User: JoeNorm, Location: WA
Asked on: Wednesday, November 13, 2024 at 11:07 pm EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:11 am EST
Question: If you have a single raceway with 120v as a "power in" and "power out" to a control board and back out to a motor, would you just run one neutral wire? I am having a brain meltdown on this one.
You would typically run one neutral wire for the entire circuit, if all the current flowing on the "power in" wires returns on the same neutral. Here's a breakdown of why and the key considerations
Understanding the Basic Principle
The neutral wire is the return path for the unbalanced current in a circuit. Ideally, in a perfectly balanced circuit (which is rare), the current flowing out on the hot (ungrounded) wires would perfectly equal the current flowing back on the neutral. In practice, there's almost always a small imbalance due to factors like slight differences in the load impedance, harmonic currents, and other non-linear loads.
Why One Neutral is Usually Sufficient
In your described scenario: Single Source
You're dealing with a single 120V source.
Serial Path
The power essentially flows in from the source to the control board, through the control board (which does some processing or switching), and then out to the motor. The motor current is ultimately derived from the initial 120V source.
Neutral Continuity
The neutral wire is essentially a single, continuous conductor that provides the return path from the source, through the components, and back to the source.
Therefore, all the current that leaves the source on the "power in" hot wire should be returning on the same single neutral wire.Important Considerations (When to Consider Multiple Neutrals or Oversizing)
Harmonic Currents
If the control board or, more likely, the motor is a non-linear load (e.g., contains electronic components like Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) or switching power supplies), it can generate harmonic currents. Harmonic currents, especially the 3rd harmonic, can add up arithmetically in the neutral conductor of a three-phase wye system (or in your single-phase case). In this scenario, you might need to oversize the neutral conductor or even consider a separate neutral if the harmonic content is high. A qualified electrician or electrical engineer can perform measurements to determine the harmonic content. Since you are on a single-phase, the harmonic currents will not sum up in the neutral; it will only carry the imbalance of current.2.
Voltage Drop
For long raceway runs, voltage drop can become a factor. While adding a second neutral can help reduce voltage drop by effectively paralleling conductors, it's generally more cost-effective and better practice to simply increase the size of the existing neutral and hot wires.3.
Code Requirements (NEC)
The National Electrical Code (NEC) provides specific guidance on neutral conductor sizing, especially for circuits with non-linear loads. Consult the NEC (specifically Article 220 and Article 310) to ensure compliance with local regulations. Your local electrical inspector is the final authority.4.
Specific Control Board/Motor Requirements
Always* check the manufacturer's documentation for the control board and motor. Some devices may have specific wiring recommendations that deviate from the typical practice. Pay particular attention to any instructions regarding grounding and bonding.5.
Shared Neutrals
Be cautious about using a shared neutral for multiple circuits unless it's specifically permitted and designed for that purpose. Sharing neutrals can lead to overloading the neutral conductor and potential safety hazards if not done correctly.
In your scenario, you are NOT sharing a neutral for multiple circuits. You only have one circuit.
In Summary
For a simple 120V "power in" to a control board and then "power out" to a motor, using
one properly sized neutral wire in the raceway is usually the correct and most economical approach. However, always verify that the neutral conductor is adequately sized for the expected load (including potential harmonic currents) and that you are complying with all applicable electrical codes and equipment manufacturer's instructions. When in doubt, consult with a qualified electrician. Flag for review