User: hungryeng, Location: Madison
Asked on: Saturday, November 9, 2024 at 5:26 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:02 am EST
Question: I am working with a 2800KWAc PV system and have been looking into whether SPDs are required on the AC Combiner.Here is the whole system: 14 Inverters of 200KW, combined into 2 AC Combiners (7 per combiner). Those two inverters are connected to a XFMR tied to the utility.Do I NEED to have a Surge Protection Device on the ACPs and why? In what case don't I need it? For clarity, the inverters are equiped with both DC and AC SPDs.Thanks in advance
Okay, let's break down the NEC requirements for AC SPDs on your combiner panels in your 2800 kWac PV system. Your situation is relatively common, and understanding the code is crucial.
NEC Requirements and Justification
The primary NEC section that governs this is NEC 690.125 (Surge Protection). Let's look at the relevant sub-sections: 690.125(A)
"PV systems shall be provided with surge protection in accordance with 690.125(B) through (E)."
690.125(B)
"Where the PV system is installed on or integrated with a building or structure, surge protection shall be provided to protect the PV system components."
690.125(C)
"A surge protection device (SPD) shall be installed in the following locations: (1) At the DC PV system disconnecting means (2) At the AC PV system disconnecting means
690.125(D) Where the AHJ requires and the AHJ determines that the structure served by the PV system is subject to lightning or transient overvoltage surges."Analysis of Your System
Given your system description:1. Building-Mounted PV System Implication
Since you're combining the outputs of multiple inverters into AC combiner panels, which are then connected to a transformer tied to the utility grid, it's highly likely that the PV system is
"installed on or integrated with a building or structure." Unless these combiners and inverters are physically located on a utility pole in the middle of a field, they're almost certainly considered building-integrated or building-mounted by the NEC.2. AC Combiner Panel Role
Your AC combiner panels act as an
AC PV system disconnecting means because they're used to combine the output of multiple inverters and connect to the transformer.3. Inverter SPDs
The fact that your inverters have integrated AC and DC SPDs is helpful, but likely not sufficient to eliminate the need for SPDs at the combiner panels. Inverter SPDs are generally designed to protect the inverter itself, not the entire AC distribution system leading to the transformer and ultimately the grid. Furthermore, you could argue that the AHJ might require SPDs for transient voltage protection.
Therefore, based on a straightforward reading of NEC 690.125, SPDs ARE likely required on your AC combiner panels.When Might You Not Need SPDs on the Combiner Panels?
There are only a few scenarios where you might be able to avoid SPDs at the combiner panels, and you'll need strong documentation to support it: Stand-Alone System, No Building Integration, No Requirement from AHJ If your PV system is truly a stand-alone system, with no connection to any building and the AHJ doesn't require it (e.g., a completely off-grid system installed on a vacant lot), then 690.125(B) might not apply, but this is highly unlikely with a 2.8MW system. AHJ Approval Based on Risk Assessment
The only reliable way to potentially avoid the SPD requirement is to get a written exception from the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ). You would need to present a very strong engineering justification for why SPDs are not necessary and why the risk of damage is acceptably low. This would likely involve a detailed risk assessment, possibly a lightning protection study, and demonstrating that the existing inverter SPDs provide sufficient protection for the entire system. This is a tough sell, as AHJs are generally conservative on surge protection.
Recommendations1. Default to Compliance
Assume you need SPDs on the AC combiner panels unless you get written confirmation from the AHJ otherwise.2.
Consult the AHJ
The most important step is to contact your local electrical inspector or building department (the AHJ) and discuss your specific system design. Get their interpretation of the code requirements in writing. This will save you a lot of headaches later.3.
Document Everything
Keep thorough documentation of your system design, discussions with the AHJ, and any justifications for not including SPDs (if you pursue that route).4.
SPD Selection
If you are required to install SPDs, make sure they are properly sized and rated for your system's voltage and current. Choose SPDs that are UL 1449 Listed and have a suitable Surge Current Capacity (SCCR) rating.5.
SPD Location
The closer the SPD is to the equipment it's protecting, the better. Mounting them inside the combiner panel is ideal.6.
Coordinate Protection
Ensure coordination between all SPDs in the system (inverter SPDs, combiner SPDs, service entrance SPDs, etc.). You want the SPDs closest to the surge source to activate first, preventing damage to downstream equipment.
Why are SPDs important even with Inverter SPDs? Cascading Protection
SPDs work best as part of a coordinated protection scheme. Think of it as a defense in depth.
Residual Overvoltage
Even after an SPD activates, there can still be a small residual overvoltage that can damage sensitive electronics.
Common-Mode vs. Differential-Mode
SPDs address both common-mode (line-to-ground) and differential-mode (line-to-line) surges. Inverters SPDs might not cover both adequately.
System-Wide Protection
SPDs at the combiner panels help protect the entire AC distribution system, not just the inverters.
In summary, the NEC strongly suggests you need SPDs at your AC combiner panels. Talk to your AHJ, document their requirements, and design a robust surge protection scheme for your system. Ignoring this could lead to code violations, system damage, and even safety hazards. Flag for review