Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Upsizing feeder wire and GND for voltage drop

User: PanelGuy1315, Location: Louisville

Asked on: Friday, November 8, 2024 at 10:43 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 4:59 am EST

Question: I need help from wire sizing gurus. I've had this same question come up multiple times when designing a feeder to control panel.Say a large MCP needs a 400A feed from a distribution panel 1000' away (distance inflated to make point). Without taking voltage drop into account we would typically size the feed to 2 sets of 3/0 with a #3 GND in each conduit.When I adjust feeder wire size to keep voltage drop below 3%, I come up with 2 sets of 600kcmil. I also have read that I need to increase GND wire size by the same ratio as I increased the feeder wires.How would you do this with the parallel feed? I went from 3/0 to 600kcmil, which I calculate as a 3.57 factor increase (by cir mils). Do I increase the #3 GND in each conduit by 3.57 factor? I'm coming up with needing a GND wire with 188,152 cirmils which would be a 4/0 wire.Thanks for your input.

You're on the right track, but there are some nuances and clarifications needed. Let's break it down

Understanding the Code and the Problem
Feeder Sizing

You're correctly considering both ampacity and voltage drop when sizing your feeder.


Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC) vs. Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC)

It sounds like you are speaking of an Equipment Grounding Conductor, not a Grounding Electrode Conductor.

Parallel Conductors

When paralleling conductors, the
effective ampacity is the sum of the ampacities of each conductor, derated as necessary.

Voltage Drop

Keeping voltage drop under 3% is a good design practice, but it's not strictly a requirement of the NEC except in very specific circumstances (e.g., sensitive electronic equipment). It's a performance issue more than a safety one.

NEC Considerations
NEC 250.122(B)

This is the section that governs the increase in size of equipment grounding conductors where the ungrounded conductors are increased in size to compensate for voltage drop. The rule applies
when the overcurrent protection device (OCPD) is increased as a result of the increase in conductor size. This is an exception to the normal EGC sizing based on OCPD rating.

NEC 310.10(H)(5)(b)

"If the ungrounded circuit conductors are increased in size from the minimum size that has sufficient ampacity for the intended load, based on 310.16, the equipment grounding conductor(s) shall be increased in size proportionately, according to the circular mil area of the ungrounded circuit conductors."

Here's how to apply the code to your situation
1. Base Case

400A Load. 3/0 AWG copper conductors are rated to 200A per conductor at 75°C. Paralleling two sets will give you a total of 400A of ampacity. #3 AWG EGC. Voltage drop exceeds 3%.2.

Increased Conductor Size for Voltage Drop

You determine that 600 kcmil conductors are needed to meet your voltage drop target.3.

Calculating the Proportional Increase



Circular Mils

Circular mils are a measure of the cross-sectional area of a conductor. You're on the right track with using circular mils for the proportional increase. 3/0 AWG = 167,800 circular mils (approximate) 600 kcmil = 600,000 circular mils

Ratio

600,000 / 167,800 = 3.576 (approximately). You're correct in calculating this ratio.
4.


Applying the Increase to the Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC)

#3 AWG = 52,620 circular mils (approximate) Required circular mils for EGC: 52,620 3.576 = 188,257 circular mils (approximate).
5.


Selecting the New EGC Size

Now, find the smallest standard wire size with a circular mil area equal to or greater than 188,257 circular mils. 4/0 AWG = 211,600 circular mils.Therefore, you would need a 4/0 EGC for each raceway.

Important Considerations and Clarifications
Multiple Raceways

Remember that you have
two raceways in your parallel run. You must run the increased EGC size (#4/0) in each raceway.

Alternative Approach

A valid alternative exists that can simplify the calculation. Instead of calculating and applying a multiplier based on circular mils, you could simply calculate the amount of voltage drop in each raceway with the original wire size. After that, calculate the factor to reduce the voltage drop to the 3% target by increasing wire size. Apply that same factor to the EGC.

Conduit Fill

Be mindful of conduit fill when increasing conductor sizes. Make sure your conduit can accommodate the larger conductors.


Engineering Judgment

The NEC provides minimum standards. You, as the designer, are responsible for making sound engineering decisions. If you have concerns about grounding effectiveness, you might choose to use a larger EGC than the minimum required by code.

In Summary


You're on the right track with your calculations. Based on your scenario, you would need a 4/0 EGC in each of the two conduits to meet the requirements of NEC 250.122(B) where the ungrounded conductors are increased in size to compensate for voltage drop. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question