User: tecorp, Location: SoCal
Asked on: Wednesday, November 13, 2024 at 5:43 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:10 am EST
Question: Hello,I am working on a project for a multi story multi family building. There are meter stacks for each individual unit. So current single line shows 208/120V service that is distributed to each meter, which then goes to each load center per unit. The proposed service voltage comes with a ton of voltage drop issues.I want to propose that we go to a 480/277V service so that these voltage drop issues are solved. However, I am unsure if this will be allowed by SCE since the new single line will become 480/277V service, then a step down transformer (I am guessing this is SCE owned), which is distributed to each meter, which then goes to each load center per unit.Again, the service is SoCal Edison.Just wondering if anyone had any input on this. I am looking at SCE's ESR and am not finding anything concrete.Thanks,te
You're right to question this and to check SCE's ESR. Switching to 480/277V is a common solution for voltage drop in multi-unit buildings, but there are several key considerations with SCE (Southern California Edison).Here's a breakdown of things to consider and the steps you should take
1. SCE's Position and ESR Review:
Direct Contact is Key
The best course of action is to contact SCE directly. Every service situation is slightly different, and talking to an SCE engineer or account representative is critical. They can give you definitive answers.
Review ESR Carefully (and Specifically the Relevant Sections)
You've started here, which is good. Pay close attention to:
Service Voltage Standards
Does SCE even offer 480/277V as a standard service voltage in your area, especially for residential or mixed-use buildings? This might be a limiting factor immediately.
Metering Requirements
How does SCE handle metering for multi-unit buildings at 480/277V? Are there specific meter types, enclosures, or connection requirements?
Transformer Ownership and Responsibility
This is a crucial question. Does SCE own and maintain the step-down transformer, or does that become your responsibility (and the building owner's)? This can significantly impact project costs and ongoing maintenance.
Specific Load Requirements
SCE may have specific load requirements or restrictions based on the type of building and the expected usage patterns.
Consider the "General Rules" Section
Many utility ESRs have a section outlining general rules and policies. These may address items like service size limits, restrictions on the number of meters, or specific situations that will dictate where the equipment (transformers, meters, etc.) are installed.
Don't Forget the "Red Book"
SCE also often references a "Red Book" or equivalent document. This document is a more detailed technical reference for service design and installations. Make sure you have access to this resource.
2. Key Questions for SCE
When you contact SCE, be prepared to ask these questions:
Service Voltage Availability
"Is 480/277V service available for a multi-unit residential (or mixed-use) building at [your address or general location]?"
Metering Configuration
"If 480/277V service is available, what is the standard metering configuration for individual units? Will SCE provide/own the step-down transformer? Will it be one large padmount, or individual units?"
Transformer Ownership and Responsibility
"If a step-down transformer is required, who owns and maintains it? What are the requirements for its location, enclosure, and accessibility?"
Metering Location
"Where does SCE require the meters to be located (relative to the transformer and the individual units)?"
Cost Considerations
"What are the estimated costs for SCE to provide 480/277V service, including any transformer installation or modifications to the existing infrastructure? Are there any customer contributions?"
Load Study Requirements
"Will a load study be required to determine the appropriate service size and transformer capacity?"
Protection Requirements
"What are SCE's specific requirements for overcurrent protection and grounding for a 480/277V service in this type of building?"
Coordination
"Who at SCE will be the primary point of contact for this project to coordinate engineering reviews and approvals?"
3. Code Considerations (NEC)
NEC 210.6: Branch-Circuit Voltage Limitations
Review this section carefully. While 277V is allowed for lighting and certain other loads, 120V receptacles are generally required in dwelling units. This reinforces the need for a step-down transformer.
NEC 230: Services
This article covers all aspects of service installations, including voltage ratings, overcurrent protection, and grounding.
NEC 408: Switchboards and Panelboards
Ensure that any panelboards you select are appropriately rated for the voltage and available fault current.
NEC 450: Transformers
This article covers the installation and protection of transformers.
4. Alternative Solutions (If 480/277V Isn't Feasible)
If SCE says that 480/277V isn't an option, or the costs are prohibitive, explore other solutions to mitigate the voltage drop:
Increase Conductor Size
This is the most common and often simplest solution. Carefully calculate the voltage drop using appropriate formulas and select larger conductors.
Parallel Conductors
Running conductors in parallel can reduce voltage drop and increase ampacity.
Separate Services
Consider breaking up the building into smaller sections, each with its own 208/120V service. This can be more expensive due to the increased number of service points.
Voltage Boosters
While less common, voltage boosters can be installed to compensate for voltage drop on specific circuits. These can be expensive.
Design Modifications
Can you reduce the length of the feeders by moving the meter stack closer to the service entrance? Can you redistribute loads to balance the phases more effectively?
Important Considerations for 480/277V
Safety
480/277V is a more dangerous voltage than 208/120V. Ensure that all electrical workers and building maintenance personnel are properly trained and qualified to work with this voltage.
Equipment Availability
While 277V lighting is readily available, you'll need to ensure that other equipment (e.g., HVAC, appliances) are compatible with the 277V system or can be adapted with step-down transformers.
Coordination
This project will require close coordination between the electrical engineer, the contractor, the building owner, and SCE.
In summary
Contact SCE Directly
This is the most important step.2.
Review SCE's ESR and Related Documents
Look for specific information related to 480/277V service for multi-unit buildings.3.
Prepare a Detailed List of Questions
Be specific about your project and the questions you need answered.4.
Explore Alternative Solutions: Be prepared to consider other options if 480/277V isn't feasible.Good luck! Let me know if you have any other questions. Flag for review