User: TiredEngineer1979, Location: Montana
Asked on: Tuesday, November 12, 2024 at 5:57 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:08 am EST
Question: I'm working on some utility scale BESS projects (not utility owned, so subject to electrical inspection) and I'm looking at the conflict, if you can call it that, between the requirement in 250.122(F)(1)(b) and the exception listed above in 134. The situation is a paralleled run between the Inverter unit and the battery container. It's multiple runs of less than 1500 VDC in multiple conduits. Per standard practice and 250.122(F)(1)(b), I would run a fully sized EGC in each conduit. In talking with some of our solar fellas, they're suggesting taking advantage of that Exception 2. I'm hoping to get some outside perspectives.NEC 2023 250.122(F)(1)(b): Multiple Raceways. If conductors are installed in multiple raceways and are connected in parallel, a wire-type equipment grounding conductor, if used, shall be installed in each raceway and shall be connected in parallel. The equipment grounding conductor installed in each raceway shall be sized in accordance with 250.122 based on the rating of the overcurrent protective device for the feeder or branch circuit.NEC 2023 250.134(2) Exception No. 2 For dc circuits, the equipment grounding conductor shall be permitted to be run separately from the circuit conductors.I'm just a little concerned because we get a fair number of inspectors and independent engineers that look at Exceptions as they would dog mess on their loafers. Is this something anyone here runs across? Thanks for your input.
You've identified a legitimate point of contention in applying the NEC to large-scale BESS installations. Let's break down the considerations and potential approaches
Understanding the Conflict
250.122(F)(1)(b)
This section mandates a full-sized EGC in each raceway for parallel conductor runs. The rationale is fault current distribution. If a fault occurs in one raceway, a portion of the fault current will flow through the EGC in that raceway back to the source. This ensures adequate fault clearing.
250.134(2) Exception No. 2
This permits a separate EGC for DC circuits. It doesn't require it, but allows it as an alternative. The exception provides flexibility, potentially simplifying installation and material costs.
The Conflict
The conflict arises because 250.122(F)(1)(b) requires an EGC in each raceway, while 250.134(2) Exception No. 2 allows a single, separate EGC. Which one takes precedence?
Arguments For Using 250.122(F)(1)(b) (EGC in Each Raceway) Clarity and Minimizing Inspector Scrutiny
As you rightly point out, inspectors often scrutinize exceptions. Adhering to the more straightforward requirement of 250.122(F)(1)(b) minimizes potential questions and delays during inspection. It leaves no room for interpretation.
Enhanced Fault Current Capacity
Running a full-sized EGC in each raceway provides the maximum fault current carrying capacity for each individual parallel run. This is particularly beneficial in large systems where fault currents can be substantial.
Reduced Impedance
Having an EGC in close proximity to the phase conductors in each raceway minimizes impedance, which is important for effective fault clearing. This is generally considered best practice for grounding.
Future-Proofing
While your current design might work with a single, separate EGC, future modifications or expansions could be simplified by having the EGC already in place in each raceway.
Arguments For Using 250.134(2) Exception No. 2 (Separate EGC) Cost Savings
Using a single, larger EGC instead of multiple, full-sized EGCs can significantly reduce material costs, especially on large projects.
Simplified Installation
Running a single, separate EGC can reduce the labor required for pulling conductors.
Code Compliance (Potentially)
If properly designed and sized, a single, separate EGC can meet the code requirements for fault current carrying capacity and voltage drop.
Considerations for Using Exception No. 2
If you decide to pursue Exception No. 2, you must ensure:1. Proper Sizing
The separate EGC must be sized to adequately handle the available fault current. Perform fault current calculations to determine the required conductor size. Remember to consider the entire length of the circuit, including any voltage drop implications.2.
Low Impedance Path
Ensure the separate EGC provides a low-impedance path back to the source. Proper bonding and termination are critical. The EGC should be as short and direct as possible.3.
Voltage Drop
Carefully consider voltage drop in the EGC during a fault condition. Excessive voltage drop can hinder fault clearing.4.
Documentation
Thoroughly document your design, calculations, and justifications for using Exception No. 2. This will be crucial for demonstrating compliance to the inspector.
5.
Early Inspector Communication
The most important step is to proactively communicate your design and rationale with the electrical inspector before installation. This can prevent surprises and delays later on. Present your calculations and explain why you believe your design is safe and compliant with the intent of the code.6.
Engineering Judgement
The AHJ has the final say. Be prepared to defend your approach with sound engineering judgement.
Recommendation
While Exception No. 2 can offer cost savings, the increased scrutiny and potential for misinterpretation often outweigh the benefits, particularly for large projects with multiple parallel runs. The safest and most straightforward approach is generally to follow 250.122(F)(1)(b) and run a full-sized EGC in each raceway. Start with 250.122(F)(1)(b) as your default design. Only consider Exception No. 2 if the cost savings are very significant and you are confident in your ability to design, document, and defend your approach. Communicate with the inspector early and often*.
In your specific situation, given the number of inspectors and independent engineers reviewing the project, adhering to the more prescriptive requirement of 250.122(F)(1)(b) will likely result in a smoother and more predictable approval process. The added cost of running an EGC in each raceway may be a worthwhile investment to avoid potential delays and rework.Ultimately, the decision is yours, but prioritize safety, code compliance, and clear communication with the AHJ. Good luck with your BESS projects! Flag for review