Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Emergency disconnect/ feeder disconnect

User: Dsg319, Location: West Virginia

Asked on: Tuesday, November 12, 2024 at 1:54 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:07 am EST

Question: A building (garage apartment) approx 150’ to 130’ away from the service disconnect which feeds it, does it still require the external outside disconnect since it’s over 50’ away?I know the code states within sight. But I thought I also read the definition of within sight is 50’.

You're right to be concerned about both the "within sight" requirement and the potential for a disconnect at the detached building. Let's break down the NEC requirements: NEC 225.32 Disconnecting Means. Outdoor disconnecting means shall be installed at each dwelling unit in a two-family or multi-family building. Also where more than one building or structure is supplied by a feeder(s) or branch circuit(s), a disconnecting means shall be installed at each building or structure. NEC 225.31 Location for Disconnecting Means. The disconnecting means shall be installed at a readily accessible location either outside of the building or structure or inside nearest the point of entrance of the conductors. "In Sight From (Within Sight)." This is defined in Article 100 Definitions as: Where specified in this Code that one piece of equipment shall be "in sight from," "within sight from," etc., another piece of equipment, the specified equipment is required to be visible and not more than 15 m (50 ft) distant from the other.Analysis of Your Situation


Detached Building

Since you have a garage apartment that is detached from the building where the service disconnect is located,

NEC 225.32 requires a disconnecting means at the garage apartment.2.

Location of Disconnect

The disconnect at the garage apartment must be "readily accessible" and either
outside or inside nearest the point of entrance of the conductors.3.

"Within Sight" is Not the Controlling Factor Here

The 50-foot "within sight" rule applies when the Code specifically requires one piece of equipment to be within sight of another. In this case, 225.32 requires a disconnecting means at the detached building but doesn't state the service disconnect has to be within sight.

Answer



Yes, you still require a disconnecting means (a disconnect switch or breaker) at the garage apartment even though it is approximately 130-150 feet away from the service disconnect. The code requires a disconnect at each detached building. The disconnect must be readily accessible and located either outside the garage apartment or inside nearest the point where the feeder conductors enter the building.

Important Considerations



Feeder Overcurrent Protection

Remember that the feeder to the garage apartment must have overcurrent protection (a breaker or fuses) at the point where it originates (at the service disconnect).

Grounding/Bonding

Proper grounding and bonding are critical for safety. The grounding electrode system at the garage apartment may require additional electrodes depending on local codes and the characteristics of the soil. Consult NEC Article 250.


Local Codes

Always check with your local electrical inspector or building department for any local amendments or interpretations of the NEC. They have the final say on code compliance.

In summary, focus on meeting the requirements of 225.32 and 225.31, which mandate a disconnecting means at the detached building, irrespective of the distance to the service disconnect. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question