Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Sizing AC Motor for Centrifugal Fan

User: FanGuy, Location: Pennsylvania

Asked on: Tuesday, November 12, 2024 at 8:49 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:08 am EST

Question: I thought I knew the answer to this question, but I have had some instances recently where my understanding has been challenged, and I feel like I cannot find a concise statement anywhere online that confirms what I had learned.Do I need to select an "oversized" motor (in terms of horsepower) for my centrifugal fan if I intend to operate it at less than nominal speed on a VFD?In my current application, because the customer wants the fan in direct drive, and the fan speed needs to be at a non-nominal motor speed to be at the right operating point, I am looking at running a 3600 RPM motor at just 2200 RPM, and at that 2200 RPM speed, the fan will require 176 BHP. The way I would typically size the motor would be to de-rate its horsepower by the ratio of the VFD turndown. That is:Required Nameplated Motor Horsepower ≥ 176 x (3600/2200)Required Nameplated Motor Horsepower ≥ 288So I would need a 300 HP 3600 RPM motor, which, turned down to 2200 RPM, would be capable of delivering 183.3 HP.Is this correct? I can't use an inverter-duty 200 HP 3600 RPM motor, right? Does it matter what my actual torque requirement is (i.e. the WR2 of the fan wheel)?

You've hit on a crucial point in motor sizing for VFD applications, and your intuition is correct: you generally DO need to consider upsizing the motor, but your calculation method is flawed, and it's more about torque than horsepower directly.

Here's a breakdown of the key considerations and why your initial calculation is incorrect

Why You Need to Consider Upsizing:
Constant Torque vs. Variable Torque Loads

Centrifugal fans are generally
variable torque loads. This means the torque required by the fan decreases with the square of the speed reduction. The horsepower required decreases with the cube of the speed reduction. This is the critical difference!

Motor Cooling

Standard motors are typically cooled by a shaft-mounted fan. When the motor speed is reduced, the cooling capacity of the fan is drastically reduced. This can lead to overheating, especially at lower speeds. Inverter-duty motors (or motors with auxiliary cooling) are designed to handle this, but they still have limitations.

Torque Capability at Lower Speeds

A standard motor's torque capability can degrade at lower speeds due to factors like harmonics introduced by the VFD and the motor's internal impedance. Inverter-duty motors are designed to mitigate these effects, but again, they're not perfect.

Why Your Initial Calculation is Incorrect

Your calculation `Required Nameplated Motor Horsepower ≥ 176 x (3600/2200)` is based on a
constant horsepower assumption. This is incorrect for centrifugal fans, which are variable torque. You're essentially assuming the fan needs the same HP at all speeds, which is not true.

Correct Sizing Approach – Focus on Torque

The critical parameter is

torque
. Here's the recommended approach:1. Calculate Torque at the Operating Point

You know the horsepower (176 BHP) and speed (2200 RPM) at your operating point. Use this information to calculate the
required torque at 2200 RPM. The formula is:

Torque (lb-ft) = (Horsepower  5252) / RPM
In your case:
Torque @ 2200 RPM = (176  5252) / 2200 = 419.7 lb-ft
2.


Check Motor Torque Capability

You need to confirm that the
selected motor can deliver at least 419.7 lb-ft of torque at 2200 RPM continuously. This is where the motor's torque-speed curve (available from the manufacturer) becomes essential. Don't rely solely on the motor's nameplate horsepower.3.

Consider the VFD's Torque Capability

The VFD itself may have torque limitations at lower frequencies. Consult the VFD manufacturer's documentation to ensure the VFD can deliver the required torque at the lower speed. Some VFDs have "boost" settings that can temporarily increase torque, but this might not be suitable for continuous operation.4.

Cooling Considerations

Even with an inverter-duty motor, consider the cooling requirements. If you're operating at significantly reduced speeds for long periods, you might need auxiliary cooling (a separate fan) to ensure the motor doesn't overheat. Check the motor manufacturer's recommendations for minimum speed and continuous operation.5.

Service Factor

Apply a suitable service factor (e.g., 1.15 or higher) to the torque calculation to provide a margin for safety and accommodate variations in the system. This means increasing your required torque by the service factor.

Example Using Torque

Let's say you are considering that 200 HP inverter-duty motor at 3600 RPM and you know the nameplate torque of the motor (let's say it's around 292 lb-ft at 3600 RPM). You have to determine if this motor can produce the required torque at the operating speed of 2200 RPM. Generally, inverter-duty motors can produce constant torque down to a lower speed, but you have to consult the motor torque curves provided by the manufacturer for continuous operation to verify if the motor torque is still approximately 292 lb-ft at 2200 RPM. If it can, then you can now determine if this torque is sufficient by using the fan affinity laws:Torque is proportional to speed squared:Torque2 / Torque1 = (Speed2 / Speed1)^2Torque2 / 419.7 lb-ft = (3600 RPM / 2200 RPM)^2Torque2 = 1120 lb-ft (this is the amount of torque the motor would produce at 3600 RPM assuming it would take that load, which it would not)Therefore, with this selected motor and drive, at the required 2200 RPM operating point, the motor would supply 292 lb-ft of torque. This motor is
not capable of delivering the required 419.7 lb-ft of torque.You have to go through this same exercise for any motor you are considering, looking at the motor torque curves provided by the manufacturer.

WR2 (Inertia) Matters, but Indirectly



Acceleration Time

The WR2 (inertia) of the fan wheel directly affects the acceleration time. A higher WR2 means it will take longer to bring the fan up to speed. This is relevant for VFDs because they need to be able to supply enough torque to overcome the inertia during startup. While not directly determining motor size, it does impact the VFD's short-term torque demands.

Starting Torque

A high WR2 may require the VFD to deliver higher starting torque, especially if frequent starts and stops are involved. This is another reason to consult the VFD manufacturer's recommendations.

In Summary



Focus on Torque

Calculate the required torque at the operating speed.

Motor Torque Curve

Verify the motor's torque capability at the operating speed from the manufacturer's data. Don't assume constant horsepower!


VFD Capability

Ensure the VFD can deliver the required torque at the lower frequency.

Cooling

Address cooling requirements, especially for prolonged low-speed operation. Consider auxiliary cooling.


Service Factor

Apply a service factor to the torque calculation.

WR2

Consider the impact of WR2 on acceleration time and VFD sizing.

Recommendation



Consult with Motor and VFD Manufacturers

Provide them with your operating requirements (speed, horsepower, torque, WR2) and ask for their recommendations on motor and VFD sizing. They can provide specific guidance based on their product characteristics.

Inverter-Duty Motor

ALWAYS use an inverter-duty motor for VFD applications. Standard motors are not designed for the stresses imposed by VFDs.


Err on the Side of Caution:
When in doubt, it's generally better to slightly oversize the motor (within reasonable limits) to ensure adequate torque and cooling, especially in demanding applications.By focusing on torque and considering the other factors mentioned above, you can ensure you select the right motor for your centrifugal fan application. Good luck! Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question