Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Arc Energy Reduction Requirement for Repurposed Equipment

User: sclaan, Location: Pennsylvania

Asked on: Wednesday, November 6, 2024 at 9:07 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:54 am EST

Question: First time poster. Hello.I am working on a project where a client wants to repurpose an electrical substation from one building to another. It will require dismantling of the HVL sections, transformer, and LV distributions sections to be reassembled. There are several OCPD that are 1200A and higher that were not originally required to have ERMS per article 240.87. I can't find anywhere that notes if this would require the equipment to be brought up to code and retrofitted with ERMS or if it would be considered "grandfathered". Any reference or direction would be appreciated.

Welcome to the forum! This is a good question that touches on a common issue.Here's the general principle and how it applies to your substation relocation scenario, along with relevant NEC guidance

General Principle: Equipment Compliance at Time of Installation
Generally, electrical equipment is required to comply with the NEC requirements in effect at the time it was originally installed. This is often referred to as the "grandfather clause." If the equipment met the code then, it's not automatically required to be upgraded to meet the current code just because the code has changed.

However, there are exceptions



Alterations and Renovations

The NEC makes a distinction between routine maintenance and alterations/renovations. When you perform significant alterations or renovations, some or all of the electrical system might need to be brought up to the current code.

Applying this to your substation relocation

Relocating a substation is

definitely
considered a significant alteration/renovation of the electrical system. This means the "grandfathering" protection likely doesn't apply, and you will need to meet current NEC requirements.

Specific NEC Considerations

While the NEC doesn't have a clearly defined term "grandfathering," there are sections that address the extent to which existing installations must comply with new rules:

90.4 Enforcement.
_"This Code is not intended as a design specification nor an instruction manual for untrained persons. This Code shall be permitted to be used by those who are qualified and properly trained to design and install electrical systems."_ 90.5(C) Mandatory Rules and Permissive Rules. _"Mandatory rules of this Code are characterized by the word “shall.” If a rule is of an advisory nature only, it is indicated by the word “should” or is stated as a recommendation in the commentary (Fine Print Note)."_ NEC Article 240.87. Arc Energy Reduction. This is the exact section you're dealing with. If the OCPDs you are re-installing are 1200A or higher and are operating at 1000V or less, and were not originally required to have ERMS, they almost certainly will need to be compliant now. This is because the act of moving and re-installing the equipment constitutes a new installation subject to the current code.

Key Considerations and Recommendations


Local Amendments and AHJ (Authority Having Jurisdiction)

This is critical. The NEC is a model code, and local jurisdictions can amend it. Some jurisdictions are stricter than others.

Consult with your local AHJ (the electrical inspector or building department) before starting the project.
Present your plan and ask about their interpretation of the code in this situation. They have the final say. Get it in writing if possible!2. Extent of the Renovation

The AHJ will likely want to know the
scope of the renovation. Are you just moving the existing substation as-is, or are you also replacing/upgrading other equipment? If you are replacing other equipment, it is more likely the entire substation needs to be brought up to code.3.

Safety Justification

If you believe that adding ERMS is not feasible or necessary, be prepared to justify your position. You might need to perform an arc flash risk assessment and demonstrate that the existing equipment is safe and that the risk of arc flash is low. However, the AHJ is likely to be resistant to this argument.4.

Documentation

Thoroughly document the existing equipment, its original installation date, and the relevant
NEC code in effect at that time. This information will be helpful in discussions with the AHJ.5.

Cost Implications

Be sure to factor in the cost of upgrading the OCPDs with ERMS (if required) in your project budget.

In summary, while the "grandfather clause" generally allows existing equipment to remain as is, relocating a substation is a significant renovation that likely requires compliance with the current
NEC*, including Article 240.87. Contacting your local AHJ for their specific requirements is paramount.


Good luck with your project! Let me know if you have any other questions. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question