Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Derate question

User: DTP, Location: FL

Asked on: Wednesday, November 13, 2024 at 10:56 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:09 am EST

Question: I am installing a solar system that is 54 panels at 410w, it will be 22,140 kw. The fuses or breaker would be sized at 90A. The exterior electrical panel is a meter main combination that is 200A max with a 200A main breaker. It is impossible to perform a load side connection in this style meter main combo. There is currently a generator breaker in the panel and there is a generator interlock kit installed already. I am currently looking at a plan set that would have me performing a load side tap but I feel that is incorrect as we would need to ensure the system is not on when the generator is in use. The only way to do that would be for the homeowner to remember to shut the disconnect off prior to running their generator or installing the solar as a back fed breaker. I know I would need a different style interlock kit but my issue is the derate. In order to install it properly we would need to derate to 150A. My question is would I be able to derate from 200A to 150A? Also I forgot to mention yes there is a 200A sub panel inside their home.

You've accurately identified the potential issues and challenges with this solar installation and the generator interlock. Let's break down the problem and explore the best options

Understanding the Issues
Load-Side Tap with Generator

You're correct. A load-side tap in this situation is risky. Without a robust system to prevent simultaneous operation, the solar and generator could backfeed into each other, damaging equipment or creating a dangerous situation. Relying on homeowner action is not a safe solution.


Backfed Breaker and the 20% Rule (120% Rule)

This is the crux of your problem. The NEC limits the sum of the main breaker ampacity and the backfed breaker ampacity to no more than 120% of the service busbar ampacity.

Derate Concerns

Your concern about derating the main breaker to 150A is valid and requires careful consideration.

NEC Code Relevant to Your Situation
NEC 705.12(D) - Supply-Side Source Connection

This section is relevant if you were able to make a "supply side connection" which is defined as "a connection located on the supply side of the service disconnecting means". This is usually not possible with a meter main combination panel without replacing the entire panel.

NEC 705.12(B) - Load-Side Interconnections

This section is applicable because you're trying to connect on the load side of the main breaker. Subsections 705.12(B)(2) and 705.12(B)(3) are critical here. This is the "120% rule."


NEC 705.12(B)(3)(a) 120% Rule Calculation

This is the formula you'll use: `(1.2 Service Rating) >= (Main Breaker Rating + Solar Breaker Rating)`

NEC 690 (Solar Photovoltaic Systems)

Article 690 covers the specific requirements for solar PV systems, including conductor sizing, overcurrent protection, and disconnects.

NEC 702 (Optional Standby Systems)

Article 702 covers optional standby systems, which is the category generators fall into. It dictates transfer switch requirements.

Calculations and Feasibility


Let's use the 120% rule formula:
Service Rating: 200A Main Breaker Rating: 200A (Currently) Solar Breaker Rating: 90APlugging in the values:`(1.2 200A) >= (200A + 90A)``240A >= 290A`As you can see, the current configuration fails the 120% rule by 50 amps.

Options and Solutions

Here's a breakdown of possible solutions, along with their pros and cons:1. Derate the Main Breaker (and Potentially the Sub Panel)



Calculation

To meet the 120% rule, we need to solve for the main breaker rating:`(1.2 200A) >= (X + 90A)``240A >= X + 90A``X <= 150A`

Conclusion

Yes, you can derate the main breaker to 150A to comply with the 120% rule. You would replace the 200A main breaker with a 150A breaker.

Important Considerations



Load Calculation

A critical step is to perform a comprehensive load calculation on the entire house (including the subpanel). You must prove that the existing load, even with future anticipated load additions, will never exceed 150A. This is the biggest hurdle.

Subpanel Derating

If the load calculation indicates that derating the main to 150A would starve the subpanel for power, then you would need to evaluate derating the subpanel main breaker as well.


Homeowner Acceptance

The homeowner needs to understand that their total available power from the grid will be limited to 150A. Explain what this means in practical terms (e.g., running fewer high-draw appliances simultaneously). This also means that you should update any nameplates or documentation to reflect the change to the 150A rating.2.

Reduce the Solar Array Size

Reduce the size of the solar array to where the calculations meet the 120% rule. The formula would look like this:`(1.2 200A) >= (200A + X)``240A >= 200A + X``40A >= X`Therefore, if you were to retain the 200A main breaker, the solar breaker would need to be reduced to 40A.

Disadvantages

This would require a smaller solar system with less power generation.3.

Consider a different panel

A 200A service upgrade to either a 225A or 400A panel will either open up much more space for the solar breaker or provide a supply side tap option.

Recommendation
1. Perform a Detailed Load Calculation

This is the

first and most important step
. Without this, you cannot proceed safely.2. Evaluate Existing Generator Interlock

Examine the existing generator interlock kit. Can it be easily modified to include the solar breaker in the interlock logic? You need to ensure that the solar and generator cannot be on at the same time, regardless of human error.3.

Prioritize Derating vs. Reducing Array Size

If the load calculation is favorable,

derating the main breaker to 150A is likely the simplest and most cost-effective solution
, assuming you can also get a suitable interlock kit that includes the solar. If the load calculation is marginal or unfavorable, consider reducing the solar array size to meet the 120% rule without derating the main breaker.

Important Considerations Local Codes and AHJ

Always consult with your local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) before making any modifications. They may have specific requirements or interpretations of the NEC.


Professional Installation

This type of electrical work requires a licensed and qualified electrician.*

Documentation

Document all changes, calculations, and approvals. Provide clear instructions to the homeowner on the limitations of the system.

Disclaimer:
This information is for guidance only and should not be considered a substitute for professional electrical advice. You must consult with a qualified electrician and adhere to all applicable codes and regulations. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question