User: mmm_max, Location: ridgecrest,ca
Asked on: Wednesday, November 6, 2024 at 10:46 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:55 am EST
Question: I found an old forum thread discussing running a three phase well motor being supplied by 208 vac to a 230 vac motor. My situation is that I have an antique Onan propane gen set handy at 208 three phase and as Edison in CA is horribly unreliable. I need water in an outage! The pump is 5 hp and the gen set is 4 cyl. Seems it should push 5 hp. The name plate on the gen set lists 18.75 kva. Amps as 52.0, PF=.8. The well motor specs are; kw=3.7 ,FL amps @ 200V=17.2, FL amps @ 230 =15. But it is Edison supplied with 240. I calc that the well motor kva is 3.4. Seems tiny. Am I nuts?
Okay, let's break this down step-by-step and see if we can determine if your plan is viable, and what considerations you need to be aware of.1. Generator Capacity vs. Motor Load
Generator KVA
Your generator is rated at 18.75 kVA. This is a good starting point. However, KVA doesn't directly translate to horsepower, but it does tell us the maximum apparent power the generator can provide.
Generator kW
To get the usable real power, multiply the KVA by the power factor: 18.75 kVA 0.8 = 15 kW. This is the real power the generator can continuously supply.
Motor kW
Your motor is rated at 3.7 kW.
Apparent Power of the Motor (kVA)
You calculated the motor's kVA as 3.4, which is correct based on the motor's kW rating. To verify, we can use the 230V amperage value: 230V 15A 1.732 (sqrt(3)) / 1000 = 5.97 kVA. This is the running kVA.
Important Consideration: Starting Current (Inrush)
This is the critical factor you're missing! Motors draw significantly more current when starting than when running at full load. This is often called the locked rotor amps (LRA) or inrush current. This inrush can be 5-7 times the full load amps (FLA). Without knowing the LRA, it's impossible to say for sure if your generator can start the motor.
How to Estimate Inrush
Check the Motor Nameplate
The best place to find the LRA is the motor's nameplate. It might be listed directly as LRA, or as a code letter (e.g., "Code G"). This code letter can be used to determine the LRA.
Consult Motor Documentation
If the nameplate doesn't have the LRA, consult the motor's technical documentation or the manufacturer's website.
Estimate (Worst Case)
If you can't find the actual LRA, you can estimate it as 6 times the FLA. In your case, that would be roughly 15A 6 = 90A. Using the 90 amps we can back calculate the KVA. 230V 90A 1.732 / 1000 = 35.87 kva. This inrush is very high and may be hard on the gen set.
2. Voltage Mismatch (208V Generator to 230V Motor)
This is also a critical point. While a slight voltage drop is acceptable (motors can often tolerate +/- 10%), running a 230V motor consistently on 208V will lead to:
Reduced Performance
The motor will produce less torque and horsepower.
Increased Current Draw
To compensate for the lower voltage and try to maintain the load, the motor will draw more current. This increased current creates more heat.
Overheating and Damage
Prolonged operation at a lower voltage can cause the motor to overheat and eventually fail.
3. Generator Loading
Continuous vs. Intermittent
Generators are typically rated for continuous output. However, running a generator continuously at its maximum rated capacity can shorten its lifespan. It's generally better to load it to around 70-80% of its rated capacity.
Propane Fuel
Propane-powered generators often have slightly lower power output compared to gasoline or diesel, especially at higher altitudes.
4. Things to check
1. Inspect the gen set wiring to verify it is in fact wired for 208. Some can be re-wired to 240.
2. Verify the gen set frequency is 60 hertz. Many older gen sets are 50 hertz. Running a 60 hz motor on 50 hz will likely burn it up in short order.
Summary of Recommendations
Find the LRA
This is the most crucial step. Without the LRA, you can't be sure if the generator can start the motor. Check the nameplate, motor documentation, or estimate based on 6x FLA.2.
Address the Voltage Mismatch
Running a 230V motor on 208V is not ideal.
Consider a Buck-Boost Transformer
A buck-boost transformer can step up the 208V to something closer to 230V. This will improve motor performance and longevity. You would need a three-phase transformer rated for at least the motor's running kVA (ideally, a bit larger to handle starting surges). Note: transformers introduce losses and additional cost.
Investigate Re-wiring the Generator
It is possible your generator may be able to be rewired to supply 240 volts. If the generator could produce 240 three phase you would be in much better shape.3.
Monitor Generator Performance
If you proceed, carefully monitor the generator's voltage and frequency while the motor is starting and running. Excessive voltage drop or frequency dips indicate the generator is being overloaded.4.
Professional Consultation
Consult with a qualified electrician or motor technician for a more definitive assessment of your specific situation. They can perform load calculations, assess the motor's starting characteristics, and recommend appropriate solutions.
In conclusion:
Your generator might be able to run the motor, IF the starting current is low enough. However, the voltage mismatch is a serious concern that needs to be addressed for reliable and safe operation. It is important to determine how to properly manage the voltage. Get a qualified professional opinion! Flag for review