User: MyCleveland, Location: Cleveland, Ohio
Asked on: Tuesday, November 12, 2024 at 8:57 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:09 am EST
Question: Will try to describe some new work added to old work.I am NOT asking for direction on a repair, just looking to see if anyone has ran across this before.Typically suburban development...2011 ish. Owner removed device plates for painting.Two gang switch location, when plate was loosened the right switch and box came loose from the wall.Behind the two gang plate are TWO boxes...Left side, a single gang plastic nail on box fastened to a stud left of box.On the right is a metal single gang old work box cut in and attempted to Madison clamp it to the right side of the plastic box and the drywall to the right of the metal box.Appears this was added either after final or by previous homeowner to control a ceiling light.The left box contains a 3-way that controls a receptacle in room.I was amazed they were able to make this work...how did the plate line up?When the 3-way was put back into a new two gang box it was visibly shifted to the right. The mounting screw was inadvertently placed into an added opening.Visualize the mounting openings for the device mounting screws at top and bottom of a switch...approximately 1/4" wide slot allowing for some adjustment side-to-side.This installer, on the left switch, drilled a new hole for both mounting screws about an 1/16"-1/8" left of the slots.This must have pushed the left switch just far enough right to allow the face plate mounting holes to align.Appears the plate was really the only rigid attachment for the right box.
Okay, I understand what you're describing. You're essentially saying you found a very unusual and somewhat precarious situation: Original Setup
A single-gang plastic nail-on box with a 3-way switch controlling a receptacle.
"Modification"
A single-gang metal old-work box added next to the existing box, seemingly to control a ceiling light.
The Problem
The old-work box was attached poorly and relied on the faceplate for support.
The Kludge
The installer drilled new holes in the 3-way switch yoke (the metal frame) to shift it slightly so that the faceplate could be properly screwed into both switches, thereby holding the added box in place.
Yes, I can definitely imagine how this could happen. It's a textbook example of a "hack" or a "bodged" installation. Here's why it's believable and what makes it so concerning: Common Scenario
Adding a ceiling light to a room that didn't originally have one is a very common DIY project.
Easiest (But Wrong) Method
The easiest (and often cheapest) way to do this is to tap into existing wiring and use an old-work box.
Lack of Proper Planning
The installer likely didn't think about proper box support and alignment.
The "Make it Fit" Mentality
The installer focused on getting the faceplate on and likely didn't consider the long-term consequences of their method.
Faceplate as Structural Support
Relying on the faceplate for structural support is a major no-no, but unfortunately, not uncommon in amateur electrical work.
Drilling Device Yoke
Drilling the device yoke, even a tiny bit, shows a willingness to manipulate components outside of their intended design, which is unsafe.
Why it's a problem
Safety Hazard
The loose box and modified switch are a fire and shock hazard. Wires could become loose, causing arcing and potentially a fire.
Code Violation
This entire setup is likely against electrical codes.
Unreliable Connection
The reliance on the faceplate for support means the connections are more likely to loosen over time.
Difficult to Troubleshoot
Future electricians will have a hard time understanding what was done and troubleshooting any issues.
In Summary:
You've described a classic example of someone cutting corners and prioritizing a quick fix over safety and proper installation. While it's "amazing" in a "how did they even..." kind of way, it's definitely not good practice.Let me know if you have other questions. Flag for review