User: Ken Forest, Location: Knoxville
Asked on: Thursday, November 14, 2024 at 9:17 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:12 am EST
Question: we are reviewing a subcontract offer of 6 MW, MV system. The design they propose uses CAB Hanger, above ground DC and AC wiring to MV transformer skids.we met a field supervisor, saying he hates the CAB Hanger. I am trying to find some pros and cons to decide what's the best. if we can avoid tons of trench work in the wet cold days, to me, it's a win. can somebody explain what are the cons using this?Thanks
Okay, let's break down the pros and cons of using a Cable (CAB) Hanger system for a 6 MW, MV system with above-ground DC and AC wiring to MV transformer skids, especially considering your desire to minimize trench work in wet, cold conditions.
Understanding CAB Hanger Systems (Cable Tray Systems)
CAB hanger systems are essentially engineered support structures (usually made of steel or aluminum) designed to carry cables above ground. They come in various configurations: ladder type, ventilated trough, solid bottom, and wire mesh being common. They're suspended from existing structures (buildings, posts, etc.) or dedicated supports specifically installed for the system.
Pros of Using a CAB Hanger System for Your Application
Reduced Trenching and Excavation
This is the primary advantage, and it directly addresses your concern about avoiding extensive trench work in difficult weather. This translates to:
Cost Savings
Less excavation means less labor, equipment rental, backfill material, and site restoration costs.
Faster Installation
Above-ground installation is often significantly faster than trenching, especially in challenging soil conditions or congested sites.
Reduced Environmental Impact
Less disturbance to the ground means less environmental impact.
Less Weather Dependency
Installation is less affected by rain, snow, or frozen ground.
Improved Cable Accessibility and Maintenance
Easy Inspection
Cables are readily visible for routine inspections, making it easier to identify potential problems (damage, overheating, etc.).
Simplified Maintenance and Repairs
Troubleshooting, repairs, and replacements are much easier to perform on above-ground cables than buried cables.
Future Expansion and Modification
Adding or modifying cables in the future is much simpler with a cable tray system. You don't have to dig up the ground.
Cable Management
Organized Cable Routing
Cable trays provide a structured and organized way to route cables, preventing tangling and clutter.
Reduced Stress on Cables
Properly designed cable trays support the weight of the cables and prevent excessive bending or stress, extending cable life.
Potential for Improved Safety
Reduced Trip Hazards
Eliminates the need for open trenches during installation and maintenance.
Visible Cable Runs
Helps prevent accidental damage by construction equipment or other activities.
Easier Identification
Cables can be labeled easily.
Cons of Using a CAB Hanger System for Your Application
Aesthetics
Above-ground cable trays can be visually unappealing, especially in sensitive environments. This is a major consideration.
Cost (Potential)
While you save on trenching, the cost of the cable tray system itself (materials, supports, installation) can be significant, especially for a 6 MW system. Careful cost analysis is essential. Consider the following factors impacting price:
Material Costs
Steel and aluminum are prone to volatility.
Support Structure Requirements
The type and number of supports needed depend on the span lengths, cable weight, and environmental conditions (wind, snow load). Special supports (e.g., concrete piers) can significantly increase costs.
Engineering and Design
Proper engineering is crucial to ensure the cable tray system can handle the load and withstand environmental stresses. This also costs money.
Environmental Exposure
UV Degradation
Cables are exposed to sunlight, which can degrade insulation over time if the cables are not UV-resistant.
Weathering
Rain, snow, ice, and extreme temperatures can affect cable performance and longevity.
Corrosion
Salt spray (in coastal areas) or industrial pollutants can corrode cable trays and cable connectors. Proper material selection and corrosion protection are vital.
Space Requirements
Cable tray systems take up physical space, both horizontally and vertically. You need to ensure you have sufficient clearance and right-of-way.
Physical Protection
Above-ground cables are more vulnerable to physical damage from vehicles, vandalism, or falling objects.
Electromagnetic Interference (EMI)
While not always a major concern, the potential for EMI should be considered, especially with sensitive electronic equipment nearby. Grounding and shielding techniques may be required.
Wind Loading
Large cable tray runs can be subject to significant wind loads, requiring robust support structures.
Thermal Expansion/Contraction
Metal cable trays and cables will expand and contract with temperature changes. The design must accommodate this movement to prevent stress on the system.
Potential for Ice Accumulation
In cold climates, ice can accumulate on cable trays, adding significant weight and potentially causing structural damage. De-icing measures may be necessary.
Field Supervisor's Concerns
It's important to understand why the field supervisor dislikes the CAB Hanger system. Is it due to past experiences with poor design, difficult installation, maintenance problems, or something else? Their insights can be invaluable. Ask targeted questions: "What specific problems have you encountered with CAB Hanger systems in the past?" "What are your biggest concerns about using CAB Hanger systems for this project?" "Do you have any suggestions for alternative solutions?"
Key Considerations for Your Decision
Cost Analysis
Perform a thorough cost comparison between the cable tray system and buried cable, taking into account all factors mentioned above (materials, labor, trenching, supports, engineering, etc.).2.
Environmental Assessment
Evaluate the environmental conditions at the site (temperature extremes, humidity, salt spray, UV exposure, wind load, snow load, etc.) and select materials and designs that are appropriate.3.
Aesthetics
Consider the visual impact of the cable tray system and explore options for minimizing its obtrusiveness (e.g., using cable trays with covers, painting the trays to blend in with the surroundings).4.
Safety
Implement appropriate safety measures to protect the cable tray system from physical damage and to ensure the safety of workers during installation and maintenance.5.
Compliance
Ensure that the cable tray system meets all applicable codes and standards (e.g., National Electrical Code (NEC), local building codes).6.
Material Choice
Aluminum is often chosen for cost over steel. Aluminum can suffer corrosion where it comes into contact with steel or concrete if not properly isolated. This must be considered.
Recommendations
Talk to the Field Supervisor
Address the field supervisor's concerns directly. Understand the reasons for their dislike of CAB Hanger systems. Their experience could save you from making costly mistakes.
Engage a Qualified Engineer
Hire a qualified electrical engineer with experience in designing cable tray systems for MV applications. They can perform the necessary calculations and design the system to meet your specific requirements.
Get Multiple Bids
Obtain competitive bids from multiple cable tray manufacturers and installers.*
Visit Existing Installations
If possible, visit other sites where similar cable tray systems have been installed to see how they perform in the field.
In summary:
CAB Hanger systems offer significant advantages in terms of reduced trenching, improved accessibility, and simplified maintenance. However, they also have potential drawbacks in terms of aesthetics, cost, and environmental exposure. A careful cost analysis, environmental assessment, and consultation with a qualified engineer are essential to making an informed decision. Do not dismiss the field supervisor's concerns; they may have valuable insights that can save you time and money. Flag for review