Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Failed motor

User: kwired, Location: NE Nebraska

Asked on: Wednesday, November 13, 2024 at 11:18 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:10 am EST

Question: Little while back got a call for a crop drying fan not working. Though I fixed up some other shoddy things in the process, none of those were the cause of motor failure. An internal cooling fan on the motor shaft happened to decide to come off the shaft and ended up crashing into and damaging motor windings.Not the first time I seen foreign material damage windings before but can't recall ever seeing such a fan come off the shaft without some external reason. I think welds simply gave up. I spread it open further than it was when I found it to get it past the bearing

That's a tough break, and you're right, it's unusual for an internal cooling fan to detach and cause such catastrophic damage. Here's a breakdown of potential causes and some things to consider going forward

Possible Causes of Internal Fan Detachment
Vibration

This is the most likely culprit. Over time, continuous vibration, especially if coupled with other factors, can weaken welds or other fastening methods.


Misalignment

Even slight misalignment of the motor or the driven equipment (the crop dryer) can introduce excessive vibration.

Imbalance

An unbalanced rotor or even an unbalanced fan itself can contribute to vibration.


Loose Mounts

Loose motor mounting bolts can amplify vibration.

Resonance

It's possible that the motor's operating frequency or harmonics thereof coincided with the natural frequency of the fan or its mounting, leading to accelerated fatigue.


Material Fatigue

Metal fatigue from constant stress, even at seemingly low levels, can eventually cause failure. This is more likely if the fan material or the welds were of poor quality.

Heat

Excessive heat, particularly cyclical heating and cooling, can stress the fan's welds and cause them to fail. This can be exacerbated if the motor wasn't adequately cooled due to clogged vents or high ambient temperatures.


Manufacturing Defect

While less common, it's possible that there was a flaw in the welding process or the fan material itself from the start. This could be a weak weld, porosity in the weld, or a flaw in the fan material.

Over-Speeding (Unlikely but Possible)

If the motor was subjected to over-voltage or some other condition that caused it to run faster than its rated speed, the centrifugal forces on the fan could have exceeded its design limits. However, this is less likely unless there was a clear problem with the electrical supply.


Contamination/Corrosion

Although less likely to directly cause the fan to come off, corrosion could weaken the weld joint over time.

Considerations and Preventative Measures



Motor Inspection

Thoroughly inspect the replacement motor. Look for:
Balance marks on the rotor, see if they exist, if they're still good and that nothing has been added or removed from the rotor. Proper ventilation. Make sure the motor's air inlets are clear. Check motor rating and that it matches application.

Mounting

Ensure the motor is securely mounted to a rigid base. Use appropriate mounting hardware and torque the bolts to the correct specification. Check that all bolts are secured on a routine basis.


Alignment

Carefully check the alignment between the motor and the crop dryer. Use laser alignment tools or dial indicators for accurate alignment. Re-check alignment periodically.

Vibration Analysis

If possible, consider performing a vibration analysis on the motor and the crop dryer while they are running. This can help identify any imbalances, misalignments, or other sources of vibration.


Operating Conditions

Ensure the motor is operating within its design parameters (voltage, current, temperature).

Airflow

Check for adequate airflow around the motor. Make sure the motor's cooling vents are not obstructed by dust, debris, or other obstructions.


Record Keeping

Keep a log of motor maintenance, inspections, and any repairs. This can help track the motor's performance and identify potential problems early on.

Voltage Monitoring

Monitoring voltage can give a clue to a failing power source.


Motor Protection

Make sure that motor is properly sized, and protected by properly sized overloads. Consider using a motor monitoring relay to detect overloads, undervoltage, overvoltage, or phase imbalance.*

Installation of external grease fittings to motor bearings

If motor bearings don't have fittings for grease, consider having them installed.

In summary, vibration is the most likely culprit. Addressing any vibration issues through alignment, balancing, and proper mounting is crucial to prevent a recurrence of this failure. Good luck with the repair!
Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question