Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Secondary Conductors Through Switchgear

User: Rock86, Location: new york

Asked on: Monday, November 11, 2024 at 11:03 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:04 am EST

Question: Background information: Primary metered site with Primary switch a head of Primary to 480V transformer. 480V feeders underground into 600A switchgear. Existing spare conduits from the transformer go into the switch gear and out to a manhole. Can tap conductors come from the 480V secondary side in the spare conduits without overcurrent protection? This would mean going in and out of the switch gear enclosure without any splices or breakers.

Let's break this down and analyze the feasibility and code implications.

The Core Question

Can you run tap conductors from the transformer secondary through spare conduits into a switchgear enclosure and back out to a manhole without overcurrent protection at the tap point?

Answer: Highly unlikely and almost certainly violates the NEC. You cannot reliably achieve a safe and code-compliant installation this way.
Why This is Problematic

1.

NEC Tap Rules (NEC 240.21)

The National Electrical Code (NEC) severely restricts the use of tap conductors without overcurrent protection. The primary reason is safety: a fault on the tap conductor could overload the main feeder and potentially cause a fire. The intent of the code is to keep the protection as close as possible to the power source.2.

Tap Conductor Length Limitations

The NEC allows very specific types of taps, each with strict length limitations. These lengths are a function of the overcurrent protection device's rating and the ampacity of the tap conductors. The most common tap rules (e.g., 10-foot tap, 25-foot tap) all require overcurrent protection at the tap point if you don't meet the requirements.3.

Switchgear Enclosure Considerations

Even entering the switchgear enclosure with unprotected tap conductors might violate listing and labeling requirements. Switchgear is tested and listed based on specific configurations and applications. Introducing an unconventional (and potentially unsafe) tap arrangement could void the listing.4.

Manhole Considerations

This suggests the circuit ends up in the manhole, which likely implies this is a feeder for something like a street light, signage, or some other load outside the building. This is highly unlikely to meet the tap conductor length rules.

Why You Need Overcurrent Protection at or Near the Tap Point



Fault Protection

A fault (short circuit or ground fault) on the tap conductor will draw a massive current. Without overcurrent protection, this current would be limited only by the impedance of the transformer and the main feeder, potentially causing severe damage, overheating, and fire.


Coordination

Overcurrent protection helps ensure selective coordination. This means that if a fault occurs on the tap, only the breaker or fuse protecting that tap should trip, leaving the rest of the system operational.

Specifically, you need to examine NEC 240.21 to determine whether you can meet any of the tap rules.
Most likely you will have to put some kind of fused disconnect in or just outside of the 600A switchgear.

Alternative Solutions (Consider These)



Dedicated Breaker in Switchgear

The most common and reliable solution is to install a dedicated breaker (appropriately sized for the load and tap conductors) within the 600A switchgear. This breaker would provide the necessary overcurrent protection.


Fused Disconnect Immediately Outside Switchgear

If space within the switchgear is a major constraint, a fused disconnect switch could be installed immediately outside the switchgear, at the point where the tap conductors exit the enclosure.

Smaller Transformer

Depending on the load, you could consider a smaller, dedicated transformer with its own overcurrent protection at the secondary. This might be more cost-effective in the long run than trying to make an unconventional tap work.


Consult with an Electrical Engineer

Before making any changes to the electrical system, consult with a qualified electrical engineer. They can perform a load study, analyze the existing system, and recommend the safest and most code-compliant solution.

Key Takeaways



Safety First

Never compromise safety for convenience or cost savings. Electrical systems can be dangerous if not designed and installed correctly.


Code Compliance

Always adhere to the NEC and any local electrical codes.

Documentation

Keep accurate records of all electrical modifications and additions.

In conclusion, running tap conductors from the transformer secondary, through switchgear, and out to a manhole
without* overcurrent protection is almost certainly a code violation and a safety hazard. It is imperative to install overcurrent protection as close as possible to the tap point.
Consult with a qualified electrical engineer to determine the best and safest solution for your specific application. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question