Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: How to land on breaker

User: Crash117, Location: Nevada

Asked on: Friday, November 8, 2024 at 1:12 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:00 am EST

Question: I looked at a job today to install transfer switch for a generator and all that comes along with that. Tricky part is it’s a 200amp service in a meter main type panel. Is the best route to put a 200 amp breaker in that panel and then send to transfer switch and a second panel? There’s no way to separate the incoming feed from the meter portion of the meter main panel and send it to transfer switch. The customer wants to power entire house and I’m trying to find the best way to get them what they want without having to change out the existing meter main. Thanks for any ideas and thoughts.

Okay, this is a common situation and you're right to think it through carefully. Here's a breakdown of the common solutions, their pros and cons, and some important considerations

The Goal:
Provide whole-house generator backup power while complying with NEC (National Electrical Code). Avoid replacing the existing meter main panel if possible. Meet the customer's desire for full backup.

Solution #1: Subpanel with 200A Breaker in Meter Main (Most Common & Recommended)
Description

1. Install a 200A breaker in the existing meter main panel. This breaker will feed the automatic transfer switch (ATS).
2. From the ATS, run conductors to a new 200A subpanel. This subpanel will become the "critical loads" panel, essentially powering the entire house.3. Move all existing branch circuits from the meter main panel to the new subpanel.4. The ATS switches between the utility feed (through the 200A breaker in the meter main) and the generator.


Pros

Relatively straightforward installation. Avoids replacing the meter main (significant cost savings). Provides full house backup, assuming the generator is sized appropriately. Meets code requirements when installed correctly (especially regarding bonding/grounding). You can use a standard 200A ATS.

Cons

Requires moving all branch circuits to the new subpanel. This can be labor-intensive and time-consuming. Requires enough physical space for the new subpanel and ATS, usually adjacent to the meter main. You will lose the use of spaces for breakers in the existing meter main.

Important Considerations



Neutral-Ground Bond

Critically important. The neutral-ground bond must be present only in the service equipment (the meter main). The subpanel

must not
have a neutral-ground bond. The ATS typically switches the neutral for this reason. Verify the ATS you select properly handles the neutral. Overcurrent Protection

The 200A breaker in the meter main protects the conductors feeding the ATS and the subpanel.


Conductor Sizing

Size conductors appropriately for the 200A load, considering ampacity and voltage drop.

Generator Sizing

Make absolutely sure the generator is adequately sized for the entire house load. Load calculations are essential. Consider using a load management system to shed non-essential loads during generator operation if the generator capacity is marginal.


Permitting and Inspection

This work always requires a permit and inspection.

Short Circuit Current Rating (SCCR)

Ensure the subpanel and ATS have a SCCR rating sufficient for the available fault current at the service. This is a critical safety consideration.

Solution #2: Load Shedding ATS with Existing Panel (Less Desirable for Whole-House Backup)
Description

1. Install a smaller ATS (e.g., 100A or 150A) fed from a new breaker in the meter main.
2. Install a limited number of critical circuits into the ATS and power them from the generator through the ATS.3. Use a load shedding system to prioritize circuits during generator operation. This can be done with contactors or smart panels.


Pros

Potentially less expensive than Solution #1. Avoids moving all branch circuits. Might be suitable if the customer has a very small number of essential circuits.

Cons

Doesn't provide full house backup, which is what the customer wants. Requires careful planning and programming of load shedding. Can be confusing for the homeowner to understand which circuits are powered and when. Still requires adding a breaker in the meter main.

Important Considerations

Load calculations are absolutely critical to determine which circuits can be supported by the generator and the ATS. Reliability of the load shedding system is paramount. Requires a good understanding of load management technology.

Solution #3: Replacing the Meter Main with a Meter/ATS Combination Unit (Potentially More Expensive, But Clean)
Description

1. Replace the existing meter main with a combination meter/automatic transfer switch unit. These are available from various manufacturers (e.g., Generac, Eaton).
2. These units typically have a built-in 200A ATS and load center.3. The generator connects directly to the unit.


Pros

Clean and integrated solution. May save space compared to separate components. Can be easier to install than separate ATS and subpanel in some cases. Potentially simplifies wiring.

Cons

More expensive than Solution #1 in many cases, as it involves replacing the meter main. Requires coordination with the utility company. They may have specific requirements for meter socket types and placement. May require more lead time to obtain the specific meter/ATS combination unit. May require an electrician with experience installing these types of units.

Important Considerations



Utility Company Approval

This is the most important consideration. Contact the utility before you even quote the job. They may have a list of approved manufacturers and models, and specific requirements for the installation. The neutral-ground bond is typically handled within the meter/ATS unit. Same considerations for conductor sizing and generator sizing apply. SCCR rating is critical.

Which Solution is Best?


Given the customer's desire for whole-house backup, Solution #1 (200A breaker to ATS to subpanel) is likely the best option
if the budget allows and if there's sufficient space for the new subpanel and ATS. It provides the most flexibility and meets the customer's needs while minimizing the disruption.

Key Steps


Load Calculation

Perform a thorough load calculation for the entire house to determine the required generator size. This is the foundation for everything else.2.

Generator Sizing

Based on the load calculation, select an appropriately sized generator. Err on the side of caution and choose a generator with a bit of extra capacity.3.

Space Assessment

Carefully assess the available space for the new subpanel and ATS.4.

Component Selection

Choose high-quality components (ATS, subpanel, breakers, conductors) that are properly rated for the application.5.

Utility Coordination (if considering solution #3)

Contact the utility company
immediately if considering replacing the meter main.6.

Permitting and Inspection

Obtain all necessary permits and schedule inspections.7.

Thorough Wiring and Grounding

Pay meticulous attention to wiring and grounding. Proper grounding and bonding are essential for safety.8.

Testing and Commissioning

After installation, thoroughly test the entire system to ensure it operates correctly. Demonstrate the system to the homeowner and provide clear instructions for its operation.

Important Safety Considerations



Qualified Electrician

This work should only be performed by a licensed and experienced electrician who is familiar with generator installations and the NEC.

Lockout/Tagout

Always use proper lockout/tagout procedures when working on electrical systems.


Grounding and Bonding

Ensure proper grounding and bonding throughout the system. This is critical for safety.

CO Detectors

Make sure the home has working carbon monoxide detectors, especially near sleeping areas.


Generator Placement:
The generator must be located in a well-ventilated area, away from doors and windows, to prevent carbon monoxide poisoning.Good luck with the project! Take your time, plan carefully, and prioritize safety. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question