Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: X-former neutral

User: eager2learn, Location: Mennifee,Ca

Asked on: Thursday, November 7, 2024 at 8:52 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:55 am EST

Question: We have a 3ph 208v circuit feeding a new transformer. The transformer was installed to pick up a neutral also rated at 208v on the secondary side. The transformer is 45kva delta wye. The existing amperage on the primary side is 175a. Can we utilize the existing feeder on the primary side and extend that circuit to an outside load that needs a neutral. If we extend the primary side through the transformer with double barrel mechanical chair lugs can we utilize the neutral on the secondary side of the transformer with the primary side conductors extending to the outside load. The outside load is a sub panel rated at 150a. The secondary side of the transformer feeds a120/208 100a panel. I hope this makes sense. All in all, is it legal to utilize the neutral on the secondary side with the primary side conductors in the same raceway considered it’s all in the transformer. Thank you in advance.

Okay, let's break this down. There are several code implications and safety concerns here, so this requires careful consideration.

Here's a summary of the situation as I understand it



Existing

You have a 3-phase, 208V circuit with 175A existing load that currently feeds a 45kVA Delta-Wye transformer.


Transformer

The transformer's secondary is 120/208V, providing a neutral. The secondary then feeds a 100A panel.

Proposed

You want to extend the
primary (208V) feeder of this transformer to a new 150A subpanel outside and then use the secondary neutral from the transformer for the new subpanel. All of this would be in the same raceway.

Here's why this is generally a bad idea and likely a code violation (based on the NEC - National Electrical Code)


Overcurrent Protection & Coordination



Primary Side Overload

While your existing primary side might be sufficient to feed the transformer at its rated load, running a 150A subpanel in addition to the transformer is likely going to overload the primary circuit. A 45kVA transformer on a 208V, 3-phase system has a full load primary current of about 125A (45000 / (208 1.732 0.9) -- assuming a power factor of 0.9). You said the existing load is 175a . You are likely overloading your existing conductors.

Secondary Side Overcurrent

You also mentioned that the secondary feeds a 100A panel. What this means is you have three possible places the conductors would need to be properly protected with overcurrent protection. The existing primary feeder, the 45kva transformer secondary and the 150a sub panel.2.

Neutral Sharing (and Grounding)



NEC 300.3(B)

This is the big one. The NEC generally requires that all conductors of a circuit, including the neutral (if any), be run together in the same raceway. Your proposal violates this. The neutral from the secondary side of the transformer is considered part of a separate circuit from the primary side. You cannot combine the primary phase conductors and the secondary neutral in the same raceway like this. This is a significant safety hazard, especially in the event of a ground fault.

Ground Fault Path

Combining primary and secondary conductors in this way can create an unintended ground fault path.


Transformer Grounding (NEC 250)

The transformer neutral must be properly grounded according to NEC 250 to establish a low-impedance ground fault path. This is separate from the grounding requirements for the primary side.3.

Voltage Drop

Extending the primary feeder to an outside panel adds to the voltage drop of the entire circuit, potentially impacting the performance of both the transformer and the outside subpanel. Voltage drop can be a big problem with 208V systems, especially with longer runs.4.

Tap Rules

Depending on the length of the conductors running from the primary breaker, it could also create a tap rule violation. Tap rules place limits on how far you can extend from the breaker without additional overcurrent protection.

Alternatives and Code-Compliant Solutions



Run a Separate Feeder

The
correct way to handle this is to run a completely separate, appropriately sized and protected feeder to the 150A subpanel from the main panel. This feeder would include its own neutral and ground conductors.

Upgrade the Existing Feeder

If the load calculations show you can't add the 150A subpanel without overloading the existing feeder, upgrade the feeder to a larger size to handle the total load. Then, run separate feeders to the transformer and the 150A subpanel. This will probably be more expensive but still the best route.

Separate Raceways

If,
in theory, you could find a way to make the transformer act as a code-compliant tap (extremely unlikely in this scenario, and still not recommended), the primary and secondary conductors must be run in separate raceways.

New Transformer Location

Move the transformer to a location closer to the load.

In Conclusion:


What you're proposing is almost certainly a violation of the NEC and poses significant safety risks. The NEC is extremely explicit on keeping circuits separated. Do not attempt to run the primary conductors and the secondary neutral in the same raceway to feed a separate panel. Run a separate feeder to the new subpanel, or upgrade the existing service if the load calculations require it. Contact a qualified electrician to make sure you meet your local and national electrical codes. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question