User: KS_Trout, Location: Kansas City KS
Asked on: Tuesday, November 12, 2024 at 11:36 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:07 am EST
Question: Long time lurker. First post.I am seeing that I may need to upsize a grounding conductor for my run to a subpanel. Not because SERVICE capacity is increased, but because wire size is. I'm running a 40A service to a small outbuilding, service distance panel to panel of 131'. I chose #6 THWN for both phases plus N. Initially, it appeared that 250.122 calls out a 10AWG Cu ground wire, but because I am using #6, I'm finding references online that I have to upsize my ground wire as well, to a #8 Cu. Is this correct? How incredibly frustrating if so.
Welcome to the forum! It's great to see you making your first post after lurking for a while. Let's break down your grounding conductor sizing for your subpanel feed to your outbuilding.
Understanding the Situation Subpanel
You're feeding a subpanel in an outbuilding from your main panel.
Feeder Size
You're using #6 THWN copper conductors for the hots and neutral.
Distance
The run is 131 feet.
Concern
You're questioning if the grounding conductor needs to be larger than #10 AWG copper, even though the overcurrent protection is 40A.
NEC Reference: 250.122
NEC 250.122 is the article that governs the sizing of equipment grounding conductors (EGCs). 250.122(B) states that if the ungrounded conductors are increased in size from the minimum size that has sufficient ampacity for the intended load, the equipment grounding conductor (EGC) is increased in size proportionately, according to the circular mil area of the ungrounded conductors.
Why the Upsize?
The need to upsize the EGC doesn't come from an increased service capacity, but because you've increased the size of the ungrounded conductors (your #6 hots) beyond what's minimally required for the 40A overcurrent protection.
CalculationsTable 310.16 indicates that #8 is fine for 40A with its 50A rating in the 75 degree column, in copper.
Is it Required?
Yes, it appears to be a code requirement to upsize to #8 for the reasons stated above.
How To Prove the EGC Upsizing (and perhaps prevent it!)
The main panel overcurrent device protecting this sub-panel is likely a 40A circuit breaker. If a 40A circuit breaker is protecting the circuit, NEC Table 310.16 shows that #8 AWG copper conductors are acceptable as the feeder conductors to the sub-panel. So why run #6 conductors instead of #8 conductors? If you ran #8 conductors instead of #6 conductors, then 250.122 would require a #10 AWG copper EGC, and you wouldn't have to upsize the EGC!There are only two scenarios for why you may be running #6's:1. You ran a voltage drop calculation and #8 was not sufficient.
2. You are planning on increasing the size of the overcurrent device protecting the conductors in the future.
The Takeaway
You've identified a critical aspect of grounding conductor sizing. It's not always just based on the overcurrent protection. It's also tied to the size of the ungrounded conductors and whether they are increased for other reasons like voltage drop. In your case, it appears that you might need to upsize your ground wire to #8 AWG copper because of your choice of running #6 AWG copper for the hots and neutral.Hope this helps, and feel free to ask if you have any more questions! Flag for review