User: LightsOn81, Location: North Carolina
Asked on: Sunday, November 10, 2024 at 1:43 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:03 am EST
Question: This will be a good bit for a “first“ post.Im troubleshooting a Zurn flush valve on a urinal. When the flusher is connected to the low voltage power supply AND the urinal, it will not work.When the flusher is disconnected from the urinal it works fine. When the flusher is connected to another urinal, the flusher works fine.The flush valves are on their own circuit. Supply conductors are installed in EMT, EGC pulled and connected clean and text book. Transformer is mounted to a 4sq box per manufacturer instructions. Low voltage terminations are clean, in J Box. Total length of the low voltage cable is well within the allowable length.I’ve taken the flush valve while energized and reconnected it to the urinal and I’ve watched the red LED indicator flicker and go out as I’ve tightened the nut down that attaches the flusher to the valve body.I pulled new cable and get the same result.the flusher has been replaced this is the second one. Same result.i free aired the cable and have eliminated the possiblit’s of something in the wall or conduit.I measured voltage and read 5 VDC on the valve body while the flusher is attached.I wrapped the threads of the male connection side of the valve body with 33 to create a dielectric break and, now, the flusher will work but still read 3VDC on the valve body. Can’t leave the tape because the flusher will leak.The chrome on the valve body and flusher both have what looks like the effects of electrolysis ( like someone wiped grease off and it left streaks) on both components.the transformer supplying this urinal also supplies 4 other toilets and 1 urinal. Max on these toilets is 6. 1 feed off the transformer is spliced and goes 3 different directions. Only this urinal has an issue. There’s a total of 40 sensors in this building all installed the same way and this is the only place with an issue.I think it’s a low impedance ground fault, as if the water supply to this toilet is touching something somewhere else (rebar, structural steel) and giving a shorter path to ground for the low voltage xfmr. Or a dielectric break (plastic valve installed in the cold water copper not allowing the voltage to go to ground on the cold water bond).does anyone have any ideas how to determine what’s wrong and how to go about fixing this.
Okay, this is a really fascinating problem! You've done some excellent troubleshooting already. It's definitely got a "ground loop/stray voltage" feel to it. Here's a breakdown of thoughts, a plan to isolate the issue, and some potential solutions based on your description
Understanding the Suspect Issues
Galvanic Corrosion/Electrolysis
The streaky appearance suggests dissimilar metals are in contact with an electrolyte (water) and a voltage is present. This confirms your suspicion of stray voltage.
Voltage on the Valve Body
The 5VDC reading is a major clue. It means current is flowing where it shouldn't be, seeking a return path.
Temporary Fix with Tape
The fact that the tape (creating a dielectric break) allowed the flusher to work, even with 3VDC still present, strongly suggests a ground loop or a difference in ground potential.
Isolation Effect of Disconnecting from Urinal
This points to the urinal itself being part of the unintended circuit.
Successful operation on other urinals
Isolates the issue to just this urinal.
Plan of Attack & Steps1. Confirm the Urinal's Water Supply is Bonded
Crucial
Ensure the copper water supply pipes feeding this urinal are properly bonded to the building's grounding electrode system. This is a code requirement, but it's the first place to check for missing or loose connections.
Test, Don't Just Look
Use a multimeter to confirm continuity between the copper pipe near the urinal and the main building ground. A low resistance reading is what you are looking for. If the urinal uses a PEX supply line for the majority of it's length, verify both connection points are bonded.2.
Isolate the Water Supply
Install a Dielectric Union
Temporarily install a UL-Listed dielectric union on the water supply line right before the flush valve. This creates a complete electrical break in the water line. You can get these at most plumbing supply stores.
Evaluate
Does this solve the problem? If so, you've confirmed that the water supply is the path for the stray voltage. You'll need to trace back where the stray voltage is entering the water pipes.3.
Tracing the Stray Voltage
Start at the Panel
If the dielectric union fixes the problem, the stray voltage is entering the water system upstream of the union. This is where it gets trickier.
Systematically Disconnect Branches
Methodically disconnect branch water lines one at a time to see if the voltage disappears. This could involve temporarily shutting off water to sections of the building. It's tedious, but often effective.4.
Check for Shorts to Structural Steel/Rebar
Water Lines in Contact
Carefully inspect where the water lines run. Are they touching metal studs, rebar in concrete, or other grounded structural elements? Even incidental contact can create a path for stray voltage.
Non-Metallic Isolation
Ensure the water lines are properly insulated from any contact with grounded metal structures. Use appropriate pipe hangers and isolation materials.5.
Evaluate Shared Neutral/Ground Issues
Unlikely, but possible
Because other fixtures share the same transformer, there's a remote chance of a neutral-ground bond issue upstream of the transformer. It's less likely because you're only seeing the problem at one urinal, but double check neutral and ground separation at the panel and transformer.6.
Re-evaluate Grounding of other equipment A poorly grounded piece of equipment near the urinal could be providing a path back. Check any electrical boxes near the problem location.7. Check for Foreign Voltages With a high impedance meter, check between the cold water supply and the urinal. You might be surprised.
Potential Sources of Stray Voltage Improperly Grounded Equipment
Faulty appliances, HVAC equipment, or other electrical devices with grounding problems can introduce voltage into the building's metallic infrastructure (pipes, conduit, structural steel).
External Sources
In rare cases, stray voltage can originate from outside the building (utility equipment, nearby electrical systems).
Shared Neutral/Ground
Though less likely, a faulty neutral-ground connection somewhere in the system can create a path for stray voltage.
Important Considerations Safety First
Work with electrical systems carefully. Use proper PPE and follow lockout/tagout procedures when working on electrical circuits.
Qualified Electrician
If you're not comfortable with electrical troubleshooting, call a licensed electrician. Stray voltage problems can be complex and dangerous.
Document Everything
Keep detailed notes of your troubleshooting steps, voltage readings, and any changes you make. This will help you track your progress and communicate effectively with an electrician if needed.
Addressing the Electrolysis Issue Clean Metal Surfaces
Once you've identified and eliminated the source of the stray voltage, thoroughly clean the affected metal surfaces (flush valve, valve body) to remove any corrosion products.
Corrosion Inhibitors: Consider applying a corrosion inhibitor to protect the metal surfaces from future corrosion.This is a complex problem, but with a systematic approach, you should be able to identify and fix the source of the stray voltage. Good luck! Let me know if you have any more questions as you work through it. Flag for review