User: Dan Kissel, Location: st louis, mo
Asked on: Tuesday, November 12, 2024 at 3:38 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:07 am EST
Question: I have a 1200 circuit breaker set at LSIG set at 1200A, 12 sec delay, 6000A. 3sec IsqT .3 with 1200 amps worth of cable feeding a 1200 distribution panel. A Fluke 435 Power quality analyzer measured the current for 7 days, which really captured the panels current load. All said and done the report for the highest amp draw which was over ~ 6. The distribution panels about 10 different control panels with eccentric loads. The meter can trap loads lasting 200 msec. The report indicates that the maximum peak current was ~700 amps but the average peak is only 358 amp with 95% of my load being under 321 amps.Is the code concerned with the 700 amps which may happen for 200 msec or the avg peak of 358 amps. BTW the average current of the is 193 amps.Th question other are asking how much available ampacity do I have left. The manufacture says, I am nowhere tripping the breaker ( only about 25 % used).Does the code say I am using 700 amps of my 1200 capacity?
Okay, let's break down the code implications and your available ampacity.
Understanding the Code (NEC) Perspective
The National Electrical Code (NEC) is primarily concerned with:1. Continuous Load
This is the maximum current expected to flow for 3 hours or more. Breakers and conductors must be sized to handle 125% of the continuous load.2.
Ampacity of Conductors
The conductors feeding your panel must have an ampacity sufficient to carry the calculated load and be protected by the overcurrent device (the breaker).3.
Overcurrent Protection Coordination
The breaker must protect the conductors from overload and fault currents.4.
Short-Circuit Withstand Rating
The panel must be able to withstand the available fault current at its terminals. This is separate from the normal load considerations.
Applying it to Your Situation Continuous Load
Your average current of 193 amps is a good starting point. This is significantly below your 1200 amp breaker rating. However, you need to verify if any portion of this load is considered "continuous" (operates for 3 hours or more). If so, you need to account for the 125% factor for that portion.
Peak Current (700 amps)
The NEC is not usually concerned with short-duration peak currents as long as the breaker doesn't trip and the conductors are not damaged. Breakers are designed to allow for short-duration inrush currents, like motor starting, without tripping. The fact that your breaker hasn't tripped during these 700 amp peaks suggests that its trip curve is accommodating them.
Conductor Ampacity
This is crucial. Your 1200 amp conductors MUST have an ampacity of at least 1200 amps. This means they need to be properly sized based on the NEC's ampacity tables (NEC 310.15 and associated tables). You also need to consider derating factors for ambient temperature and number of conductors in a raceway.
The LSIG settings
Long Time, Short Time, Instantaneous, and Ground Fault
Long Time
Your breaker is set to trip at 1200A after 12 seconds. This is to protect the conductors against overload
Short Time
Your breaker is set to trip at 6000A after 3 seconds.
IsqT
This is used for overcurrent protection of the equipment. It's only required on equipment that can produce its own power or has high levels of fault current like generators, paralleled transformers or if it's double ended switchgear.
Calculating Available Ampacity
The calculation of available capacity is always based on NEC 220 for the feeder.1. Base load 125% is the most accurate, which is your continuous load times 1.25 (NEC 220)2. Base load 100% add up all the remaining loads.3. Total Load of NEC 2204. Available Ampacity = 1200 amp - Total LoadAddressing the "Am I Using 700 Amps?" Question Not exactly. You are momentarily using up to 700 amps. The breaker is not seeing this as an overload because it's short-duration. The effective load from a planning perspective is more related to your average current (193 amps) and your continuous load calculations. However, the 700 amp peak is a consideration when determining if you have enough short-circuit withstand rating in your panel and downstream equipment.
Key Considerations and Recommendations1. NEC 220 Load Calculation
Perform a proper load calculation according to NEC Article 220. This is essential for determining the required ampacity for your feeder conductors and the load on your breaker.
2.
Verify Conductor Ampacity
Ensure your conductors are properly sized and derated to handle the calculated load and are protected by the 1200 amp breaker.3.
Motor Starting
If a significant portion of your load is motors, consider motor starting currents and how they affect your load calculations.4.
Monitor Trends
Continue to monitor the current with your power quality analyzer. A week is a good start, but longer-term monitoring can reveal seasonal variations or changes in load patterns.5.
Consider Demand Factors
NEC Article 220 allows for demand factors in certain situations (e.g., for dwelling units). However, demand factors are less likely to be applicable in industrial control panel scenarios.6.
Coordination Study
If you are adding significant new loads, consider a coordination study to ensure that your overcurrent protective devices (OCPDs) are properly coordinated. This helps to minimize nuisance tripping and maximize system reliability.7.
Consult an Electrical Engineer
For complex systems or if you are unsure about any of these calculations, it's always best to consult with a qualified electrical engineer.
In summary: You likely have significant available ampacity based on your average current. However, a thorough NEC 220 load calculation is essential to confirm this and ensure compliance. Also, verify your conductor ampacity and short-circuit withstand ratings. Don't dismiss the short duration peak currents completely, they are important to think about. Flag for review