eliminates the potential for load imbalance and voltage fluctuations. If the cost is prohibitive then option 2 would be my second choice.Before making a final decision, discuss all options with your customer, explain the pros and cons of each, and let them choose the solution that best meets their needs and budget. Make sure they understand the importance of proper operation and maintenance. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question