Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Raceway Fill

User: Cindysparky, Location: Milwaukee

Asked on: Wednesday, November 13, 2024 at 8:49 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:11 am EST

Question: So, I’ve got a question of opinion here. I’m working on this job and we are pulling all these switch legs out of a 277V lighting control panel. There’s more than just Swicth legs in the pipe. The pipe is comprised of say 2 different circuits, a couple all the time hots, and a bunch of swicth legs.Now, I did the Math and considered all of the switch legs current carrying. The Math says that you can fit all of these in the pipe and it’s all fine and well.My question is: if you have 1 circuit with all of these switch legs coming off of it, all sharing the same neutral in the pipe (clearly)… Doesn’t it seem like overkill to count them all as current carrying. If the circuit breaker is saying it’s only going to allow 20 amps… doesn’t it seem reasonable to count it once?My only thought was the potential to change it. Like how we count spares.

You've hit on a common point of debate in electrical work. While the code might technically allow it based on the math you've done, the practical implications and best practices often suggest a more conservative approach. Here's a breakdown of the considerations

Why You're Questioning It (and Why You Have a Point)
Circuit Breaker Protection

You're right, the circuit breaker is designed to protect against overcurrent on
that specific circuit. It doesn't care how many switch legs are connected to it, only the total current flowing back to the neutral on that circuit.

Parallel Paths

The neutral in the pipe is the common return for all the switch legs on that circuit. Theoretically, the current will distribute according to the impedance of each load.

Code Interpretation (Grey Area)

The code can be interpreted in different ways regarding switch legs. Some argue that because they carry current, they must be counted. Others argue that the total load is governed by the circuit breaker.

Why the Conservative Approach (Counting All Switch Legs) is Recommended
Future Changes

This is the KEY factor. You mentioned it, and it's what makes the conservative approach the most prudent.

Adding Loads

Imagine someone adds a load to one of those switch legs. Now, the neutral wire could be carrying a disproportionately larger current than originally calculated.


Circuit Modifications

Someone could repurpose a switch leg for a completely different purpose in the future, drastically altering the current flow.

Re-Balancing

The load on each switch leg can change over time, potentially increasing the load on the common neutral.


Overheating

Even if your calculations are perfect today, unforeseen changes can lead to excessive current on the neutral, causing it to overheat.

Safety Margin

The code is a
minimum safety standard. A conservative approach provides an extra layer of safety.

Good Practice/Professionalism

Following a conservative practice helps demonstrate a commitment to safety and quality work.

AHJ Interpretation

Some Authorities Having Jurisdiction (AHJs) may specifically require counting all switch legs as current-carrying conductors, regardless of the circuit breaker size.

What to Do
1. Consult the AHJ

This is the most important step. Ask your local inspector how they interpret the code regarding switch legs. Their opinion is the one that matters.2.

Err on the Side of Caution

If in doubt, it's generally better to count all the switch legs. It may require a larger conduit or derating the conductors, but it provides a greater margin of safety and reduces the risk of future problems.3.

Consider Alternatives



Separate Neutrals

If possible, consider running separate neutrals for each circuit, or at least for groups of circuits with distinct loads. This eliminates the common neutral issue.*

Homerun Each Switchleg

If possible it would be best to consider homering all the switch legs.4.

Document Everything

If you choose to count fewer conductors based on your calculations, document everything clearly, including your calculations, the specific code sections you're relying on, and any conversations you had with the AHJ. This will protect you in the future if any issues arise.5.

Consider the Lifetime Cost

While a smaller conduit might save money upfront, the potential cost of future problems, repairs, or even safety hazards far outweighs those savings.

In summary:
While the code might technically allow you to count the switch legs only once (or in some reduced capacity), the potential for future changes and the desire for a higher safety margin make the conservative approach of counting all switch legs as current-carrying conductors the recommended best practice. Always consult with your local AHJ to confirm their interpretation of the code. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question