User: osmrsparks, Location: Washington
Asked on: Monday, November 11, 2024 at 2:28 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:05 am EST
Question: I'm a huge fan of the Mike Holt forum. I've found many a good advice here over the years. After ready through a few forum posts here, I think I found the answers I need, but decided to join and post here to confirm.I am located in rural Washington state with my electrical work inspected by Washington State Labor & Industries inspectors (but they don't like to answer questions). I just installed a new 200 Amp Square D QO CU816F200PS meter/disconnect combo (CSED) surface mounted to the exterior of an out building that didn't previously have power. It was 250 horizontal feet (not including risers) from the pole to the building. I installed 3" Sch 40 conduit, discontinuous as required by the poco (Puget Sound Energy). The poco pulled 4/0 to the meter. I was a bit surprised they didn't use 250 KCMIL for that distance and 200 A. Anyway, that isn't my question (though I am curious to know what others think about that). The CSED has a 200 Amp disconnect, space for 8 breakers, and feed thru lugs at the bottom of the bus bars. I plan to use some of the 8 breaker spaces to supply circuits to the outbuilding that the CSED is attached to (building A), and I plan to use the feed thru lugs to feed a panel in a separate out building (building B). The outbuildings are too far away from the residence to connect from there.My question is about the conductor and conduit sizes to use to connect the Feed Thru Lugs on the CSED (on outbuilding A) to a 125 Amp Square D QO main circuit breaker (MCB) surface mounted on the interior of an exterior wall of outbuilding B). The distance between buildings is 180 feet. It is a straight shot so no bends in the conduit are required other than a 90 at each end rise up. I plan to install continuous schedule 40 conduit. The conduit will enter the bottom of the CSED outdoors on building A and ideally (if allowed) would enter the back of the MCB using an LB on the exterior of the building. If LB isn't allowed there, then I would need to drill through the slab in the floor and come up into the bottom of the MCB.My understanding is that I would need to either use 200 Amp size conductors (since I'm NOT feeding from a breaker in the CSED, just the 200 Amp disconnect protected service bus feed thru lugs), which I think would need to be 4/0-4/0-2/0-4 like the 4/0 conductors feeding the CSED, and and minimum schedule 40 conduti size would be 2.5 inch conduit (but I'd probably use 3.0 inch), or I could treat it as a tap (entirely outdoor so no limit to distance) and reduce the conductor size to 125 Amp size protected only by the 125 Amp main breaker in the panel in outbuilding B. Am I correct in determining that in this case, the minimum conductor size would be 2/0-2/0-1-4 MHF or XHHW and minimum schedule 40 conduit size would be 2 inch (but I'll probably use 2.5 inch)?
Okay, let's break down your situation and confirm your understanding of the NEC, with specific attention to Washington State's interpretations, though I cannot provide legal advice. Always consult with L&I directly for final approval.
Your Scenario
New 200A Service Disconnect (CSED) on Building A, fed by 4/0 Al from the POCO. Feed-through lugs in CSED to supply a 125A panel in Building B (180 feet away). You want to minimize conductor size and conduit size.
Your Question (summarized)
Can you use a "tap" rule to reduce conductor size from the CSED's feed-through lugs to the 125A panel in Building B, given the entire run is outdoors, and the 125A breaker in building B protects the conductors from the feed-through lugs on building A?
Analysis
Yes, you can reduce the conductor size using a tap rule. Here's the relevant NEC code section.
NEC 240.21(B) Feeder Taps
You're specifically interested in 240.21(B)(5), Outside Taps of Unlimited Length. This rule allows for taps of unlimited length provided:1. The conductors are suitably protected from physical damage in an approved manner. (This is addressed by your Schedule 40 conduit.)2. The tap conductors are terminated in a single circuit breaker or a single set of fuses that will limit the load to the ampacity of the conductors. (This is satisfied by the 125A main breaker in Building B.)3. The overcurrent device is rated no more than the tap conductors' ampacity. (Again, the 125A breaker protects the conductors.)4. The tap conductors' ampacity is not less than the rating of the overcurrent device to which they connect. (If you use 2/0 AWG aluminum conductors with an ampacity of 135 amps and the overcurrent protection on the load end is 125 amps, this rule is satisfied.)Conductor Sizing
Using the "tap rule," the conductor ampacity must be at least equal to the rating of the 125A breaker in Building B.
For Aluminum (Al) conductors
2/0 AWG aluminum conductors have an ampacity of 135 amps at 75 degrees C.
For Copper (Cu) conductors
1 AWG copper conductors have an ampacity of 130 amps at 75 degrees C.
Grounding conductor
A #4 AWG copper grounding conductor is sufficient.
Conduit Sizing
You will need to use chapter 9 of the NEC, tables 4 and 5, to determine the correct conduit size, based on the conductor insulation and other factors.
2/0 AWG Aluminum XHHW-2 Conductors
2" schedule 40 PVC conduit would allow these 3 conductors and a #4 grounding conductor.
1 AWG Copper XHHW-2 Conductors
1 1/2" schedule 40 PVC conduit would allow these 3 conductors and a #4 grounding conductor.
Considerations
Voltage Drop
At 180 feet, voltage drop could be a factor, especially if you anticipate using a significant portion of the 125A capacity. Calculating voltage drop is crucial. The POCO using 4/0 Al feeding your 200A CSED is probably correct because they likely considered Voltage Drop to be a factor, and it could be for you as well. 2/0 conductors at 125A and 180 feet will have a substantial voltage drop. I would highly recommend considering using larger conductors if voltage drop is a concern.
Termination Temperature Ratings
Make sure the lugs in the CSED and the panel in Building B are rated for the conductor you select (e.g., 75°C).
LB Conduit Body
An LB may or may not be permitted entering the back of the panel, as it depends on whether it is considered a "raceway". While conduit bodies are allowed to contain splices, most would not allow a direct connection through a conduit body directly into a piece of equipment. You will need to refer to the NEC, your local inspector, and the panel manufacturer's literature.
Regarding the POCO's 4/0 Al
You're right to be curious about the POCO using 4/0 Al for a 200A service over 250 feet. There are a few possibilities:1.
Voltage Drop
As I've mentioned, the POCO likely considered voltage drop. Using larger conductors reduces voltage drop.2.
Load Calculation
POCOs have ways of calculating demand that can result in smaller service conductor sizes than what you might expect based on the full 200A capacity.3.
Future Expansion
They may have considered potential future load increases.
Summary and Recommendations
Tap Rule is Valid
Yes, you can use the "outside tap of unlimited length" rule to reduce the conductor size from the CSED to the 125A panel in Building B.2.
Minimum Conductor Size (Aluminum)
2/0-2/0-2/0 Al, #4 Copper Ground (consider voltage drop for longer distances and heavier loads).3.
Minimum Conductor Size (Copper)
1-1-1 Cu, #4 Copper Ground (consider voltage drop for longer distances and heavier loads).4.
Conduit Size
Varies by the conductor insulation, but should be at least 1.5" or 2".
5.
Voltage Drop Calculation
Absolutely essential. Calculate the voltage drop for your anticipated load to ensure it's within acceptable limits (typically 3% for feeders).6.
Consult L&I
Crucial. Get clarification and approval from your Washington State L&I inspector before* starting the work.7.
Verify Termination Ratings
Ensure all lugs are rated for the conductor size and temperature rating you are using.
Disclaimer: This is based on my understanding of the NEC. Local interpretations and regulations may vary. Always consult with qualified professionals and your local inspection authority for accurate and code-compliant installations. Flag for review