Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: C1D1 boundaries vs seal offs

User: Edwarjw22, Location: Lakeland, FL

Asked on: Wednesday, November 6, 2024 at 2:21 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:54 am EST

Question: I have been working on a sewer wet well installation. The wet well is defined as class 1 div 1 by NFPA820. The submersible pumps have a multiconductor cord that is sealed into the pump and extends from the wet well to a JB where it is terminated. This cord passes through a pipe, sleeve, conduit, whatever you want to call it that stops at grade level and is not sealed. The cable extends upward into an enclosure that has a class 1 div 2 cable gland fitting installed. This JB is mounted greater than 3 feet above the open pipe that passes into the well. From the JB we have rigid conduit with poured seal off fittings running to the MCP that is located greater than 5 feet from any well openings.In my opinion the open pipe from the well, C1D1, extends that C1D1 classification to the opening of the pipe and as long as the boundary distances are met and we do not intend on extending the pipe outside of the boundary area, a poured seal off is not required. It is only required if we want to stop the C1D1 boundary distance.According to NFPA820, 3 feet beyond any opening into the well is C1D1. Between 3 feet and 5 feet is C1D2 and beyond 5 feet is unclassified.This has been a very long topic of discussion, and I would really like some input.

You've laid out a common scenario and a well-reasoned argument. Let's break it down, focusing on NFPA 820 and general hazardous location principles.

Your Interpretation (and it's likely correct)

You're essentially arguing that the open pipe acts as a "vent" extending the Class I, Division 1 area. The boundaries defined in NFPA 820 then govern. You are not arguing for reducing the classified area, but accepting it and working within its parameters. You're relying on the natural dissipation of gases to dilute them below the Lower Explosive Limit (LEL) beyond the specified distances. Since you are not trying to interrupt the free vent of the C1D1 location with a seal fitting, the boundaries are not extended.

Key Points to Support Your Position



NFPA 820 (2020 Edition - likely what you're using)

Your understanding of the 3-foot Class I, Division 1 and 5-foot Class I, Division 2 boundaries around openings is correct (see Sections 5.2.3 and 5.
2.4, specifically 5.2.
4.1). The "opening" in this case is arguably the
top of the open pipe, not where the pipe enters the wet well.

Natural Ventilation and Dilution

Hazardous location classifications are based on the probability of a flammable concentration. The code assumes natural ventilation will dilute gases as they rise and dissipate. An open, unsealed pipe facilitates this natural ventilation.

Cable Gland

The Class I, Division 2 rated cable gland in your junction box is appropriate if that JB is within the Class I, Division 2 area.


Rigid Conduit and Seal-Off

Your use of rigid conduit with a poured seal-off between the junction box and the motor control panel (MCP) is crucial for preventing a potential explosion from propagating to the MCP. This is especially important because the MCP is outside of the Class I, Division 2 area and should not be exposed to a hazard.

3ft. and 5ft. are the minimum boundaries

You stated the distances were greater than these dimensions, that is an important detail and should be noted.

Where Your Position Could Be Challenged (and how to address it)



Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) Interpretation

The most significant factor. The AHJ has the final say. Present your reasoning clearly and be prepared to back it up with code citations.

"Intent of the Code"

Someone might argue that the intent of a seal-off is to prevent the
migration of gases. However, your design allows for migration within the defined hazardous area boundaries.

Vapor Density

You might be challenged based on the vapor density of the gasses that are produced by the wet well. However, vapor density is only a concern in a confined space. An open pipe allows the gasses to vent, which also cools them.

Maintenance Considerations

While not strictly code, consider long-term maintenance. If the cable needs replacing, does the open pipe create a significant hazard during that process?

Recommendations


Documentation

Thorough documentation is key. Include:
A clear diagram showing the wet well, the open pipe, the junction box, the conduit run, the seal-off, and the MCP.

Crucially, dimension the distances.
The hazardous area classification diagram showing the Class I, Division 1 and Class I, Division 2 boundaries. A detailed explanation of your reasoning, citing relevant NFPA 820 sections. Material certifications for all components used.2. Pre-Approval from AHJ

If possible, submit your design for review and approval
before* installation. This can save significant time and expense if there's a disagreement later.3.

Ventilation Calculation (Optional but Recommended)

While not explicitly required, performing a simple ventilation calculation (e.g., based on the pipe diameter and expected gas generation rate) can bolster your argument. This demonstrates that the open pipe provides adequate ventilation to maintain concentrations below the LEL outside the defined boundaries.4.

Consider a Flange Seal

Depending on the local AHJ and the specific circumstances, consider incorporating a flange seal at the point where the cable enters the junction box (on the wet-well side of the cable gland). This provides an extra level of protection, and may satisfy concerns of migration.

In summary, your interpretation of NFPA 820 appears sound, given the conditions you've described. The key is to clearly document your design, understand the AHJ's perspective, and be prepared to provide supporting justification.
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question