Mike Dolt Enterprises Logo Mike Dolt Enterprises

Topic: Understanding 250.184 and 250.186

User: philly

Asked on: Thursday, November 14, 2024 at 11:33 am EST
Answered on: Thursday, March 6, 2025 at 5:12 am EST

Question: I wanted to better understand requirements of 250.184 and 250.186 (2023 NEC) using the attached example of MV system. In this example the customer (distributed generation site) is interconnecting with 24.9kV utility distribution line which has a multipoint grounded neutral ran with distribution.This neutral comes into the site as part of a concentric cable neutral with UG distribution feeders and then transition to an overhead ASCR type neutral as the UG feeders come up a riser pole and transition to overhead. I've illustrated on drawing where feeders and neutral transition from UG to OH cable for context.I was hoping someone with familiarity with sections could help clarify a few questions:1) In looking at 250.186 I would consider this service one with a grounded conductor (neutral) at service point and thus fall under requirements of 250.186(A). This section requires that this grounded conductor be installed and routed to the first service disconnect which in this case will be the switch, and the grounded conductor will be routed be connecting incoming cable concentric neutrals to OH ASCR neutral for routing to switch. This section requires that this grounded conductor to switches grounded conductor terminal or bus with a bonding jumper between the grounded conductor and enclosure. Given that a switch typically does not have a "grounded bus" or maybe not even a specific grounding point at all would we just carry the neutral over with a bonding jumper between OH neutral line and switch frame?2) Since this neutral will be carried all the way to the transformer I would consider this a solidly grounded neutral system which falls under 250.184. Seeing that this is also a multi-grounded neutral system I would say that this would specifically fall under 250.184(C). If that is the case then after the neutral is initally bonded to first disconnect (switch) as described in #1 above would this neutral just be able to continue to run all the way to transformer wye point with bonding to ground along the way at locations required by 250.184(C) and shown on drawing? I'm assuming the cable concentric neutral would be allowed to serve as this neutral if its a 1/3 concentric neutral?3) Is there technically a requirement for an Equipment Ground Conductor (EGC) between switch and recloser, and between recloser and transformer like there would be on an LV system after first disconnecting means? The multipoint grounding is throwing that off a bit for me. If required would the concentric neutral be able to double as both a neutral and EGC?4) On the LV detla side of transformer what would the ground conductor between transformer and first disconnect means downstream be considered. To me these would be an EGC given that the neutral is derived by seperate grounding transformer. I'm used to LV application with wye secondary where SSBJ is ran between transformer and first disconnecting means downstream.

Okay, let's break down those NEC 2023 requirements in 250.184 and 250.186 for your distributed generation site interconnected with the utility's 24.9kV multi-grounded neutral system.

Assumptions & Context You're asking about NEC 2023. You're using a multi-grounded neutral (MGN) system from the utility. You have a 24.9kV to LV transformer on your site. You want to understand bonding and grounding requirements at the service point, switch, recloser, transformer, and low-voltage side. Service disconnect (switch) and overcurrent protective device (recloser) are included.

Answers to Your Questions1. 250.186(A) - Grounded Conductor at Service Point
Correct, this scenario falls under 250.186(A). You're right, the grounded conductor (neutral) from the utility must be brought to the first service disconnecting means (the switch). Regarding bonding at the switch

Since your switch likely doesn't have a dedicated "grounded bus," your approach is correct. The neutral conductor (utility neutral) is carried to the switch location. Here's the nuance:

Bonding Jumper

You
must install a bonding jumper from the utility neutral conductor to the switch enclosure/frame. The NEC requires this.

Purpose

This bonding jumper ensures that the switch enclosure is at the same potential as the utility neutral.

Practical Implementation

This is typically done with a conductor sized according to 250.186(A) which refers you to table 250.
66.2.


250.184(C) - Multi-Grounded Neutral System
Correct, you're dealing with a solidly grounded, multi-grounded neutral system, making 250.184(C) relevant. Neutral Run to Transformer

After the initial bonding at the switch as described in #1, you're generally correct. The neutral can continue to the transformer wye point.

250.184(C) Grounding Electrode System connections along run

The neutral is to be connected to a grounding electrode system that is grounded in accordance with 250.50.

Concentric Neutral as Neutral

A 1/3 concentric neutral conductor is generally acceptable as the grounded conductor. This may be a decision based on your design criteria, not solely NEC requirements. Your AHJ can also weigh in on this.


Important Considerations Regarding Grounding Electrode System and Grounding Impedance



250.184(C)(1)

The transformer neutral point must be connected to a grounding electrode system meeting the requirements of 250.50. This typically involves ground rods, building steel (if qualified), etc. It is NOT acceptable to bond to a metal water pipe without supplemental grounding electrodes.


250.184(A) Grounding Impedance

250.184(A) also may be relevant, since it notes that "Where solid grounding is used, the grounding impedance shall be limited to the impedance of the grounding electrode system."

250.190 Grounding Impedance

If you use a grounding impedance rather than a solid connection, this section would apply.3.

EGC Between Switch, Recloser, and Transformer
Here's where it gets tricky with multi-grounded systems



Generally, yes,
an EGC (equipment grounding conductor) is required between the switch, recloser, and transformer, in addition to the neutral. The purpose of an EGC is to provide a low-impedance path back to the source in case of a ground fault. NEC 250.4(A)(5) requires equipment likely to become energized to be connected to an effective ground fault current path. 250.4(A)(3) and 250.4(A)(4) describes the performance of that effective ground fault current path. Why an EGC is still needed

The MGN
helps limit voltage rise during a fault, but the EGC provides a more dedicated fault current path, especially for equipment enclosures. Relying solely on the MGN for equipment grounding can lead to higher touch potentials and slower fault clearing.

Concentric Neutral as EGC

The concentric neutral can serve as the EGC if it meets the requirements of 250.118 and 250.122 (sizing, continuous path, etc.). Often, this is the most practical approach, however you need to VERIFY.

Practical Considerations

In many MV installations, the concentric neutral of the cable
is sized to act as both the neutral and the EGC. However, confirm that the sizing meets both the neutral current carrying capacity and the ground fault current requirements.

Separate EGC

If the concentric neutral doesn't meet the sizing or other requirements of an EGC, you will need to run a separate dedicated EGC.4.

Low-Voltage (Delta) Side Grounding
Correct, on the delta secondary, the conductor between the transformer and the first disconnecting means is an Equipment Grounding Conductor (EGC). Derived Neutral

You create a neutral point using a separately derived system such as a zig-zag grounding transformer on the delta secondary. This is NOT a continuation of the utility MGN.

Delta Secondary Grounding Requirements



250.20

Generally speaking, delta systems are required to be grounded in a manner pursuant to 250.21 or 250.
30.


EGC from Transformer to Disconnect

The EGC, sized according to 250.122, is used to bond the transformer enclosure and the enclosure of the first disconnecting means downstream of the transformer.


System Bonding Jumper (SBJ)

A System Bonding Jumper (SBJ) connects the derived neutral (from the zig-zag transformer) to the equipment grounding conductor system at a single point, typically at the source of the separately derived system (i.e., the grounding transformer). The size is according to 250.28.

Grounding Electrode Conductor (GEC)

The derived neutral point is connected to a grounding electrode (ground rod, etc.) via a grounding electrode conductor (GEC), sized per 250.66.

Key Takeaways and Recommendations
Consult with the Utility

Crucially, coordinate your grounding design with the utility company. They may have specific requirements for interconnecting with their multi-grounded neutral system.

Bonding is Critical

Pay close attention to proper bonding at the switch, recloser, and transformer locations.


Fault Current Study

Perform a fault current study to ensure that your grounding and bonding system is adequate for the available fault current. This will determine the appropriate size for your bonding jumpers and EGCs.

250.50 - Grounding Electrode System

Ensure that the transformer neutral point is connected to a proper grounding electrode system per 250.50.


AHJ Review

Submit your design to the Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ) for review and approval. They will have the final say on whether your design meets the NEC and local requirements.*

Document Your Design:
Thoroughly document your grounding and bonding system design on your drawings.This information is for educational purposes only and not professional engineering advice. You should consult with a qualified electrical engineer for your specific project. Always comply with the latest edition of the NEC and local codes. Flag for review

Previous Question Next Question