Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: My Students are having trouble with this

User: Cindysparky, Location: Milwaukee

Asked on: Sunday, November 10, 2024 at 5:38 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:03 am EST

Question: I’m teaching from this book. In this particular chapter, the book talks about choosing conductors with two things happening: continuous load, and adjustment factors of temperature and current carrying conductors. Many people in the class are very knowledgeable electricians. They are a smart bunch. Two of them had a fit that the book was wrong on this topic. They said that the conductors should be sized up from 12 gauge to 10 gauge.I did mention that the book warns that oversizing conductors (per code requirement ) is a common misconception. That the true sizing the largest of the two observations: continuous load vs heat/current carrying adjustment.I told them that I would take the time to pose this question to the forum and get some expert advice.I think the book is correct. What do you think???

Okay, let's break down conductor sizing and address the misconception you're encountering. You're on the right track, and here's a more detailed explanation to support your position and help clarify things for your students

The Core Principles of Conductor Sizing

The NEC (National Electrical Code) dictates the proper procedure for selecting conductor sizes to ensure safety and prevent overheating. The goal is to choose conductors that can safely carry the anticipated load without exceeding their ampacity. The key sections of the NEC involved are: Article 310: Conductors for General Wiring

This article provides the rules for determining the allowable ampacity of conductors, correction factors, and adjustment factors.


Article 210: Branch Circuits
The Two Main Considerations (As Your Book Correctly States)


Continuous Load

NEC 210.19(A)(1) (for branch circuits) and 215.2(A)(1) (for feeders) state that branch-circuit and feeder conductors must have an ampacity not less than 125% of the continuous load. A continuous load is defined as a load that operates for 3 hours or more. Calculation: Multiply the continuous load by 1.25 (or divide the conductor ampacity by 0.8). Example: A continuous load of 16 amps requires a conductor with an ampacity of at least 16 1.25 = 20 amps.
2.


Adjustment and Correction Factors



Ambient Temperature Correction (NEC 310.15(B)(1))

If the ambient temperature is higher than the temperature rating of the conductor insulation (typically 30°C or 86°F for common insulations like THHN/THWN), you must
reduce the conductor's ampacity. Tables like NEC Table 310.15(B)(1) provide correction factors based on the temperature.

Adjustment for Number of Current-Carrying Conductors in a Raceway or Cable (NEC 310.15(B)(3))

When multiple current-carrying conductors are bundled together, their heat dissipation is reduced, and their ampacity must be reduced. NEC Table 310.15(B)(3)(a) provides adjustment factors based on the number of conductors.

The Correct Procedure: The Larger of the Two


Here's the critical point, and where your book is correct: You must size the conductor based on the larger of the following two requirements

1. The ampacity required to handle 125% of the continuous load.
2. The ampacity required after applying all applicable temperature correction and conductor bundling adjustment factors.


Why the Misconception About Always Upsizing to #10 AWG?


The "always go to #10" approach is a simplified rule of thumb often taught for specific common scenarios, but it's not a universal NEC requirement. Here's why it arises and why it can be misleading: 15 and 20 Amp Circuits

#14 AWG is typically rated for 15 amps, and #12 AWG is rated for 20 amps (using the 60°C column in NEC Table 310.16). If you have a 20-amp circuit with a continuous load, 20
1.25 = 25 amps. #12 AWG is not sufficient. So, you must increase the conductor size to #10 AWG because #10 AWG is rated for 30 amps (again using the 60°C column).

Oversimplification

The rule of thumb "go to #10" is meant to be a safe practice when electricians deal with continuous loads on 15 or 20 amp circuits. However, it ignores the fact that adjustment factors should be calculated separately.

A Practical Example (To Demonstrate the Book's Point)

Let's say you have a 20-amp circuit with a continuous load of 16 amps. You are using THHN conductors in a conduit with three current-carrying conductors, and the ambient temperature is 30°C.1.

Continuous Load

16 amps
1.25 = 20 amps.
2.


Ampacity After Adjustment

NEC Table 310.16 shows that #12 AWG THHN has an ampacity of 30 amps at 30°C. Since there are only 3 current-carrying conductors, and 310.15(C)(1) states that “No adjustment factor shall be applied to conductors in raceways or cables that have not more than three current-carrying conductors." no adjustment needs to be made. Because of this, #12 is acceptable for the 16 amp continuous load.

Key Points to Emphasize to Your Students



Don't rely on rules of thumb without understanding the underlying code.
The NEC is a complex document, and shortcuts can lead to errors. Understand the definitions

Specifically, what constitutes a "continuous load" and what factors trigger adjustment/correction.


Follow the code procedure

Calculate the ampacity required for continuous load, calculate the ampacity derated for temperature and bundling, and choose the larger of the two.

Document your calculations

This is crucial for inspections and for demonstrating compliance with the NEC.


Safety is paramount

Oversizing conductors (within reason) generally won't hurt anything except your budget. Undersizing conductors is a serious safety hazard.

Reference the code

Always refer to the
current edition of the NEC and consult with a qualified electrical inspector if you have any doubts.

How to Handle the Disagreement in Class


Acknowledge their experience

Start by validating the practical experience of the electricians in your class. Acknowledge that the "go to #10" rule is commonly used.2.

Present the code sections

Clearly show them the relevant sections of the NEC (210.19(A)(1), 215.2(A)(1), 310.15(B)(1), 310.15(B)(3), and Table 310.16).
3.


Work through examples

Use several examples, including ones where the continuous load
does require a larger conductor and ones where the adjustment factors are significant. Emphasize the "larger of the two" rule.4.

Encourage critical thinking

Ask them to explain
why the code is written the way it is. Why does continuous load require a higher ampacity? Why do temperature and bundling affect ampacity?5.

Allow for discussion

Let them debate and ask questions. A healthy discussion can lead to a better understanding for everyone.6.

Reinforce that you are there to teach code, not just accepted practice:
While practical experience is valuable, the course is based on code compliance.By presenting the code clearly, using practical examples, and encouraging a thoughtful discussion, you can help your students understand the correct way to size conductors and dispel the misconception about always* upsizing to #10. You are correct in your understanding of the code. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question