User: Smash, Location: Philadelphia suburbs, PA USA
Asked on: Friday, November 8, 2024 at 9:00 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:02 am EST
Question: Doing a warehouse with about 50 UFO lights replacing T5s This is an older building with a 3 phase delta high leg. The T5s didn’t seem to mind the high leg two phases were always 240VI wasn’t taking any chances and arranged the breakers so no high leg would be used. Everything going fine then had one as you plug it in flicker a little then nothing. Checked voltage everything was fine. After a couple more I set up a bench power supply and as I was building them (twist lock plugs ) I would test them. Two would work fine then the 3rd nothing. I’ve now installed 22 fixtures and 6 would not fire. So far the ones that do work continue to work. But the random ones brand new same everything don’t work. I’m at a loss my best guess is an older possibly cheap driver likes a neutral better than a hot. Rewiring to 120V would be a time consuming pain in the ass. Anyone ever had this problem.
This is a really perplexing situation. Here's a breakdown of the issues, some troubleshooting steps, and potential solutions, given the information you've provided
Understanding the Potential Problems
High Leg Delta Issues
While the T5s seemed fine, a high-leg delta can cause problems for electronic devices, especially if they aren't designed to tolerate the voltage imbalance. Even though you arranged breakers to avoid the high leg, the overall system's grounding and neutral configuration can still influence the behavior of these lights.
UFO Light Quality and Driver Sensitivity
You rightly suspect the drivers. Cheaper LED drivers can be very sensitive to voltage fluctuations, harmonics, and other power quality issues. High-leg delta systems are often more susceptible to these problems. The fact that some lights work fine and others don't, despite being the same model, points to manufacturing variability in the drivers.
Neutral/Grounding Issues
In a delta system, the neutral (if derived from a transformer tap) is especially critical. Even a slightly poor neutral connection can lead to voltage imbalances, causing flickering or failure. While it shouldn't be required on a 240V supply, the internal circuitry of some cheaper drivers might be relying on a stable ground reference that's being compromised in your situation.
Harmonics and Power Quality
LED lights, especially cheaper ones, can inject significant harmonics back into the power system. This can exacerbate existing power quality problems in an older building, potentially overloading the neutral or causing voltage distortion.
Inrush Current
LED drivers have an inrush current when they first turn on. If the branch circuit breaker is borderline (even if it should be adequate), repeated inrush current from multiple lights could potentially weaken the breaker over time. It sounds like this is happening right away though so not as likely.
Defective Lights
As you've already identified, some units may simply be defective from the factory. The high failure rate suggests this could be a contributing factor, particularly if you're using a budget brand.
Troubleshooting Steps1. Double-Check Wiring
Polarity
Verify that the hot and neutral wires are connected correctly to the lights. Though they should be dual voltage and be wired for 240 either polarity should work.
Connections
Make sure all connections are tight and secure, especially at the breaker panel, junction boxes, and light fixtures. Use a torque screwdriver to ensure proper tightness.
Grounding
Ensure that the lights are properly grounded. Verify that the ground wire is securely connected to the fixture's ground terminal and that the grounding system is properly connected throughout the building.2.
Power Quality Analysis
Voltage Imbalance
Even though you're not using the high leg, measure the voltage between each phase and ground. A significant imbalance could indicate a problem with the transformer or the distribution system.
Harmonic Distortion
Use a power quality analyzer to measure voltage and current harmonic distortion. Excessive harmonics can cause a variety of problems with electronic equipment.
Voltage Fluctuations
Monitor the voltage over time to see if there are any dips, spikes, or surges that could be damaging the lights.
Neutral Current
Measure the current flowing through the neutral conductor (if you have one). Excessive neutral current can indicate a problem with unbalanced loads or harmonics.3.
Driver Testing and Compatibility
Driver Specifications
Carefully review the driver specifications for the UFO lights. Pay attention to the input voltage range, frequency range, and power factor.
Isolation Testing
If possible, test the drivers in isolation with a known good power source (e.g., a laboratory power supply). This can help determine if the driver itself is the problem.
Driver Replacement
If you suspect the drivers are the issue, try replacing them with higher-quality drivers from a reputable manufacturer.
Manufacturer Consultation
Contact the manufacturer of the UFO lights and explain the problem you're experiencing. They may have encountered similar issues with high-leg delta systems.
Brand Research
Check online reviews and forums to see if other users have reported similar problems with these lights in high-leg delta systems.4.
Breaker Evaluation
Breaker Size
Ensure the breaker size is appropriate for the load (number of lights on the circuit) and wiring gauge.
Breaker Condition
Test the breaker to ensure it's functioning correctly and not tripping prematurely. Replace any faulty breakers.
Potential Solutions Voltage Stabilization
Install a voltage regulator or line conditioner to stabilize the voltage and reduce voltage fluctuations. This can help protect the lights from damage.
Harmonic Mitigation
Install harmonic filters to reduce harmonic distortion. This can improve power quality and prevent problems with other equipment.
Neutral Improvement
Improve the neutral connection to the transformer. Ensure that the neutral conductor is properly sized and grounded.
Driver Upgrade
Replace the existing drivers with higher-quality drivers that are more tolerant of voltage fluctuations and power quality issues.
Individual Surge Protection
Add surge protection devices at each light fixture.
Transformer Upgrade
Consider replacing the existing transformer with a wye-connected transformer that provides a true neutral. This is a more expensive solution but can provide the best overall power quality.
120V Rewiring
This is a last resort, but it might be the most reliable solution if you continue to have problems with the 240V system. It involves rewiring the lighting circuits to 120V and installing a new neutral conductor.
Product Return/Exchange
Given the high failure rate, pursue returning the non-functional lights and potentially switching to a different brand or model known for better quality and compatibility.
Recommendations1. Start with Power Quality Analysis
Get a comprehensive power quality analysis done by a qualified electrician or electrical engineer. This will help you identify the root cause of the problem.2.
Focus on the Drivers
Since the symptoms point towards driver issues, prioritize driver testing and replacement.3.
Document Everything
Keep detailed records of your troubleshooting steps, measurements, and any changes you make to the system. This will help you track progress and identify any patterns.4.
Consult Professionals: Don't hesitate to consult with a qualified electrician or electrical engineer who has experience with high-leg delta systems and LED lighting.Good luck! It sounds frustrating, but with a systematic approach, you should be able to find a solution. Flag for review