User: electricalintern, Location: PA
Asked on: Thursday, November 7, 2024 at 5:55 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:57 am EST
Question: The current service setup is (2) 200 AMP/208V/3P (two tenant spaces each), but now there’s a need to upgrade the service from the electrical room to the tenant spaces to 400 AMP/208V/3P.The township electrical inspector and building engineers have approved the drawings.However, the electrician installed MC cable for the 400 AMP upgraded service in the electrical room rather than the conduit specified in the approved drawings.The existing electrical room setup only includes galvanized hard conduit.Is it acceptable to use MC cable for the 400 AMP service, or should it strictly follow the approved drawings showing 2 sets of (4#3/0 + 1#1/0 G in 4" conduit)?What are the advantages and disadvantages of using MC cable compared to conduit in this scenario?
This is a tricky situation, and here's a breakdown of the issues and considerations
Legality & Approval:
The Approved Drawings are King (Unless Properly Amended)
The fact that the township electrical inspector and building engineers approved drawings showing conduit is the primary factor here. Technically, the electrician deviated from the approved plans and a change order needs to be submitted to the township. The install is not up to code, and the electrician has to adhere to what was reviewed by the township, unless, the township is willing to review a change order. If the township doesn't approve, it'll need to be removed and properly installed.
Inspector Discretion (Possible, but Risky)
An inspector might be willing to approve the MC cable installation if it meets all code requirements and safety standards for the application, and a change order needs to be created. However, this is entirely at their discretion. They may have had a specific reason for requiring conduit in the original plans. Trying to get approval after the fact is always harder.
Liability
Deviating from approved plans without documented approval opens up liability issues for the electrician, the building owner, and potentially the engineer of record. If something goes wrong in the future, this deviation could be scrutinized.
Technical Considerations: MC Cable vs. Conduit
Here's a comparison to help understand why conduit might have been specified
MC Cable (Metal-Clad Cable) Advantages:
Faster Installation
Generally, MC cable is faster to install than conduit, especially for long runs with bends. It's more flexible and requires fewer fittings.
Lower Labor Costs
Faster installation usually translates to lower labor costs.
Flexibility
MC cable is more flexible than rigid conduit, making it easier to navigate around obstacles.
MC Cable Disadvantages
Limited Ampacity per Cable
MC cable has limitations on the maximum ampacity it can handle per cable size. To achieve 400A at 208V, you may need more runs of MC cable compared to conduit, depending on the specific cable size used.
Potential for Damage
While MC cable has a metal jacket, it's generally less robust than conduit against physical damage, especially in high-traffic areas or where there's a risk of impact.
Heat Dissipation
Conduit can provide better heat dissipation for high current conductors, which can be important for ampacity rating and long-term reliability.
Grounding Issues
Proper grounding of MC cable is critical. The metal jacket serves as the equipment grounding conductor (EGC), so connections must be tight and reliable.
Code Restrictions
Some jurisdictions or specific applications may restrict the use of MC cable due to local codes or building requirements.
Future Modifications
It's harder to add or replace wires within MC cable after it's installed compared to conduit. Conduit allows for easier future modifications.
Conduit (Rigid or EMT) Advantages
Superior Protection
Conduit provides excellent physical protection for conductors against damage from impact, abrasion, moisture, and other environmental factors.
Higher Ampacity Potential
Allows for larger conductors, potentially fewer parallel runs.
Better Heat Dissipation
Helps dissipate heat generated by conductors, which can increase ampacity ratings and improve conductor lifespan.
Easier Future Modifications
Allows for easy addition, replacement, or rerouting of conductors in the future.
Grounding Path
Provides a reliable, low-impedance ground path for equipment grounding.
Code Requirements
Some applications or building types require conduit for specific wiring methods.
Appearance
In some situations, conduit offers a more aesthetically pleasing and professional appearance than MC cable.
Conduit Disadvantages
Higher Installation Costs
More labor-intensive to install, requiring cutting, bending, threading, and fitting.
Less Flexible
More difficult to route around obstacles.
Time Consuming
Conduit takes much longer to install than MC cable, and therefore more expensive.
Why Conduit Might Have Been Specified in Your Case
Consider these possibilities for why conduit was specified in the approved drawings:
Durability Requirements
The electrical room environment may have been deemed to require the superior protection of conduit due to potential physical damage risks.
Heat Dissipation Concerns
The engineers may have calculated that conduit would provide better heat dissipation for the 400A service, especially if the conductors are running at or near their maximum ampacity.
Future Expansion
Conduit allows for easier addition or replacement of conductors in the future.
Building Codes or Local Ordinances
The township may have specific codes or ordinances that require conduit for high-ampacity service entrances in commercial buildings.
Aesthetics
Conduit can be installed in a more organized and visually appealing manner in an electrical room.
Recommendations
Immediately Contact the Electrician
Discuss the deviation from the approved drawings. Find out why they chose MC cable. Ask them if they considered the ampacity requirements and calculated the number of runs needed.2.
Document Everything
Keep records of all communication, deviations, and approvals (or lack thereof).3.
Contact the Electrical Inspector and Building Engineer
Explain the situation and ask if they will consider approving the MC cable installation after a change order is submitted. Provide them with any information the electrician has regarding the ampacity and grounding calculations for the MC cable. Be prepared to explain why the change was made and to address any concerns they may have.4.
Be Prepared to Redo the Installation
If the inspector and engineer are not willing to approve the MC cable installation, the electrician will need to remove it and install the conduit as originally specified in the approved drawings. The township has the final decision, and what's been reviewed by the inspector needs to be followed.5.
Safety First
Regardless of whether the MC cable is approved or not, ensure that the installation meets all applicable electrical codes and safety standards. Pay close attention to grounding requirements.
In conclusion: The safest and most compliant approach is to adhere to the approved drawings, and if a change is desired or needed, it needs to be reviewed by the township as a change order. Without proper approval, you risk having the installation rejected, incurring additional costs, and potentially creating safety hazards. Focus on communication and getting the necessary approvals before* proceeding further. Flag for review