Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Panel Feed 800A MLO

User: PanelGuy1315, Location: Louisville

Asked on: Friday, November 8, 2024 at 7:04 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:59 am EST

Question: I am working on multiple projects for existing facilities where we are to add a new panelboard (iLine 800A MLO) that will be fed by a new breaker we are adding to the existing distribution panel. This new panelboard is for material handling equipment only (480v, 3ph) and will contain Qty8 30A breakers as a standard. For one particular project, our bid department only included a 50A feed to the new 800A MLO because the FLA of the equipment is only at 29A.Is it ridiculous to feed a 800A MLO with a 50A feed? Looking through iLine catalog, I'm not necessarily seeing much smaller sizes like 100A, 150A, 200A, etc.Do they just put a tag on the panel to derate it to 50A?There will be plenty of available breaker slots on this thing when we are done and I just worry someone will think there is plenty of capacity to add more loads.Thanks for your help!

Yes, feeding an 800A MLO panelboard with a 50A breaker is unconventional and potentially problematic, even if the initial load is only 29A. Here's a breakdown of why

Why it's a bad idea (even if it technically "works" at first):
Future Expansion

This is your primary concern, and rightly so. Panelboards are meant to be flexible and allow for future expansion. Labeling a panel as "50A Max Feed" doesn't guarantee someone won't ignore it, especially down the line when the original designer isn't around. If someone adds loads without understanding the limitation, they will overload the 50A feeder, tripping the breaker and potentially causing a dangerous situation.


Misleading Impression

An 800A panel board visually implies a large capacity. A 50A feed creates a misleading impression of the available power. People often assume the panel's rating is indicative of its available capacity.

Nuisance Tripping

Even if the current load stays at 29A, minor fluctuations or inrush currents (especially with motor loads) could cause the 50A breaker to trip unnecessarily, even without exceeding its continuous rating. This is especially true if the 50A breaker is older or not designed for motor loads.


Code Compliance (Gray Area)

While it may technically meet the minimum code requirements in some interpretations (sizing the feeder for the load), it violates the spirit of the code, which intends for installations to be done safely and with reasonable foresight for future use. A very strict inspector might flag this.

Resale Value

If the facility is ever sold, a potential buyer might be confused by the mismatch in the panel rating and the feeder size. It could raise questions and concerns during due diligence.


Heat Dissipation

While a 50A load in an 800A panel won't generate excessive heat in the panel itself, the heat generated in the 50A breaker feeding the panel will be a factor. A 50A breaker at full load needs to dissipate heat properly. This could be a concern if the breaker is enclosed in a tight, poorly ventilated distribution panel.

Practicality

You mentioned that the panel will contain eight 30A breakers. If anyone ever decides to use even
two of those 30A breakers to near their capacity at the same time, you'll be well over the 50A feed limit.

Motor Starting Currents

Motor starting currents are typically 3-6 times the full load current. If even a small motor starts up, it could momentarily exceed the 50A feeder rating, causing a trip.

Harmonics

Even with modern VFDs, some harmonics can be present. These harmonics contribute to the overall heating of conductors and equipment, potentially leading to earlier failures or nuisance tripping.

Why your bid department might have done this (and why it's still wrong)



Cost Cutting

The most likely reason is to save money on the feeder conductors, conduit, and breaker. They focused solely on the immediate load requirement, disregarding future needs and best practices.

Misunderstanding of Code

They might have misinterpreted the code to allow the smallest possible feeder size based solely on the connected load.

What You Should Do


Push Back

Explain the potential issues listed above to your bid department and management. Emphasize the long-term costs and risks associated with undersizing the feeder. Use technical arguments and potential code violation concerns.2.

Suggest an Appropriate Size

Recommend a more appropriately sized feeder breaker and conductors. Something in the 150A-200A range would be far more reasonable for an 800A panelboard with multiple 30A breakers, even if the initial load is low. A 150A/200A feeder gives room for future additions of load.3.

Check Available i-Line Panelboard Options

While you might not find
exactly the perfect size, check the i-Line catalog again. Sometimes, they offer "downsized" versions or configurations of their panels. It's possible there's a similar panelboard with a smaller main lug or factory-installed main breaker that's more appropriately rated (e.g., 225A or 400A).4.

Proper Labeling

IF you are forced to stick with the 50A feed (which you should strongly resist), the labeling MUST be extremely clear and prominent. The label should state: "MAXIMUM FEEDER BREAKER: 50 AMPS" "THIS PANELBOARD IS ONLY RATED FOR A MAXIMUM OF 50 AMPS TOTAL LOAD" "DO NOT ADD ADDITIONAL LOADS WITHOUT CONSULTING A QUALIFIED ELECTRICIAN"5.

Documentation

Document everything! Keep a record of your concerns, your recommendations, and the reasons why the decision was made to use the 50A feed. This will protect you if problems arise later.6.

Consider a Smaller Panelboard

If space and budget allow, it might be more practical to use a smaller panelboard, such as a 225A or 400A panelboard, that more closely matches the expected load. This would avoid the misleading impression of the 800A panelboard.

In Summary:


Feeding an 800A panelboard with a 50A breaker is a bad practice. It's shortsighted, potentially dangerous, and creates a maintenance headache down the line. Fight for a more appropriately sized feeder to ensure a safe and reliable installation that can accommodate future needs. If you are stuck with the 50A feed, make sure that the panel is labeled clearly. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question