User: Grouch1980, Location: New York, NY
Asked on: Wednesday, November 6, 2024 at 12:21 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:53 am EST
Question: Hey guys,I attached an excerpt from the 2017 NEC handbook, section 625.42 for EV chargers. Where I highlighted in blue, for level 3 chargers... is this saying the charger load is or is not considered a continuous load? The paragraph above it, for level 2 chargers, explicitly sends you to section 625.41, where it states OCPD's are sized at 125%. But the section that I highlighted for level 3 doesn't send you to 625.41, but rather seems to be keeping it open ended / vague. I need help in interpreting this.
Okay, let's break down NEC 625.42 regarding EV charger load calculations, especially focusing on the difference between Level 2 and Level 3 (DC Fast Charging) and the key highlighted section.
Understanding the Context
Article 625 in the NEC deals specifically with Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Systems. Continuous Load
A continuous load is a load where the maximum current is expected to continue for three hours or more. NEC requires OCPDs (Overcurrent Protection Devices – like breakers and fuses) and conductors to be rated for 125% of the continuous load. This is to account for heating and potential degradation over time.
Analyzing the Excerpt
Let's look at the sections you're referring to:
Level 2 Charging (Above the Highlighted Section)
This section specifically refers you to 625.41 which then mandates the 125% rule. This directly makes it a continuous load.
Level 3 Charging (Highlighted Section)
"The branch-circuit, feeder, and service conductors and overcurrent protection shall be sized for the maximum current of charge of the electric vehicle supply equipment." It does not specifically reference 625.41 or any other section that explicitly mandates the 125% rule. This is where the ambiguity lies.
Interpretation and Reasoning
Based on my understanding and the context of the NEC:
The highlighted section for Level 3 chargers does not explicitly require you to treat the load as continuous (i.e., apply the 125% rule) based solely on that section.Why the Difference?
The NEC's approach is likely different for Level 3 chargers due to the following:1. Duty Cycle
Level 3 chargers, especially in commercial settings, are often not constantly delivering maximum power for extended periods. The charging session length can be shorter than the continuous load threshold (3 hours). Level 2 chargers, especially for overnight home charging, are more likely to be continuous.2.
Built-in Load Management
Many Level 3 chargers have sophisticated load management capabilities. They can adjust the charging rate based on grid conditions, available power, and the vehicle's acceptance rate. This inherent control can mitigate the risk of sustained maximum load.3.
Higher Power Levels & Infrastructure
The electrical infrastructure feeding Level 3 chargers is typically more robust, with more headroom for demand variations.
Important Considerations & Best Practices
Local Amendments
Always check your local electrical codes and ordinances. Some jurisdictions may have amendments to the NEC that do require Level 3 chargers to be treated as continuous loads.
Manufacturer's Specifications
Consult the manufacturer's specifications for the specific Level 3 charger you are installing. They may provide guidance on load calculations and conductor sizing.
Engineering Judgement
As an electrician or electrical engineer, you have a responsibility to exercise sound engineering judgement. Consider these factors when determining whether to treat a Level 3 charger as a continuous load:
Expected Usage Patterns
Will the charger be used primarily for quick top-offs or longer charging sessions?
Load Management Capabilities
Does the charger have effective load management features that can prevent sustained maximum output?
Ambient Temperature
High ambient temperatures can increase conductor heating, making the 125% rule more important.
Future Expansion
Is there a possibility of adding more chargers in the future? Oversizing the conductors and OCPD now can save money and hassle later.
Conservative Approach
When in doubt, it's generally safer and more reliable to err on the side of caution and treat the Level 3 charger as a continuous load.
Demand Factors
Depending on the number of chargers, the NEC allows for demand factors. If you have multiple Level 3 chargers, you may be able to apply a demand factor to reduce the overall calculated load. Consult Article 220 for information on demand factors.
Informational Note
Note that the Informational Note 1 gives the option of looking at load management systems to reduce the calc load.
In summary
The NEC section you highlighted does not explicitly require you to treat Level 3 chargers as continuous loads in all cases. However, prudent engineering practice, local codes, and manufacturer's instructions should always be considered to ensure a safe and reliable installation.
Disclaimer: I am an AI Chatbot and not a qualified electrician. This information is for general guidance only and should not be substituted for professional advice from a licensed electrician or electrical engineer who can assess your specific situation and ensure compliance with all applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review