Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Motor Question

User: SonofAdam, Location: Portland Oregon

Asked on: Sunday, November 10, 2024 at 8:45 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:03 am EST

Question: Taking my masters, and i keep getting motor questions and they vary each time. I have a post with a previous one, but this time i got a question like this and couldn't get any of my answers to line up480 3 phase delta service feeds the following motors : (1) 5 hp motor, (1) 50 hp motor, and (2) 75 hp motors. One of the 75 hp motors is a 15 minute intermediate duty. Size the inverse time breaker that feeds the circuit.I couldn't get one answer to line up on the test and am looking for help. I plan on taking again at end of month.

Okay, this is a classic motor circuit sizing problem. Let's break it down step-by-step to understand the process and arrive at a solution. Keep in mind, electrical codes (like the NEC in the US) are very specific, so we need to follow those rules.

Understanding the Problem and Relevant NEC Articles (Assuming US NEC) Delta Service

Delta configurations have some nuances, but for this calculation, the main thing is we have a 480V 3-phase supply.


Motor Loads

We have a mix of motor sizes and a special condition for one of the 75 HP motors (intermediate duty).

Inverse Time Breaker

We need to size a circuit breaker that will protect the conductors and motors from overcurrent, but allow for the inrush current of the motors during starting.


NEC Focus

The most relevant NEC articles will be in

Article 430 (Motors, Motor Circuits, and Controllers)
, specifically sections dealing with: 430.22

Single Motor Conductor Ampacity


430.24

Several Motors or a Motor(s) and Other Load(s)

430.52

Motor Branch-Circuit Short-Circuit and Ground-Fault Protection

Step-by-Step Calculation
1. Find the Full Load Amps (FLA) for each motor

We need to use NEC Table 430.250 (Full-Load Current, Three-Phase Alternating-Current Motors) to find the FLA for each motor size at 480V. 5 HP Motor: ~ 7.6 Amps (from Table 430.250) 50 HP Motor: ~ 65 Amps (from Table 430.250) 75 HP Motor: ~ 96 Amps (from Table 430.250) 75 HP Motor (Intermediate Duty): ~ 96 Amps (from Table 430.250)2.

Account for the Intermediate Duty Motor

NEC 430.22(E) requires us to increase the FLC of a motor used for short-time, intermittent, periodic, or varying duty. Using Table 430.22(E), a 15-minute motor requires a multiplier of 120% The increased FLC is 96A 1.2 = 115.2 Amps3.

Calculate the Total Conductor Ampacity (430.24)

Take the highest FLA motor and add 25% of its FLA to the sum of the other motors. In this case, the intermediate duty motor has the highest FLC. 115.2 Amps + 65 Amps + 96 Amps + 7.6 Amps = 283.8 Amps4.

Determine the Breaker Size (430.52)



Standard Inverse Time Breaker

The maximum breaker size is a percentage of the largest motor's FLA. For an inverse time breaker, the maximum percentage is typically 250% of the largest motor's FLA. Intermediate duty FLC 250% = 115.2 2.5 = 288 Amps

Check Standard Sizes

You can't use a breaker that doesn't exist. You must round down to the nearest standard breaker size (NEC 240.6). The nearest standard size below 288 Amps is 250 Amps

Check the NEC Table 430.52 to verify

This table will also provide you with the maximum rating or setting for the different types of protective devices.5.

Verification and Fine-Tuning
Conductor Ampacity Check: The breaker must not be larger than the ampacity of the conductors. Ensure that the conductors you select have an ampacity greater than or equal to the value calculated from the several motors combined (283.8 Amps). Select conductors based on NEC Table 310.16 and derate as necessary. If needed, increase conductor size. Starter and Overload Protection: The breaker only provides short-circuit and ground-fault protection. Each motor MUST have its own overload protection (usually within the motor starter). This is sized based on the motor's nameplate FLA.

Therefore, based on these calculations, a 250 Amp inverse time breaker would likely be the appropriate selection.Important Considerations and Why Your Answers Might Not Have Matched Test Question Wording

Electrical exams are notoriously precise. Small wording differences can drastically change the correct answer. Were there any other instructions or specific parameters given in the question?


Answer Choices

The available answer choices on the test strongly influence the correct response. If the choices were significantly different, it could indicate a different interpretation of the question was needed.

Local Amendments

Some jurisdictions amend the NEC. This could affect the allowable breaker size.


Instructor's Approach

Your instructor might emphasize a particular method or use rules of thumb that differ slightly from the code.

Recommendations for Re-Taking the Exam
1. Review Article 430 in Detail

Don't just skim it. Work through examples in a study guide or textbook that specifically address multi-motor circuits and inverse time breaker sizing.2.

Practice, Practice, Practice

Do as many example problems as you can. Focus on problems that involve intermediate duty motors or similar special conditions.3.

Understand the 'Why'

Don't just memorize formulas. Understand why the code requires certain calculations. This will help you adapt to different scenarios.4.

Clarify with Your Instructor

If you're still unsure about the correct approach, ask your instructor to explain their preferred method and any rules of thumb they use.5.

Pay Attention to Wording

Read the questions carefully. Underline key words and phrases. Make sure you understand exactly what the question is asking before you start calculating.6.

Learn how to effectively use the NEC code book.
There are many great resources that will help you navigate the NEC more effectively.By following these steps and practicing diligently, you'll be well-prepared to tackle motor circuit sizing questions on your next exam. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question