User: CBuchheit, Location: Portland, OR
Asked on: Thursday, November 7, 2024 at 2:42 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:57 am EST
Question: I'm building a UL 508A control panel and the customer wants to start the motor using the thermal switch in their motor as the overload device. That is of course allowed in section 34.1.3. The issue is they want to the contactor coil to go through this thermal switch and then use the *equipment ground wire* as the return path back to the control panel for this control circuit. They say they do it all the time and I don't doubt that it would work, but I can't imagine this is allowed by code. So what UL or NEC reference can I point to prove it isn't?
You are absolutely right to be concerned. Using the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) as a current-carrying conductor is a major safety violation. Here's a breakdown of why it's wrong and the relevant code references
Why It's Wrong (and Dangerous):
Compromised Grounding Path
The EGC is there solely to provide a low-impedance path for fault current in case of a short circuit. It's a safety net, not a normal conductor. Using it as a current-carrying conductor negates its ability to quickly and safely clear faults.
Electrocution Hazard
If the EGC is carrying normal operating current, any break or loose connection in the grounding path will energize everything connected to it. This creates a significant shock hazard. Even a small voltage drop across a loose connection can be dangerous.
False Sense of Security
Equipment connected to the system will appear to be grounded, but the grounding path may not be effective during a fault.
Increased Risk of EMI/RFI
Using the EGC for current can introduce noise into the grounding system, potentially affecting sensitive electronic equipment.
Relevant Codes and Standards
NEC (National Electrical Code)
Article 250: Grounding and Bonding
This entire article deals with the proper grounding and bonding of electrical systems. The core principle is that the EGC must not carry normal operating current.
250.6(A): Objectionable Current
While not a direct prohibition in this specific case, it clearly states that "Arrangements where objectionable current flows over grounding conductors shall be permitted only by one or more of the following:" and then lists exceptions, none of which apply to intentionally using the EGC as a circuit conductor. This implies strongly that such use is generally not permitted.
250.118 Types of Equipment Grounding Conductors
Only specifies acceptable conductor types.
250.120: Equipment Grounding Conductor Installation
(A) states that the EGC shall be installed in accordance with 300.3(B), meaning with the other circuit conductors.
UL 508A (Standard for Industrial Control Panels)
While UL 508A doesn't explicitly state "do not use the EGC as a current-carrying conductor" (it relies on the NEC for this), it does emphasize safety and proper wiring practices. A panel wired in this way would almost certainly fail inspection.
5.1.
2.6
Grounding and bonding jumpers or ground conductors in the control circuit are grounded to the grounded (neutral) circuit conductor or the equipment grounding conductor.*
66.1
The Equipment Grounding Circuit ConductorThe equipment grounding circuit conductor shall be of sufficient ampacity to safely conduct the ground fault current likely to be imposed on it, be mechanically rugged, and be effectively bonded to the electrical equipment enclosure.
How to Explain to the Customer
Safety First
Emphasize that this practice is a significant safety hazard and could lead to electrocution or equipment damage.2.
Code Violation
Explain that using the EGC as a current-carrying conductor is a clear violation of the NEC and likely other applicable codes.3.
Panel Certification
If you are building a UL 508A panel, explain that this wiring method would cause the panel to fail inspection and not receive UL certification.4.
Alternative Solution
Suggest a proper wiring method. Use a dedicated control wire from the control panel to the motor, through the thermal switch, and back to the control panel. This provides a complete and safe circuit. The thermal switch should open the circuit when an overload occurs. This method maintains the integrity of the EGC and ensures the safety of the system. Consider using a 2-wire cable for the control circuit.
Example Scenario to Illustrate the Danger
Imagine a scenario where the connection to the motor frame becomes slightly loose or corroded. The motor frame will become energized, and anyone touching it could receive a shock. If a fault to ground happens while the EGC is carrying current, it could lead to a much more dangerous situation than if the EGC was solely dedicated to its fault-clearing function.
In summary: Don't do it. It's unsafe, illegal, and unprofessional. Use a proper control wire for the thermal switch circuit. Your customer may have "always done it that way," but that doesn't make it right. Focus on safety and compliance with applicable codes. Flag for review